Hi there! Due some family changes, I'm selling my MLP collection - ABOUT 500 PONIES! :shocked: (Still can’t believe it ended up being that many, haha!) It's a bittersweet thing, but I feel good knowing that the ponies will be going to someone who will display them or have time to appreciate them more than I do today! :biggrin:
Ponies
- As an 80s kid, the G1s were either those I had as a kid, found at garage sales in the early 2000s, or received in MLP Arena swaps.
- The vast majority of G2s, G3s, & G4s were bought as an adult collector and either displayed on shelves or stored in boxes.
- I am happy to answer questions or take pictures of any ponies you may be interested in. I started taking photos, but with so many pics to take I got a little worn out. ;) Just send me a DM!
- Ponies are designated "loose" if they are out of the packaging and box/card/bucket/package if still in their original packaging.
Purchase & Shipping
- Since i have so many to sell, I thought it would be pretty time consuming to price check them all up front. So if you see some ponies you’re interested in, send me a DM and an offer (in US dollars) you have in mind.
- Once we’re aligned on price for the ponies, I’ll ask for your address and work on getting a shipping estimate!
- Items will ship within the same week.
- I am located in Washington State, US.
Payment
G1
Spoiler
Baby Firefly G1 Loose SOLD
Baby Lofty (Beddy Bye Eyes) G1 Loose
Baby North Star G1 Loose Missing Tail SOLD
Baby Rainribbon G1 Loose
Baby Ribbon (Beddy Bye Eyes) G1 Loose
Baby Stocking G1 Loose
Baby Sundance w/Harness (Beddy Bye Eyes) G1 Loose
Baby Sundance (Beddy Bye Eyes) G1 Loose
Baby Tappy (Newborn) G1 Loose
Blue Belle (35th Anniversary) G1 Box
Bow Tie G1 Loose HOLD
Butterscotch (35th Anniversary) G1 Box
Cherry Treats G1 Loose SOLD
DJ G1 Loose
Fifi G1 Loose SOLD
Firefly (35th Anniversary) G1 Box
Fizzy G1 Loose
Jabber & Jebber w/ bottle G1 Loose
June Rose G1 Loose
Li'l Tot G1 Loose SOLD
Love Melody G1 Loose SOLD
Lovin' Kisses G1 Loose SOLD
Merry Treat G1 Loose
Minty (35th Anniversary) G1 Box
Moondancer (35th Anniversary) G1 Box
Moonstone (35th Anniversary) G1 Box
Moonstone (35th Anniversary) G1 Loose SOLD
Painting Time (Schooltime Ponies, UK) G1 Loose
Parasol (35th Anniversary) G1 Box
Raincurl G1 Loose SOLD
Ringlet G1 Loose SOLD
Ringlets G1 Loose
Scrumptious G1 Loose
Sea Breeze G1 Loose HOLD
Secret Star G1 Loose SOLD
Skyflier G1 Loose
Skylark G1 Loose
Snuzzle (35th Anniversary) G1 Box
Songster G1 Loose
Starswirl G1 Loose SOLD
Sugar Apple G1 Loose SOLD
Sugar Sweet G1 Loose HOLD
Sunbeam (35th Anniversary) G1 Box
Sundance G1 Loose
Sundance (TAF) G1 Loose
Sunlight G1 Loose HOLD
Sunlight (35th Anniversary) G1 Box
Sweet Notes G1 Loose HOLD
Twilight (35th Anniversary) G1 Box
Up, Up, & Away G1 Loose
Wave Runner G1 Loose
G2
Spoiler
Berry Bright G2 Loose
Ivy G2 Loose
Ivy (Long Hair) G2 Loose
Light Heart (Canopy Bed Pony) G2 Loose
Sky Skimmer G2 Loose
Sundance (Keychain) G2 Card
