How cool! $5 per pony is pretty good, though less is always ideal.
Glad you could settle on a decent price, at least. Cranberry Muffins is beautiful! The rest are great, too. And there's some great accessories -- Megan's shoes (light purple, so maybe they're her nightgown 'slippers'?), Wavedancer's shell, Sea Shimmer's float, a princess wand -- very nice! Maybe the buggy has knobs on the top to hold the lace on? Just a stab in the dark, but maybe when it had BBE Cuddles they modified it like that because the old ridge for the lace didn't do well enough. Looks like BBE Cuddles is in the lot.