The MLP Arena

Pony Talk => Pony Corral => Topic started by: daystar217 on October 02, 2016, 07:08:01 PM

Title: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: daystar217 on October 02, 2016, 07:08:01 PM
So I went thrift hunting today for ponies and a few other toys I'm accruing for my little girls, and I came home very disappointed. I found lots and lots of G3's (which I didn't buy) but not a single g1. I went to Goodwill, Donna's thrift store, some scary gas station converted into a junk shop, and two different flea market malls filled with about 50 different vendors all selling tons of junk. And I mean I dug through boxes and boxes of toys. I found dozens of cabbage patch dolls and lots of other 80's toys, so why is my area so difficult to find second hand ponies? It made me wonder if I should have bought the g3's in hopes of trading them for g1's in the arena. Thoughts?
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: Epona on October 02, 2016, 07:16:31 PM
My area thrift stores rarely have G1`s. When I go thrifting I expect to find G3, G3.5, G4 and tons of McDonalds. In the last 5 years Ive only found a couple of G1s at thrift stores. And never in yard sales.
I went thrifting today and only found 1 G4 pinkie pie and a McDs. The toy section had been picked over.
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: Aliyahbetd on October 02, 2016, 07:42:40 PM
I've been visiting my two local thrift stores once or twice a week for the past year now, and I've only found g1s twice (but one f the two I found is one of my absolute favorites :) ). They seem to be quite rare.

Don't give up! I'm sure you will find something super cool :)
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: Koudoawaia on October 02, 2016, 07:47:02 PM
I've never found G1s in any thrift store I've ever been in =/
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: Shy Violet on October 02, 2016, 07:58:12 PM
They don't come up very often. I've had pretty good luck this year but haven't found one in at least 2 months. And I check 6 thrift stores several times a week. Anytime I'm nearby one I check and twice a week I go check them all. Don't be discouraged, you are going to have to check quite often to find anything.
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: Taxel on October 02, 2016, 08:13:47 PM
Honestly, its 2016. The 80s have been over for close to 30 years. Most people who wanted to toss out/donate their 30 year old toys already have. With the popularity of eBay/Craigslist/etc and the growing knowledge random people have about collectors, most people aren't just going to give away piles of really old toys anymore. A lot of people won't pass on the opportunity to make money reselling something by giving it away, especially with all those ridiculous not-at-all-researched clickbait sites screaming about how 80s-90s toys/kid stuff is worth $83849234203 each.

Plus there's the people who buy from thrift stores and resell as a means to pay bills. If you know what to look for it can be really lucrative, not just with ponies.
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: Princess Lala on October 02, 2016, 08:54:14 PM
After five years of looking (I go twice a week) in my thrift store, ive onpy seen like 2 G1s in the wild. Lots of G4 Mcdonalds ponies and G3s though.
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: Mermaid on October 02, 2016, 11:56:13 PM
*remembers 1996-2000* ahhhhh the days of popping into a goodwill and leaving behind common g1s! Haha I very seldomly find g1s now. I found a tailless peachy at a flea market covered in ink and I paid $3 for her just for the novelty!
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: daystar217 on October 03, 2016, 05:41:02 AM
So, if you were me, would you buy those G3's when they come up? Is it possible to trade several G3's for a G1, or is that not something people are interested in doing?
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: Ponyfan on October 03, 2016, 06:00:48 AM
My area is terrible for finding old toys. The thrift   stores usually don't have ponies, Barbies etc.. or if they do they are in bad shape. I did find some G1s at an antique store probably 10 years ago but the store wanted way too much for them in their condition. I remember they wanted $6 for a Bouncy that had a lot of flocking loss.

I've even tried Savers and only found McDonald's Happy Meal Equestrian Girls and ponies. I was going to buy some old Beanie Babies from Savers and discovered a dead bug inside the bag with the toys, so I left  those behind too.

Ponyfan
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: EnaRocketQueen on October 03, 2016, 06:03:39 AM
My thrift stores never have any ponies of any generation. I keep looking in hope for G4s but there are hardly any toys at all
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: slyons on October 03, 2016, 06:08:20 AM
So, if you were me, would you buy those G3's when they come up? Is it possible to trade several G3's for a G1, or is that not something people are interested in doing?

