127 minis/blind bags
34 brushables
(2 big princesses, 1 little princess, 6 fillies, 1 crystal motion, 11 unicorns, 6 pegasi, 7 earth)
3 fashion size
(1 earth, 1 pegasus, 1 unicorn)
6 official plushies
2 McDonald's ponies
1 design-a-pony
For a total of 176 ponies. (38, not including plushies and minis.)
I also have a fanmade plushie, and two custom brushies.