Who's Your Favorite G1 Christmas Pony?

[Leave a Whisper]

None are my favorites as I think many of the G3 winter ponies do the concept better, but I can't help liking Merry Treats best. She should be tacky with that Santa symbol, but there's something endearing and nostalgic about her and her candy cane colors are so pretty. Baby Stockings and Felicidades are cute too.

[BlackCurtains]

I agree, about the G3s and Merry Treats.

[SkyCakes]

I would say baby stockings and merry treats. I dont mind the G3s holiday themed but im glad there are a few G1 that could be seasonal too.

[Harmonie]

I own Merry Treats, but think I like Felicidades just a little bit more. =)

Definitely agree, G3 hits it out of the park with Christmas ponies. I adore Candy Cane and always will.

[lovesbabysquirmy]

none of them really but i like baby ponies!

[SunPony]

I like all of them!  I think baby Stockings is my favorite, though. 

[Heart Of Midnight]

Merry Treats! 

[Ponybookworm]

Merry Treat by a landslide!!!
I do like Felicidades but firstly there's her name & wondering if I've spelt it correctly. Then there is the fact she's much harder to find than the other three.
I do like Baby Stockings & her bright red hair.
Least fave G1 Festive Pony is Stockings due to being Little Tot's twin in pretty much every way except symbol, not to mention TWELVE other Ponies in the same pose with the same colour scheme. Like what's wrong with giving her red hair???

On other notes I Customised a set of four Festive Ponies: Xmas Angel, Xmas Cracker, Xmas Pudding, & Xmas Tree. I also love the HQG1C Festive Ponies: Jolly Dasher/ Dasher/ Jolly Treat, Baby Candy Cane, & Little Holly.

The G3 Winter Ponies & winter Babies did an awesome job at making winter Ponies, & I also have G2s Snowball & Baby Sweet Snowflake. I Customised Gingersnap to be an older sibling to Baby Sweet Snowflake.

G4 was so disappointing with only Snowcatcher anywhere near a wintery theme, & no special Hearth's Warming Pony, I took a spare Pinky Pie & Customised her into Hearth Warmer specially!!!

Last but not least I think Snowflake & Powder deserve a shout-out here.

[Taffeta]

Yes to Snowflake and Powder. I need to dig out my Snowflake as Pony Christmas cutout scan again

Merry Treats, otherwise. The only one we legitimately had I finally nailed down her card.

G3 did have better winter ponies, but sucked because they were none of them in the UK. I resent store exclusives xD.

I have some pics somewhere of Snowcatcher playing in the snow. I got her right before we had a lot of snow some years back, and my sister and I went out for a walk. I had Snowcatcher with me and she had an Applejack, I think. We took a lot of photo of them on the route. We are both very grown up people over 30 >.>

[SkyCakes]

Hmm I was thinking I think I missed windy or summer wing Flurry. She would be the perfect fairy snow pony.

[Ponybookworm]

Hmm I was thinking I think I missed windy or summer wing Flurry. She would be the perfect fairy snow pony.

Bummer, me too!!! I even had her bringing in the snow in a wintery story!!!