Well, it really all depends if the person you are trading with is looking for g3's  :)
I am actually in the middle of such a transaction, my g3's for g1's....they are considerably less than what I'm purchasing so I have to cover the difference with monies...
So it is possible!  I never leave a pony behind, but that's a personal preference...
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: wyndeboo on October 03, 2016, 06:24:52 AM
Don't give up hope. I've been collecting for nine years and have only found g1 ponies in the wild 5 times. Just keep looking they'll pop up eventually.
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: Luxrayx on October 03, 2016, 06:52:21 AM
Just keep trying... I've never, ever found a pony in a thrift store, so if I found G3s I would've been ecstatic :P
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: joce on October 03, 2016, 06:54:19 AM
It's rare I find them, I'm just super surprised and happy when I do lol!

  Now I may pay more than I would in the past because it is so rare I come across them.

 I'll pick up rare G3s to trade though so far they just sit taking up room!!

I had plans for pony hunting this summer to and it never happened :(
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: FantasticFirefly on October 03, 2016, 07:02:11 AM
It's one of those things. There are thousands of members here, so when someone finds something awesome locally they post about it, they don't post about taking the time to hunt multiple times weekly and coming up empty handed for a year. Makes great finds look commonplace, when they are anything but.

Another thing, some places throw away (lead concerns) or do other things with vintage toys (sell them online- makes $$). So you would only be picking through newer stuff, or the odd toy they missed from the 90's or before. It pays to become friendly with the staff, they'll let you know then if you are wasting time in that shop "Oh, Joe works here and he buys every single one for his grandkids". I still hunt at some of those places because sometimes pieces are missed (stuff not easily recognizable as belonging to MLP by non serious collectors) but I never waste gas to go there, I'll wander in from another parking lot if we are shopping nearby.
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: zombienixon on October 03, 2016, 09:13:22 AM
I once went to every thrift store in the county and saw nothing but fakies, and one or two pieces of G4 merchandise. Also,  they stopped making G1s here about a quarter of a century ago. You can't really expect them to be plentiful anymore.
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: apanda0622 on October 03, 2016, 09:25:48 AM
I would not feel so discouraged not being able to find G1s.  I have been thrifting for years and G1's are very hard to come across, although I have been lucky a few times.  You just have to be persistent in going to thrift stores regularly.  I go thrifting several times a week after work and on weekends and sometimes I find vintage toys and sometimes nothing.  It really just comes down to luck.  If you happen to be at the thrift store when they put it out.

Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: lovesbabysquirmy on October 03, 2016, 10:29:56 AM
It really just comes down to luck.  If you happen to be at the thrift store when they put it out.

Pretty  much this.  Also remember that it's been way more than 20 years since people discarded G1's as "useless plastic taking up space in the toyroom en masse".  Most people know there is some kind of collectible market for them.  I haven't bought more than 1-3 G1's at a time, when I do sometimes find them at a thrift store.  It's been such a long time since I was able to buy multiple bags of them... going on 20 years now...

so just keep looking!  :) 
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: banditpony on October 03, 2016, 10:43:09 AM
I used to pony hunt a lot. It's rare for them to pop up, but they do. (In my area I've had way more luck at flea markets).

But there is absolutely competition. There are people who go everyday to thrift stores and flea markets with intent to flip. Sometimes they know if certain stores put out items at a certain time, or they even have friends who will hold items. Some stores won't even put out g1 ponies (like goodwill 9_9; With the exception of the outlets).
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: LadyMoondancer on October 03, 2016, 02:27:50 PM
Honestly, its 2016. The 80s have been over for close to 30 years. Most people who wanted to toss out/donate their 30 year old toys already have. With the popularity of eBay/Craigslist/etc and the growing knowledge random people have about collectors, most people aren't just going to give away piles of really old toys anymore. A lot of people won't pass on the opportunity to make money reselling something by giving it away, especially with all those ridiculous not-at-all-researched clickbait sites screaming about how 80s-90s toys/kid stuff is worth $83849234203 each.

Plus there's the people who buy from thrift stores and resell as a means to pay bills. If you know what to look for it can be really lucrative, not just with ponies.

Yes, this. :)  There were tons of G1 ponies in thrift shops in the 90s, because that was when their original owners were outgrowing them en masse. It's just going to be really difficult to find them "in the wild" now because they're 30 years old.

