This is kind of a mishmash triumvirate of a list. If you're looking for extras I like fun Duck Tape, pony hair, Princess stickers for the baby, and red licorice. As for ponies, I'll start with the minty ones. These are Grails. They are the ones I most want but even the ones I want minty are acceptable in any condition.
Mint
Bowtie (all poses)
Italy Tootsie
Sugarberry
P. Royal Pink
Munchy
baby Pearly (fancy mermaid)
Twilight
NBBE Cuddles
Blossom (adult)
Either
Bubbles (sitting)
Seashell (sitting)
Bridal Beauty
Mex. Moondancer
baby Mex. Moondancer
Gingerbread
Sweetstuff
Medley
Starshine
Italy Majesty
[any seapony]
[any summer/windy wing, any condition]
Cool Breeze
[Nirvana Boys]
Spain Tex's hat
US Slugger's bandanna
any baby bro bandannas
Tux N' Tail's bow tie
Baby Buttons
Prince Firefly
Prince Fauna
Prince Blue Dream
Baity
Bride
Sunbeam
Gusty
US Moondancer
Glory
[US boys]
Tex
Baby Moondancer
Baby Glory
BBE baby Gusty
Prince Clever Clover