Sweet Berry G2 Loose
G3
Spoiler
Alphabittle G3 Loose
Amazing Grace G3 Loose
Amberlocks G3 Loose
Apple Spice G3 Loose
Applejack G3 Loose
April Mist G3 Loose
Art Pony (2008) G3 Box
Art Pony (Pop) G3 Loose
August Breeze G3 Loose
Autumn Crisp G3 Loose
Autumn Crisp G3 Loose
Autumn Crisp G3 Card
Avalonia G3 Box
Beachberry G3 Box
Beachcomber G3 Loose
Bee Bop G3 Box
Bee Bop G3 Loose
Blank Pony G3 Box
Blossomforth G3 Loose
Blossomforth (Dance Jamboree) G3 Box
Blue Mist G3 Box
Blue Mist G3 Loose
Blushie G3 Loose
Bow Tie G3 Loose
Bow Tie G3 Box
Breezie G3 Loose
Bubblecup G3 Loose
Bubblecup, Garden Glade, and Wishawhirl (Spring Basket 2004) G3 Bucket
Bumbleberry G3 Loose
Bumblesweet G3 Box
Bunches-o-Fun G3 Loose
Butter Drop (Baby) G3 Card
Butter Pop G3 Loose
Butterscotch G3 Loose
Candy Apple G3 Loose
Candy Apple (cut hair) G3 Loose
Candy Cane G3 Loose
Candy Heart G3 Loose
Cherry Blossom G3 Box
Cherry Blossom G3 Loose
Chilly Breezes G3 Loose
Chocolate Chipper G3 Loose
Cinnamon Breeze G3 Box
Cinnamon Breeze G3 Loose
Citrus Sweetheart G3 Loose
Coconut Cream G3 Box
Coconut Grove G3 Loose
Comet Tail G3 Loose
Comic Con Ninja (2008 San Diego Comic Con) G3 Package
Comic Con Villain (2009 San Diego Comic Con) G3 Loose
Cotton Candy G3 Loose
Crowning Glory G3 Loose
Crystal Crown G3 Loose
Crystal Crown (Wishing Well Princess Playset) G3 Box
Crystal Lace G3 Loose
Crystal Lace G3 Box
Crystal Lake G3 Box
Cupcake G3 Box
Cute Curtsey G3 Loose
Daffidazey G3 Loose
Dainty Daisy G3 Loose
Daisy May G3 Loose
Daisy Paisley G3 Loose
Daisydotes G3 Loose
Daisyjo G3 Box
Dance Slippers G3 Loose
Dandelion (MLP Fair 2010) G3 Loose
Daybreak G3 Loose
Dazzle Surprise G3 Loose
December Delight G3 Loose
Denim Blue G3 Box
Denim Blue G3 Loose
Desert Blossom G3 Box
Desert Blossom G3 Loose
Desert Rose G3 Loose
Desert Rose G3 Box
Doseydotes G3 Card
Doseydotes G3 Loose
Dream Blue G3 Box
Dream Blue G3 Loose
Dream Drifter G3 Loose
Fair Weather G3 Loose
Fairy Dust G3 Loose
Fancy Flora G3 Loose
Fantastical February G3 Box
Finger Paints G3 Loose
Fizzy Pop G3 Box
Flippity Flop G3 Loose
Flower Garland G3 Loose
Flutter Butter G3 Loose
Flutterbutter, Princess Peppermint, Tropical Delight, & Banjo Blue G3 Box
Fluttershy G3 Loose
Fluttershy G3 Box
Fluttershy G3 Loose
Forsythia G3 Box
Forsythia G3 Loose
Frilly Frocks G3 Loose
Garden Wishes G3 Loose
Gardenia Glow G3 Box
Gardenia Glow G3 Loose
Gem Blossom G3 Box
Glitter Glide G3 Box
Glitterbelle G3 Loose
Golden Delicious G3 Box
Golden Delicious G3 Loose
Goodie Goodie G3 Loose
Graffiti Pony (2010 San Deigo Comic Con) G3 Loose
Guava Lava G3 Loose
Heather Winds G3 Box
Hidden Treasure G3 Loose
Island Rainbow G3 Box
Jade Garden G3 Loose
January Joy G3 Loose
Jazz Matazz (Avon) G3 Loose
July Jubilee G3 Loose
July Larkspur G3 Loose
Juniper Jade G3 Box
Junko Mizuno Collector Pony G3 Loose
Kimono G3 Loose
Kiwi Tart G3 Box
Lavendar Cloud G3 Loose
Lavender Locket (Baby) G3 Card
Lickity-Split G3 Loose
Lily Lightly G3 Loose
Lolligiggle G3 Box