Regarding trading G3s for G1s:  Personally I think it's more efficient to save the money you would have spend on G3s and just buy a G1 online.  It's hard to move G3s and most of them are not worth much.  If you see a more valuable G3 then yeah, totally pick it up. 
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: invaderhorizongreen on October 03, 2016, 05:29:29 PM
I am looking for a lot of gen 3 ponies, and I very rarely even see them at my local thrift.
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: Aliyahbetd on October 03, 2016, 06:54:07 PM
Wow, some of the replies here make my two g1s in one year look relatively lucky lol (though one was a grungy blossom and I was tempted to leave her).
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: plushroo on October 03, 2016, 08:54:31 PM
It's still  possible, just more difficult than it was say 10 years ago.  I live in a very small town with only one second hand shop (mostly sells clothes and little knick knacks), but I've managed to find a couple of G1's there. A Peachy and a Cotton Candy in a sweet dreams outfit. It was completely unexpected given the small population here and slim  chance anyone here still had ponies from the 80's. I still go there from time to time to get small items and check out the few toys they have. Some thrift stores don't have vintage toys like they used to because of the lead laws so it makes toy hunting more challenging.
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: vira on October 03, 2016, 09:38:41 PM
i almost never find ponies in garage sales or thrift stores besides g4; maybe theres a lot of other collectors in my area! the last time i found a g1 was tap dancer at a garage sale four or five years ago :'-)

what i have had some luck with is vintage toy stores! there are a couple in my area, and their prices, while not thrift-store low, are often reasonable!

ive found peachys for three dollars, good condition BBEs for five, and a vintage toy store is where i got my cha cha the llama for like 15 dollars! :'-O

id also recommend seeing if your town or any of the surrounding ones has a garage sale website or facebook page; i see g1 ponies on them semi regularly!
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: Taffeta on October 04, 2016, 02:41:13 AM
I agree with what's already been said. Time has passed and now MLP is no longer junk but something people see a value in. In the UK I've noticed a shift from second hand sales like carboot sales and charity shops to the toy fair which is more of a collector experience. Last toy fair I saw a lot of G1 ponies. They were not at junk prices, although I admit that the prices on the rarer ones I saw were probably about right for what they were.

I have found 2 g1 ponies at carbootsales this year. Applejack and Baby Cuddles. Also Seastar's float, but no Seastar. And originally the seller wanted £5 for that on its own, but I talked him down. AJ and Cuddles were 50p each, though, so it does still happen. It's just rare.

I don't buy G3 or G4 unless I like/want them, because they take up space I don't have and are hard to get rid of. I've seen G2 a few times this year - there was one BIG lot of them at a carboot I went to and someone else got there just after me and and was all excited about them so I guessed she was a ponyperson (maybe someone here?) I left her to get on with it, though, since they were all the oldest G2 and I know we have them all at home.

I was genuinely surprised at the rise in pony numbers at the toy fair this year. From one or two to about six stalls with them, some labelled and priced and named clearly as who they were.

I think that's the future. Second hand sales in general are a bonus if you find them, but there's no point in expecting a 30 year old toy to drop into your lap the way they did in the late 1990s.
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: buttonso on October 04, 2016, 04:43:02 AM
I think everyone else pretty much covered it. I've had a fairly high rate of G1 "in the wild" finds and I still come away empty handed MUCH more often than not. And the ones I do find are usually in pretty sad shape, so there's also that. (Restoring is fun though!)

i do see G3s a lot but buying them made me fall for the dang things, so proceed with caution. You may end up wanting to keep them.  ;)
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: josiekat on October 04, 2016, 11:51:17 AM
Its not really a surprise that G1's aren't in thrift stores. They were in thrift shops about 10 years ago. Now its time for G3's to show up there.


Sending you a PM daystar!
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: shelvesofwhimsy on October 04, 2016, 12:03:24 PM
After thrifting quite a bit, I've only found 1 G1 Baby Snippy in a thrift store!

That being said I have found lots of ponies at toy shows, collectibles shops and more. But its geared towards toys. I think you just have to thrift knowing you probably wont find anything, but you might get lucky someday. Its really just luck.
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: Tak on October 04, 2016, 12:25:11 PM
Honestly, its 2016. The 80s have been over for close to 30 years. Most people who wanted to toss out/donate their 30 year old toys already have. With the popularity of eBay/Craigslist/etc and the growing knowledge random people have about collectors, most people aren't just going to give away piles of really old toys anymore. A lot of people won't pass on the opportunity to make money reselling something by giving it away, especially with all those ridiculous not-at-all-researched clickbait sites screaming about how 80s-90s toys/kid stuff is worth $83849234203 each.

