The Unloved Ones....

[VanillaBean]

Is it just me, or is Banana Surprise the most unloved G1 ever? I seem to see nothing but a lot of hate for her. That makes me sad... she's cute.

I think Banana Surprise is absolutely adorable, the poor girl needs more love! 

[Princess-Sparkles]

Oh, another one from the Twinkle eyed set..

Popular: Brighteyes
Unpopular: Speedy

Late input is late.  Speedy may not be popular, but darn it I'd kill for her now. She was my second fave pony growing up, but got lost with all my other ponies in a move.

Aww. Sorry you lost her in a move. I'm glad someone loves her.

[scarletjul]

So sad that ponies are unloved!

 How about the BBE babies? No one loves them (except me)!

I did'nt like them until I got a BEAUTIFUL baby Lofty from a swap. I just melted at her blue eyes <3

Mountain Boy Ponies:
Popular: Ice Crystal and Sunburst
Unpopular: Lightening

Well.. I guess none of the MB's are really unpopular, But I think some are just more popular that the others.

Sweetberry ponies:
Popular: Blueberry Baskets and Strawberry Surprise
Unpopular: Cherry Treats, maybe because it's hard to find a white one?

And another pony that does'nt get the love she deserves: Pony Bride, really, she's a bride! What's not to love? <3

I am still searching for a Cherry Treats; I love her bright red hair and she's in my favorite pose.  I'm not so picky on her being a true white but I do want her to still be scented. 

I don't think Pony Bride or Bridal Beauty are popular though.

[Shenanigans]

The Dance N Prance and ballet ponies seem to be unloved. I had a DNP pony when I was little and she used to scare me :p

Of the baby ponies and pretty pals:

Loved: Baby Lucky Leaf and Leafy
Unloved: Baby Fleecy and Woolly

I have two Fleecy's and and two Wooly's and would trade them for Lucky Leaf in a heartbeat

[hathorcat]

The Dance N Prance and ballet ponies seem to be unloved. I had a DNP pony when I was little and she used to scare me :p

Of the baby ponies and pretty pals:

Loved: Baby Lucky Leaf and Leafy
Unloved: Baby Fleecy and Woolly

I have two Fleecy's and and two Wooly's and would trade them for Lucky Leaf in a heartbeat

Ooooh...thats a good one! Fleecy is so overlooked!!!

[PrincessNikki]

In my herd, Drummer was the most popular among the baby ponies.

[Lon-san]

Banana Surprise is cute and I like her a lot more than Crunch Berry. But those 3D symbols? Eee....

[lovesbabysquirmy]

The Drink n ' Wet Babies... in general...

[toralei]

I think Cloud Puff is pretty unpopular for a flutter pony.... or maybe just uncommon?

[Catlein]

Aww... poor Drummer. WHY SO UNLOVED! He was my absolute favourite pony when I was young...

Maybe his lighter hair makes him stand out less? I'd love to get a second rehaired in bright orange!

As for some others... Rockin Beat Ponies
Loved: Tuneful
Not so Loved: Half Note

[SkyCakes]

I think Cloud Puff is pretty unpopular for a flutter pony.... or maybe just uncommon?

I think maybe because of her regrind issues that she has that makes her less popular? I am not sure.

[Starbright]

A couple, just imho-

So Softs:
Most loved...hard to say actually! Maybe Wind Whistler? Crumpet is probably most valuable.
Least: Scrumptious. I never see anybody talk about her. Twist is pretty rare too.

Taf, first set
Most: Dancing butterflies
Least: Sweet Tooth

I can understand because she's a weird color combination. She's a childhood pony for me.

Merriweather is my fave of the 2nd set!
     

[terabithianprince]

All the ones people say are unpopular are the ones that I love the most or are in my collection. I love the BBE ponies now(I didn't at first) I'm probably too new to judge what is popular and what isn't though.

[Zest]

So sad that ponies are unloved!

 How about the BBE babies? No one loves them (except me)!

I did'nt like them until I got a BEAUTIFUL baby Lofty from a swap. I just melted at her blue eyes <3

Mountain Boy Ponies:
Popular: Ice Crystal and Sunburst
Unpopular: Lightening

Well.. I guess none of the MB's are really unpopular, But I think some are just more popular that the others.

Sweetberry ponies:
Popular: Blueberry Baskets and Strawberry Surprise
Unpopular: Cherry Treats, maybe because it's hard to find a white one?

And another pony that does'nt get the love she deserves: Pony Bride, really, she's a bride! What's not to love? <3

Aww! How can Lightning be unpopular! x) I love Lightning, he and Sunburst were my first two Mountain Boys.
That said I adore all Big Brothers and Mountain Boys. x)

Personally from what I've seen, I feel like for Perfume Puffs:

Popular: Red Roses (oh gosh I need her, too!)
Unpopular: Daisy Sweet

I feel like this only because it seems so hard to find a Daisy Sweet that doesn't have a color mismatched head/body, which can look fairly unattractive. Or is it just me and having horrible luck with Daisy Sweet?

[LadyMoondancer]

I love this thread!


Popular: Baby Lucky Leaf
Unpopular:  Baby Fleecy


Sorry, Baby Fleecy, but gold trumps pink.


Popular:  Little Dipper
Less Popular: the other ones


Popular:  Sea Mist and Whitecap
Unpopular: Sand Dollar


Well, actually ALL the Year 3 sea ponies are pretty popular, but Sea Mist and Whitecap definitely dominate the set in terms of popularity!  And I never hear much about Sand Dollar.