Loop-De-La G3 Loose
Loop-De-La G3 Box
Love Wishes (Mail Order) G3 Loose
Lovely Ladybug G3 Loose SOLD
Lulabelle G3 Loose
Magic Marigold G3 Box
Marshmallow Coco G3 Box
May Belle G3 Loose
Meadowbrook G3 Loose
Merriweather G3 Box
Merriweather G3 Loose
Midnight Dream G3 Loose
Minty G3 Loose
Minty (Winter Series III) G3 Box
Mistletoe G3 Box
Misty Blue G3 Loose
Mittens G3 Loose
Moondancer (Moonlight Celebration) G3 Box
Morning Monarch G3 Loose
October Calendula G3 Loose SOLD
October Dreams G3 Loose
Paradise Island G3 Loose
Party Cake G3 Loose
Peach Surprise G3 Loose
Peachie Keen G3 Loose
Peachy Pie G3 Box
Peachy Pie G3 Loose
Peacock Pony (2009 My Little Pony Fair Exclusive Pony) G3 Box
Penny Candy G3 Card
Pepperberry G3 Loose
Pepperberry G3 Box
Peri Winkle G3 Box
Periwinkle G3 Loose
Petal Blossom G3 Loose
Petal Blossom G3 Card
Petal Blossom G3 Loose
Petite Petunia G3 Loose
Petite Petunia G3 Loose
Piccolo G3 Box
Pick-a-Lilly G3 Loose
Pick-a-Lilly & Sunny Salsa G3 Box
Pineapple Paradise G3 Loose
Pinkie Pie G3 Loose
Pinkie Pie G3 Box
Pinkie Pie G3 Loose
Pinkie Pie (3D Symbol) G3 Loose
Pinkie Pie (Large Styling Size) G3 Loose
Pony Project White (San Diego Comic Con) G3 Box
Port-o-Bella & Lickity Split G3 Box
Precious Gem G3 Loose
Pretty Palace G3 Loose
Pretty Pop G3 Loose
Princess Cadance & Shining Armor Family Moments Set G3 Box
Princess Peppermint G3 Loose
Providence, RI 2008 MLP Fair Pony G3 Box
Puzzlemint G3 Loose
Rainbow Dash G3 Loose
Rainbow Dash (Large Styling Size) G3 Loose
Rainbow Dash (Rainbow Down Leg) G3 Loose
Rainbow Dash (w/ Charm) G3 Box
Rainbow Flash G3 Loose
Rainbow Flash G3 Loose
Rainbow Flash & Baby Romperooni G3 Card
Rainbow Swirl G3 Box
Rainbowberry G3 Box
Rarity (3D Symbol) G3 Loose
Rarity (Large Styling Size) G3 Loose
Rarity (Super Long Hair) G3 Loose
Razzaroo G3 Loose
Razzaroo (Birthday Celebration) G3 Box
Rhapsody Ribbon G3 Loose
Ribbon Wishes G3 Loose
Round 'n Round G3 Loose
Royal Beauty G3 Loose
Royal Beauty (Super Long Hair) G3 Loose
Royal Ribbon G3 Card
Royal Rose G3 Loose
Royalette G3 Loose
Sand Dollar G3 Loose
Sapphire Shores G3 Box
Sapphire Shores G3 Loose
Savannah Sage G3 Loose
Savannah Sage G3 Box
Scootaloo G3 Loose
Scooter Sprite G3 Loose
Seascape G3 Loose
Seaspray G3 Box
Seaspray G3 Loose
Secret Wish G3 Loose
September Aster G3 Loose HOLD
Serendipity G3 Box
Sew-and-So G3 Box
Sew-and-So, Tink-a-Tink-a-Too, & Baby Keen Bean G3 Box
Shell-Belle G3 Box
Shell-Belle G3 Loose
Shenanigans G3 Box
Silver Glow G3 Loose
Silver Rain G3 Loose
Silver Song G3 Loose
Skywishes G3 Box
Skywishes G3 Loose
Sno-Glo G3 Box
Sno-Glo G3 Loose
Snow'el G3 Box
Sparkle Snap G3 Loose
Sparklesnap G3 Loose
Sparkleworks G3 Loose
Sparkleworks G3 Box
Sparkleworks II G3 Loose
Spike (Dragon) G3 Loose
Spring Breeze G3 Loose
Spring Fever G3 Loose
Spring Parade G3 Box
Star Catcher G3 Box
Star Catcher G3 Loose
Star Dasher G3 Loose
Star Dasher G3 Box
Star Dasher G3 Loose
Star Flight G3 Loose
Star Flower G3 Loose