Plus there's the people who buy from thrift stores and resell as a means to pay bills. If you know what to look for it can be really lucrative, not just with ponies.

This saddens me.
I'm discouraged by thrift stores. Everywhere, actually.
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: daystar217 on October 05, 2016, 04:27:46 AM
Wow, so many responses!
Thanks for the encouragement. After reading how hard it is for some of you to even find G3's, I went back the next day and picked up the four bags of G3's for $16.
visitors can't see pics , please register or login




i do see G3s a lot but buying them made me fall for the dang things, so proceed with caution. You may end up wanting to keep them.  ;)
I can see that happening! I bought them for trading, but now I'm thinking I might want them for my kids. I don't know which G3's are rare but these look pretty common. I found another one at a different junk shop today (We're getting a new roof on our house and I had to get the kids out of the noisy work zone for the past few days.) She was only $.50.
So I spent my pony budget for the month, but I'm excited that there are people in the arena with G1's to sell or trade! Maybe next month?
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: josiekat on October 05, 2016, 06:58:42 AM
That's a nice set of G3's! I love that blue baby one! And I agree. Once they are in hand, you may end up starting a G3 collection!
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: EnaRocketQueen on October 05, 2016, 09:24:12 AM
Those G3s look so nice- if they'd have been in a shop near me I'd have pounced on them!  :)
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: gullideth on October 05, 2016, 10:11:42 AM
I got discouraged same as you, I hunted every thrift and flea only to find no G1 ponies.  The other 80's toys I pick up if they are collectable and sell them online to buy ponies online.  It really does work out if  you know what to pick.

Regardless, don't give up!  I found some very rare petites at a yard sale once and my grandma scored a mimic at a yard sale for 2.00.  Yard sales are really the best, fleas second best, then thrift shops.
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: reanna-mator on October 05, 2016, 10:17:12 AM
Glad you went for the G3s. They do look very nice. :) Don't give up, when I got frustrated with the shop nearest me, I often found that I had good luck right when I was thinking of giving up for a while.
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: Eternia on October 05, 2016, 04:52:37 PM
I have only found one G1 in a thrift store in my entire life. one.
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: nemubones on October 05, 2016, 05:02:52 PM
It has been scarce to find them in thrift shops but they do show up. I have better luck at flea markets and antique shops nowadays but even then its still the luck of the day.
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: Terra on October 05, 2016, 06:37:45 PM
I've had good luck at flea markets, but not so much thrift stores.

NOW.... There was one thrift store that was a pretty good resource for them near my old home. Usually beat up g1s, but I'd buy them none the less!  Later on I kind of connected the dots, and realized they were probably being stocked by a fellow that ran this awesome vintage toy trading store in the area. That is, that he would donate the baits he got in pony lots to savers in exchange for store credit. 

SO that was sort of an unusual circumstance (I miss that store dearly!). Like others have said, we've kind of gone past the stage where kids from the 80's are unloading their old toys at the good will. Its still possible though! But you may have better luck at flea markets, because there are people that make their livelihood picking up old stuff from thrift stores and estate sales and reselling it.   That's going to vary a lot by location of course!
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: scarletjul on October 05, 2016, 08:12:36 PM
I actually haven't been at a thrift store in about 6 weeks (I've been too busy.)  However...

In general, I find g1s about once every 4 or so months.  They just aren't that common.  Strangely, g3s are becoming less common, as well (and when I do find them, they're always Core 7.)  I run into g4s way more often than any other era of pony.  Lots of Pinkie Pies.  :P

I think this comes down to a few things.  One is that people gave up their ponies awhile ago.  Two is that people are more savvy.  Either they know to sell their ponies on eBay, etc or some reseller is going to the thrift stores and *they* know to see ponies on eBay, etc (I see those people fairly often.)  Three is just luck.  Either you got there at just the right time or you didn't.  I've been to the store enough times to find the accessories but not the ponies.

