Peachy?

[icecreamgirl]

I seem to get a lot of Peachy too and also Posey she seems to be in every lot I buy!

[LittleHoneyPie]

I forgot to add Baby Tiddlywinks!!!

[DalaPony]

I seem to get a lot of Peachy too and also Posey she seems to be in every lot I buy!

I nearly forgot about her, but yeah eBay seems be full of Poseys!

cyberunicorn, I'd buy a Cherries Jubilee, she's such a beautiful pony, one of my favourites! 

[invaderhorizongreen]

melody keeps finding me , I have my fixed one, one I sent in a swap box, and now a long hair one.

[himmie]

Firefly and SS Magic Star... I have at least six of each, most of which were found locally. Blah.

[MoondancerMilkyWay]

I'll take your SS Magic Star Himmie!!

[hathorcat]

In population numbers Peachy is easily the Pinkie Pie of G1 However I do agree the other early playset ponies such as Baby Cuddles and Lemon Drop can be equally as populous.

[Sarah-Bee]

I always always get Peachys in the lots I buy! Along with Lemondrop, Lickety Split, Tootsie, Cherries Jubilee and Posey. I current have SIX Poseys for sale on ebay and another three to list

[Gizmo]

The most common for me would be:

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

[Mermaid]

I think there are tons of peachy due to the fact that she came with the first relatively cheap play set. And one that realllly appealed to little girls. The castle is dreamy but was big and expensive, the show stable was cute, but not a ton of fun and again expensive. The pretty parlour was the first playset aimed at beautification of the ponies. And well as you know, we looooved (still do) brushin some ponies! The price point was also really good! If I recall I think it was priced at around $15? Maybe $20?

Here's a list of ponies I've put together that at any given time there are at least 5 on ebay:
Glory
Moondancer
Posey
Firefly
Skydancer
Bow tie
Cherries jubilee
Lemon drop
Majesty
Lickity split
Starshine
Windy
Parasol
Masquerade
Fizzy
Ss North Star
Pony bride
Cotton candy
Baby stockings
Rose dust
Sprinkles
Sunbeam
milkweed and tumbleweed
Dibbles and nibbles
Sniffles and snookums
Baby shaggy
Sundance
Baby tappy
Baby moondancer
Baby surprise
Apple jack
Shs spring song
Shs flower burst
Mgr flower bouquet
Pina colada
Dancing butterflies
Steamer
Daddy bright bouquet
Mommy sweet celebrations
Bubbles
Banana surprise
Sherbet
Twilight
Taf fifi
Blue bell
Princess primrose
Baby glory
Baby tiddlywinks
Baby cuddles
Bbe baby half note
Medly
Sugar berry
Baby sea pony sea shimmer
Baby sea pony celebrate
Flutter yum yum
Party time
Blossom
Bng bouquet
Beach ball
Baby tic tac toe
Zig zag
G2 morning glory

[Ivy]

The Pretty Parlor & Peachy was also available for a number of years and through lots of mail offers. It's a very common playset.

I usually give away any extra Peachy's I have - almost all my cousins and 2nd cousins have gotten at least a Peachy from me to start their pony collections. I have a ton of Sundance too - but that's just because I tend to use her to display ponywear.

[Rainfeather]

Aaaargh I drown in Italian peachys.

She came with the pretty parlour over here. But I still think she was being sold seperately too. Or something.
There are sooooo many of them, and not as many pretty parlours...