Is this a fair price?

[faeriesblood]

Hi  I'm thinking of selling my small collection. I have about 65 ponies G1-G4. I'm hoping to get about $230 for the lot. Do you think this is a fair price? All are mint or near mint unless otherwise stated. Please let me know what you think.

G1
Seastar (spot under hair)
Cotton Candy Plush
Baby Moondancer
TAF Sugarberry
Baby Toe Dancer
SS Wind Whistler (need deflocking)

G2
McDonald’s Ivy x 2
McDonald’s Silver Swirl (some frizz)
McDonald’s Light Heart
McDonald’s Sunsparkle

G3
Rainbow Swirl II
Forsythia
Periwinkle
Love Wishes
Cloud Climber
Pinkie Pie V
Heart Bright (with crown)
2002 Minty w/ charm
Cotton Candy w/ charm
Morning Glory
Butterscotch
Sunny Daze V
Star Flight (with crown)
Fabric Wings Star Catcher
Flutter Butter
Love-A-Belle
Bowtie
Alphabittle
Sweetsong
Aurora Mist
Sunrise Song
Dazzle Surprise
MIB Royal Bouquet
MIB Strawberry Surprise
MIB Party Cake
MIB Pretty Pop
MIB Triple Treat
MIB Cupcake
MIB Breezies Parade
MIB Butter Pop
Styling size Rarity
McDonald’s Butterscotch (loose
McDonald’s Daisy Joe loose
McDonald’s Minty loose
McDonald’s Pinky Pie loose
McDonald’s Ponyville Minty
MIP McDonald’s Scootaloo (25th Birthday Celebration)
MIP McDonald’s Minty (25th Birthday Celebration)


G3.5
MIP McDonald’s Sweetie Belle
MIP McDonald’s Scootaloo
MIP McDonald's Rainbow Dash

G4
FS Pinkie Pie (cupcake version)
Talking Princess Celestia (white)
MIB Target Exclusive Crystal Rainbow Collection
Fluttershy with bunny friend and accessories
Glimmer Wings Diamond Rose and Pinkie Pie
BB Cherry Spices
BB Lilac Links
BB Royal Riff
BB Chance-A-Lot
BB Flower Wishes
BB Sugar Grape
BB Amethyst Star
BB Twilight Sparkle

[Cherry_Sunset]

In my opinion, that sounds like a fair price to me! I'm not much of an expert on earlier ponies, but for your G4's, you have a few more sought out ones! Good luck selling your collection if you do decide to do so

[faeriesblood]

Thank you very much!! 

[hathorcat]

Are you planning on selling individually. Unfortunately as a lot I think that total would be more than you will find someone willing to pay for a majority g3 lot plus shipping.

However if you are splitting things out and if you are happy to hold out for set prices then yes you should manage that total with those ponies. Just be prepared that you may need to do some offers on the common g3s.

Good luck with your sales and I am sorry you are selling your collection, will you be keeping at least 1 or 2 of your favourites?

[faeriesblood]

Thanks for the input! Yes, I'll be keeping my two minty plushes