As for g3s, I know there's members here who collect them.  :)  Looks like you found some pretty ones, anyhow.
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: Epona on October 08, 2016, 06:35:11 PM
That's a nice lot of G3`s. I`d be thrilled to find that many. Especially Non-core 7.
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: Lucky_Ladybug on October 09, 2016, 01:25:22 AM
That's great that the G3s were still there for you to get! What a nice lot! They all look in such good condition. That would totally thrill me; I've only seen very dirty Ponies at the local antique store and I just couldn't deal with that. (I'm not one of the enthusiastic Pony cleaners here.)
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: lovesbabysquirmy on October 09, 2016, 09:11:33 AM
That is a great lot of G3's!
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: Sunset on October 09, 2016, 10:40:23 AM
I saw a g1 for the first time in a long time at my local flea market.  Sadly, I left her behind.  It was a baby Surprise in the worst condition I've ever seen.  Absolutely covered in rust stains with a ragged neck seam and cut hair.  I suppose I could of customized her but I have too many other projects right now.
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: SilverHealer on October 09, 2016, 11:16:21 AM
In my years of searching, I've only ever found a regrind-plagued Majesty and maybe two G3s. :(

I have a friend who manages to find a bunch of G1s downtown, though.
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: ghouldilocks on October 12, 2016, 11:03:20 AM
Wow, so many responses!
Thanks for the encouragement. After reading how hard it is for some of you to even find G3's, I went back the next day and picked up the four bags of G3's for $16.
visitors can't see pics , please register or login




i do see G3s a lot but buying them made me fall for the dang things, so proceed with caution. You may end up wanting to keep them.  ;)
I can see that happening! I bought them for trading, but now I'm thinking I might want them for my kids. I don't know which G3's are rare but these look pretty common. I found another one at a different junk shop today (We're getting a new roof on our house and I had to get the kids out of the noisy work zone for the past few days.) She was only $.50.
So I spent my pony budget for the month, but I'm excited that there are people in the arena with G1's to sell or trade! Maybe next month?

That is MUCH better luck than I have ever had at a thrift shops! I usually only ever find fakies, McDonald's ponies, or the occasional G4/EqG. I sometimes get lucky at antique malls or flea markets, though more often than not, they're overpriced. It's pretty rare when I come across a really good lot of G1 in the wild that's priced secondhand instead of being priced like a collector or with wishful thinking, lol

I'm of the mind, though, that when I find ponies in the wild, I never leave them behind unless the price is just really over the top and I can't justify it, or if they're a common G4/McDonald's ponies.
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: ringwraith10 on October 13, 2016, 10:52:46 AM
If you're shopping for kids, it's probably better to look for G3s and G4s, anyway. It's very difficult to find G1s, and G1s tend to have a whole slew of problems that can make them dangerous for kids (mold, lead, one study even said they might have traces of arsenic in them!). By today's safety standards, G1s are best kept thoroughly cleaned and on a shelf.
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: FantasticFirefly on October 15, 2016, 10:29:28 AM
If you're shopping for kids, it's probably better to look for G3s and G4s, anyway. It's very difficult to find G1s, and G1s tend to have a whole slew of problems that can make them dangerous for kids (mold, lead, one study even said they might have traces of arsenic in them!). By today's safety standards, G1s are best kept thoroughly cleaned and on a shelf.

Um. do you have a link in regards to anything about arsenic? I tried to keep my research on these toys pretty updated and from reputable sources and haven't read anything about arsenic thus far.

ok, 1980's era toys including G1 ponies contain lead and cadmium, the concentrations can vary, and some colours of toy is far far higher then others. I'm not speaking of the paint, actually in the vinyl itself. they also contain types of phthalates that are now banned as they are highly suspected of being endocrine disruptions in people. (if you have slimy leaky ponies to clean, use gloves, and wash hands after handing your collection, before eating etc. I personally stopped giving g1's to kids for these reasons to be on the safe side. I do buy g3's/g4's to share pony joy with them though. :)

G3 era and beyond are safe. they also tend to show age worse then the vintage toys. so something about the older recipes made them hold up far better. maybe it is the unsade stuff. G2 is unknown, and I don't have the kind of cash to send off samples to the quality of lab we'd need to find out.
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: daystar217 on October 15, 2016, 06:57:45 PM
visitors can't see pics , please register or login

So I went back to the flea market today and picked up the three G3's that I saw from this original post. I wasn't surprised they were still there, business had been slow. But I found a G1! A Firefly in great condition! And the orange G3 still has the packaging plastic around her tail and sewn into her mane. She was also wearing a pony costume with all the shoes and leg warmers and crown...pretty good for $3, right? The purple one was $2, the FIrefly and rainbow haired G3 were $1 each. But something happened to the rainbow hair when I washed it - the pink hair snapped off at the base, as clean as a razor blade. It just fell out in chunks. No other color, the white hair and green hair was fine, but the sugarberry colored streaks disintegrated. Anyway, I had lots of fun dragging my poor kids all over town to bargain hunt today.  :happy:
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: LadyMoondancer on October 15, 2016, 08:16:52 PM
Might be this study?

