Help with Accessory Trade?

[silverdawn]

Hey all!

I'm hoping I can get some opinions on what would be a fair trade.  Everything the other party would like to have is in this picture.

visitors can't see pics , please register or login


(Better picture of slumber accessories, cookies label and record sleeve slightly worn)

visitors can't see pics , please register or login


BBE Cuddles is in great shape with just a tiny bit of rust on one eye lid, and a bit of symbol bleed.  Everything else is as follows

-Sleep Over accessories
-Purple & Pink Bassinet
-BBE Baby Cuddles
-2 PE Flowers
-2 leg warmers or Bonnet School (not the fuzzy ones that go to Prima Ballerinas, more like the adult ones that go to Flashprance)
-PE Table leg
-Lavender lollipop barrette
-2 Towels for Perm Shoppe
-2 hanging lights for Perm Shoppe

What the other party has that I would like is

Skydancer German Variant

She is pretty much perfect. I couldn't point out anything. She may have been a little brighter when she was new, but I can't be sure since my other one is the same shade of yellow.

Baby Buttons

She is very light, could be faded a little, but I can't see any discolorations. Symbols are fine, hair is perfect.

Love Story

Pretty with kind of dry hair, otherwise nothing to point out.

Bon Bon

I love her, but be aware that I restored her symbols. They had major rubs and are repainted be me. You wouldn't notice, but I have to tell you that.
My other one doesn't look better even she has intact symbols, but I had to decide wich one to keep since you are asking for 7 Tales Ponies.

Obviously I don't have enough to trade for all 4 ponies, lol.  The one I'd most like to trade for would be Baby Buttons.  But is that fair?  What would be fair? I'm looking for any opinions as I don't want either of us to lose out!  Thanks so much for all your help!

Silverdawn

[hathorcat]

Accessory value can a little be in the eye of the beholder and what someone considers valuable another may simply see as a bit of plastic clogging up their trade box.

I would say its a little tight but for an accessory collector yes I am sure the trade for a Baby Buttons against all those accessories shown would be fair to both parties.