I voted for Buttons, but I like Bangles more, if that makes sense.
![Tongue :P](https://mlparena.com/Smileys/default/tongue1.gif)
I don't like Buttons' pose, and I never liked her character on the show either. However, Bangles, despite being in one of my favourite poses and the fact that I like her symbol much more that Buttons', always looks so off to me. Clear-ish and "fleshy", almost like a fakie. Buttons looks more solid.