Star Swirl G3 Loose
Starbeam G3 Box
Starcatcher G3 Loose
Starcatcher G3 Loose
Starsong G3 Loose
Strawberry Reef G3 Loose
Strawberry Sunset G3 Loose
Strawberry Swirl G3 Box
Strawberry Swirl G3 Loose
Summer Berry G3 Loose
Summer Bloom G3 Loose
Sunny Daze G3 Box
Sunny Daze G3 Loose
Sunny Sparkles G3 Loose
Sunrise G3 Loose
Sunrise Song G3 Loose
Sunset Sweety G3 Box
Sunshimmer (Mail Order) G3 Loose
Sunshimmer (Mail Order) G3 Package
Super Hero Pony (2008 San Diego Comic Con) G3 Loose
Sweet Breeze G3 Box
Sweet Breeze G3 Loose
Sweet September G3 Loose
Sweet Summertime G3 Box
Sweetberry G3 Box
Sweetberry G3 Loose
Sweetie Belle (2008 "Core Friends" Single) G3 Loose
Sweetie Belle (2008 "Name on Leg" Single) G3 Loose HOLD
Sweetie Belle (Valentine) G3 Loose
Sweetsong G3 Box
Swirlypop G3 Loose
Tangerine Sunset G3 Loose
Tangerine Twinkle G3 Loose
Tea Leaf G3 Loose
Tea Leaf G3 Card
Tea Lily G3 Loose Missing some mane hair HOLD
Tea Lily G3 Loose
Tink-a-tink-a-too G3 Loose
Tink-a-tink-a-too G3 Box
Toboggon G3 Box
Toodleloo G3 Box
Toola-Roola G3 Box
Triple Treat G3 Box
Tropical Delight G3 Loose
Tropical Surprise G3 Loose
Tulip Twinkle G3 Loose
Twilight Twinkle G3 Loose
Twinkle Bloom G3 Loose
Twinkle Twirl G3 Loose
Twirlerina G3 Loose
Valenshy G3 Box
Velvet Bow G3 Loose
Waterfire G3 Box
Whistle Wishes G3 Loose
Wind Drifter G3 Loose
Windy Wisp G3 Loose
Winter Snow (International Exclusive) G3 Loose
Winterberry G3 Box
Wish-I-May G3 Loose
Wish-I-Might G3 Loose
Wondermint G3 Box
Wondermint G3 Loose
Wysteria G3 Box
Wysteria (as the Crystal Bride) G3 Loose
Wysteria V (Flowers down the leg) G3 Loose
G3.5
Spoiler
Cheerilee (Newborn Cuties) G3.5 Loose
Pinkie Pie (Large Styling Size) G3.5 Loose
Pinkie Pie (Newborn Cuties) G3.5 Loose
Rainbow Dash (Newborn Cuties) G3.5 Loose
Scootaloo (Newborn Cuties) G3.5 Loose
Starsong (Newborn Cuties) G3.5 Loose
Toolaroola (Newborn Cuties) G3.5 Loose
G4
Spoiler
Apple Bloom (Wild Rainbow) G4 Box
Applejack (Crystal Princess Celebration) G4 Card
Applejack (My Little Pony The Movie) G4 Card
Big McIntosh (My Little Pony The Movie) G4 Card
Blossomforth (Water Cuties) G4 Box
Bubble Splash (My Little Pony The Movie, Baby Sea Pony) G4 Card
Buttonbelle & Friendship Flutters G4 Box
Cherilee G4 Bag
Cherry Berry (Pearlized) (Explore Equestria) G4 Card
Coloratura (Pearlized) (Explore Equestria) G4 Card
Crystal Pearl (My Little Pony The Movie, Baby Sea Pony) G4 Card
Dewdrop Dazzle G4 Loose
Diamond Mint (Water Cuties) G4 Box
DJ Pon-3 (My Little Pony The Movie) G4 Card
Festival Foes (Tempest Shadow & Twilight Sparkle & Spike) G4 Box
Flower Wishes (Water Cuties) G4 Box
Fluttershy G4 Loose
Fluttershy (My Little Pony The Movie) G4 Card
Fluttershy (Pony Mania) G4 Loose
Helia (Pony Mania) G4 Loose
Jelly Bee (My Little Pony The Movie, Baby Sea Pony) G4 Card
Lilly Drop (My Little Pony The Movie, Baby Sea Pony) G4 Card
Lily Blossom G4 Loose
Lily Blossom (Water Cuties) G4 Card
Lily Valley (Pony Mania) G4 Loose
Lotus Flower (Pony Mania) G4 Loose
