I don't have my breyer value book with me but I'm guessing that's just about right for the given economy. A broken tail would greatly deppreciate the value as would broken off ears. However, if you're just after the horse, somebody has it listed as #3095 appaloosa performance horse for $25 on ebay. There's another one for $37 listed as appaloosa roan. You could snag a single horse and if you really want that ugly Breyer doll you could snag her seperately.