The MLP Arena
Pony Talk => Pony Corral => Topic started by: LordBlumiere on November 08, 2022, 07:56:21 PM
-
I was always under the impression Mochanut and Dance Around weren't quite babies, but not quite adult ponies either... but My Little Wiki seems to think otherwise! They have unique non-baby poses, don't have the 'baby' before their name most baby ponies do in their generation, and again, are pretty well otherwise unique to the babies. What's your opinion? (Wish I could ask someone who worked at Hasbro during G3!! :lol:)
-
I thought of them as tweens. :) I just corrected the page actually, since it kept reporting Honolu-loo was the only baby pegasus, but it sounds like that wasn't true. It's hard to tell. I think to the layperson, they'd both be babies.
-
I sort of consider them the first tooth era of baby. Able to babysit new born twins but young enough not to be an adult, like the G1 cartoon depicted.
-
To me they seem like they would be maybe like 9,10,11 in human years, haha :)
The term 'baby' pony as used in G1 and G3 by Hasbro is actually quite wrong, right? Because the 'baby ponies' are more like elementary school aged kids. But, only after Hasbro made these G1 'kid ponies' and named them 'babies' they came up with even smaller ones.
'Newborns' who are more like actual babies/toddlers, and 'Teeny Tiny ponies' who are more like actual newborns.
So the naming was kind of lagging behind all the time :')
(EDITED because I wrote primary school where I meant elementary school, mistake because I'm not from US)
-
Looking at the box artwork on the sets, they seem like older children. Also I think there is mention that the ponies are siblings not parent and child?
There's not a lot of box art to compare it with the regular G3 babies since a lot of them were sold with adult ponies or playsets, and didn't get their own little description on the back.
Which is a shame because I love knowing a bit about the pony's personality/hobbies !
-
They're babies because they're on baby poses and proportions. Too young to be like SHS.
-
I always just thought of those two as "little sister ponies". :B
-
I cannot help but interpret all of the G3 baby ponies as young children rather than babies, but these two are maybe a little older. (The average baby pony is maybe 4-7, these are perhaps 8-11, or whatever the pony equivalent is).
-
Yep, my G1 Babies are in primary 1-4 or elementary school, with the G3 Babies a bit younger. These two would be a bit older, just starting middle school or primary 5-6, alongside the G2s, Dabble & Scribbles, & the HQG1C wingless flutters.
They were definitely sold as sister sets, with the smaller Ponies being younger sisters to the older ones. All my G3 "adults" are high school/ college age (secondary 3-6 & college/uni). But that's just how I make my Ponyworld
-
They're 'tweens' in my mind - if regular G3 babies are like 4-6 I imagine Mochanut and Dance around are like 10-12ish?
-
i guess the “Baby X” moniker started in G1. Even in G1 i wouldn’t say the size and shape of “Babies” are actual baby ponies size, more like “Yearling”? Baby Applejack is a bit easier to say than “Kid Applejack”, “Applejack Jr”, “Yearling Applejack” or “Applejackette”? so i see why they went with Baby. i bet they didn’t imagine they’d be going to newborns or teeny tinys some day!
anyways i love MLP “Babies” no matter the gen. but i love the G1 Twins the. very. most.
personally i call my Honolulu , Baby Honolulu because of her size but that’s just me.
-
To me "baby ponies" aren't literal infants, they're more like young kids. So yeah, I would count those two as baby ponies.
If you look at real horses, they can do so much more than a human baby, like running through a field the day they're born. So I guess it makes sense that a "baby" pony has the ability to reason and talk very early on. Even in the backcard stories of the Newborn Twins, they can talk and a lot of times are wandering around on their own.
-
They are their own unique class of "little sister."
G1 had a ton of subcategories under the umbrella of "baby pony." From just baby to newborn to teeny tiny newborn.
To me "baby ponies" aren't literal infants, they're more like young kids. So yeah, I would count those two as baby ponies.
Exactly how I feel
I sort of consider them the first tooth era of baby. Able to babysit new born twins but young enough not to be an adult, like the G1 cartoon depicted.
Also this ^
I wish they had made more. I loved that adolescent in between size. G3 was a wonderful generation for color variations but they never went far enough with the body variants like G1.
-
What bugs me about G3 is that there's quite a few lovely "different" body molds, like these little sisters, that they only used once or twice! I would kill for more sister G3s. Or more baby pegasi!
-
What bugs me about G3 is that there's quite a few lovely "different" body molds, like these little sisters, that they only used once or twice! I would kill for more sister G3s. Or more baby pegasi!
Adding the need for more Unicorns in G3, AGAIN, because I had to Customise a Dance Around & a G3 Baby to get that size in unicorn AT ALL!!!
-
What bugs me about G3 is that there's quite a few lovely "different" body molds, like these little sisters, that they only used once or twice! I would kill for more sister G3s. Or more baby pegasi!
Agreed
-
What bugs me about G3 is that there's quite a few lovely "different" body molds, like these little sisters, that they only used once or twice! I would kill for more sister G3s. Or more baby pegasi!
Yeah, unless I'm mistaken there are no G3 baby unicorns, right? I wish they'd made Dance Around a unicorn since she was in a new mold anyway.
-
What bugs me about G3 is that there's quite a few lovely "different" body molds, like these little sisters, that they only used once or twice! I would kill for more sister G3s. Or more baby pegasi!
Yeah, unless I'm mistaken there are no G3 baby unicorns, right? I wish they'd made Dance Around a unicorn since she was in a new mold anyway.
No baby unicorns. I don't think we've had any since g1. :/
-
What bugs me about G3 is that there's quite a few lovely "different" body molds, like these little sisters, that they only used once or twice! I would kill for more sister G3s. Or more baby pegasi!
Yeah, unless I'm mistaken there are no G3 baby unicorns, right? I wish they'd made Dance Around a unicorn since she was in a new mold anyway.
No baby unicorns. I don't think we've had any since g1. :/
G4 had Sweetie Belle and Star Dreams, I think they're the only post-G1 baby unicorns though. Even G2 didn't have any non-earth babies :(
I'm trying to think of post-G1 baby pegasi. Honolu-loo, Mochanut and G4 Scootaloo... is that it?
-
I always thought of the G1 babies as the older side of toddler. That's because human toddlers melt my heart and that's how I want it to be. I also don't think of most of the adult ponies as being very old themselves. Baby ponies come from a cabbage patch. Was it responsible of the adult ponies to leave the babies to take care of newborn twins? No way! But, what could go wrong? If I'm going to pretend to logic, I just go along with "we can't put baby human development against fantasy pony development".
The information I thought I knew when I got Mochanut was that she was a little sister.
-
Even G2 Baby Swirly's "horn" was a headband, while Twinkle Star's baby had no wings at all