http://www.inhabitots.com/your-hand-me-down-vintage-toys-from-the-1970s-and-1980s-may-be-harming-your-child/

Quote
The researchers tested three categories of toys, including vintage non-vinyl, vintage vinyl, and more recently made vinyl toys. Examples of some of the toys tested included Fisher Price Little People sets, My Little Pony dolls, Barbies, rubber ducks, Little Tykes play kitchens and American Girl dolls. The study notes that 34% of the 77 non-vinyl toys tested would violate the current U.S. and Denmark limits on lead while 30% would violate cadmium limits.

Oddly the color of each toy played a significant role in the toxicity of said toy. According to the study, the highest concentrations of both cadmium and lead were found in yellow toy parts. Green, orange, and brown non-vinyl parts were similarly likely to contain high lead or cadmium concentrations. Toys colored with red and peach hues often contained lead or cadmium, and peach plastic was especially likely to contain excessive cadmium. Toy parts colored with white, magenta, turquoise, black, and gray had very little to undetectable amounts of cadmium and lead. The researchers note that while specific pigments appear to be a major source of harmful metals in toys, parents should perhaps avoid giving any older toys to their kids, as there’s not enough research on their safety.

So really we are just saving the children when we snap up all the G1s at a thrift shop.  :P

BTW, the G3-style fakies with the translucent glitter bodies were tested on a news program they contain lead.  I would never give a fakie, any fakie, to a child.  The fakie companies are too fly-by-night, there one day and gone the next.  They have much less incentive to produce safe toys than "legit" companies.

Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: Taxel on October 16, 2016, 01:52:47 AM
That's scary!

I'd never give a child a vintage (or fakie) toy like that to keep but now I'm really glad my boyfriend's little sister outgrew ponies. She absolutely loved to play with my baity G1s when we visit. I'd let her play for a short time as long as she was careful but man, I definitely wouldn't let her do that anymore.


The trend of passing down American Girl dolls without getting the plastic parts replaced is worrying me now too...
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: Foxtale on October 16, 2016, 10:16:57 AM
That's scary!

The trend of passing down American Girl dolls without getting the plastic parts replaced is worrying me now too...

I wouldn't worry so much about the American Girl dolls. I know that plastics are plastics, but their materials used to be of a higher quality. I can't speak for the 1980s dolls but the most popular "vintage" dolls were from the 90s when concerns were a lot higher. Although I do have a Rabbit Hutch that is made of real wood and real wire netting. I always thought it was dangerous even when I was younger lol.

I love going thrifting for ponies although it is highly unlikely that I see anything besides G3 ponies at this point or really gnarly common G1s.

Daystar- There is a known issue with some colors of hair on G3 ponies that do that. Specifically the pink you are describing. Someone can link you to the thread hopefully but it is common that this color gets brittle and just falls out as if a razor cut it. It's so sad that it has happened to so many ponies.
Title: Re: Thrift shopped out and discouraged
Post by: otocolobus_manul on October 16, 2016, 12:50:19 PM
visitors can't see pics , please register or login

So I went back to the flea market today and picked up the three G3's that I saw from this original post. I wasn't surprised they were still there, business had been slow. But I found a G1! A Firefly in great condition! And the orange G3 still has the packaging plastic around her tail and sewn into her mane. She was also wearing a pony costume with all the shoes and leg warmers and crown...pretty good for $3, right? The purple one was $2, the FIrefly and rainbow haired G3 were $1 each. But something happened to the rainbow hair when I washed it - the pink hair snapped off at the base, as clean as a razor blade. It just fell out in chunks. No other color, the white hair and green hair was fine, but the sugarberry colored streaks disintegrated. Anyway, I had lots of fun dragging my poor kids all over town to bargain hunt today.  :happy:

Nice! I rarely find anything at thrift stores, even g3s and g4s. I've also only found a single g1 in my 3-4 years of collecting.

And for the pony with broken hair, I forget her name, but I believe she was sold by Avon. The Avon ponies are notorious for horrible hair that breaks off in chunks.

Also, might you be interested in trading a G3 or 2 for a very nice condition TAF Sundance, by any chance?  :)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal