Well this is the first time I have ever heard of Shrinky. I don't collect these but I have a few. My first question for you would be did you ask her if the horse had any odors prior to buying? I usually alert sellers that a product they sold me did not smell good if they didn't mention it..especially with smoke as it makes me so ill. I know if I sold a Breyer and it smelled funny, I would mention that even if I didn't know what it was. I have learned though even when you ask if something stinks you can still sometimes end up with a stinky.