Lyra Heart Strings G4 Bag
Lyra Heart Strings (My Little Pony The Movie) G4 Card
Mane-Iac Mayhem (Power Ponies) G4 Box
Minty G4 Loose
Miss Pommel (Explore Equestria) G4 Box
Mrs. Cake G4 Loose
Nurse Red Heart G4 Card
Ocean Gem (My Little Pony The Movie, Baby Sea Pony) G4 Card
Octavia Melody (Equestria Girls Doll & Pony Set) G4 Box
Photo Finish (Pony Mania) G4 Box
Pinkie Pie (Crystal Princess Celebration) G4 Card
Pinkie Pie (My Little Pony The Movie) G4 Card
Pinkie Pie (Pinkie Pie's Boutique) G4 Box
Pinkie Pie (Pony Mania) G4 Loose
Pinkie Pie (Twisty-Do) G4 Box
Pretzel (Pearlized) (Explore Equestria) G4 Card
Princess Cadance (Glitter Celebration) G4 Box
Princess Cadence (Pony Mania) G4 Loose
Princess Celestia (Glitter Celebration) G4 Box
Princess Celestia (Pony Mania) G4 Loose
Princess Celestia (Rainbow Shimmer, Rainbow Power) G4 Box
Princess Gold Lily & Pinkie Pie G4 Box
Princess Luna (Rainbow Shimmer, Rainbow Power) G4 Box
Princess Sterling & Fluttershy G4 Card
Princess Twilight Sparkle & Princess Skystar G4 Box
Princess Twilight Sparkle (Pony Mania) G4 Loose
Pursey Pink (Explore Equestria) G4 Card
Rainbow Dash G4 Loose
Rainbow Dash (as Shadow Bolt) G4 Box
Rainbow Dash (Crystal Princess Celebration) G4 Card
Rainbow Dash (My Little Pony The Movie) G4 Card
Rainbow Dash (Pony Mania) G4 Loose
Rainbow Dash (Power Ponies) G4 Card
Rarity G4 Loose
Rarity (Crystal Princess Celebration) G4 Card
Rarity (My Little Pony The Movie) G4 Card
Rarity (Pony Mania) G4 Loose
Roseluck (Pony Mania) G4 Loose
Sapphire Joy (Pealized) (Explore Equestria) G4 Card
Scootaloo (Wild Rainbow) G4 Box
Sea Foam (My Little Pony The Movie, Baby Sea Pony) G4 Card
Sea Poppy (My Little Pony The Movie, Baby Sea Pony) G4 Card
Sea Swirl (Pealized) (Explore Equestria) G4 Card
Skywishes (Cutie Mark Magic) G4 Card
Soarin' (My Little Pony The Movie) G4 Card
Starlight Glimmer (Explore Equestria) G4 Card
Starlight Glimmer (My Little Pony The Movie) G4 Card
Starlight Glimmer (Pearlized) (Explore Equestria) G4 Card
Sun Twist (My Little Pony The Movie, Baby Sea Pony) G4 Card
Sunset Shimmer (Crystal Princess Celebration) G4 Card
Sunshine Petals (Pony Mania) G4 Loose
Sweetie Belle & Apple Bloom & Scootaloo (Wedding Flower Fillies) G4 Box
Sweetie Belle (Wild Rainbow) G4 Box
Sweetie Drops (Cutie Mark Magic) G4 Card
Sweetie Drops (My Little Pony The Movie) G4 Card
Twilight Sparkle (My Little Pony The Movie) G4 Card
Twirly Treats (Baby) G4 Loose
Wysteria (Pinkie Pie's Boutique) G4 Box
Other
Spoiler
UK MLP G4 Magazine
Baby Popple - Bibsy
Lady LovelyLocks Lunchbox with Thermos
Tenderheart Bear Pillow (1980s)
Care Bears Bedtime Stories Book (no record) (1980s)
Care Bears Book of Bedtime Poems (1980s)
Care Bears Keychains (1980s)
Defender of the Universe Voltron: The Buried Castle (book)
Huggabunch Doll
Cabbage Patch Ponies
Masters of The Universe: Skeletor's Flower of Power (book) (1980s)
Masters of The Universe: The Horde (book) (1980s)
Fluppy Dog Cuddle Flupp