The MLP Arena
Pony Talk => Off Topic => Topic started by: nuttertasha on February 09, 2012, 06:07:52 AM
-
hello all
i was just wondeing if anyone with children home educated them i do my two and they love it my son is very emotional like me and hates loud noises he doesnt want to go to school i asked him if he did he said no its to loud mummy he is only 5 years old bless him.
me and my partner made the chioce together and it is working out well im so proud of both my kids my 3 year old has just started wanting to sit with us and do stuff so im letting her she is picking it up really well i think thats just girls though they like to learn fast lol.
anyway is any one else home educate or is it just ickle old me
-
I home school my boys, and my girl has been in public school for two years but says she's ready to come back to home schooling for the next year.
-
aww thats fab my two love it so much
-
We don't have kids yet but when we do we are thinking about private or home schooling. I'm just really not happy with the way public schools work and the complete lack of learning that seems to go on.
-
I'm a public school teacher, and your son's assessment of public school is definitely correct. :) I agree that it's not for every child and every family. We're looking into private/charter schools for when my son enters school age (he's currently enrolled in a private pre-school, but they stop at the Kindergarten level.)
I know a few homeschooled kids and I can tell that with the right plan, it goes very well for them. There are some excellent communities online for people who homeschool, so you should definitely begin reading up and get input from others who do. Good luck! :)
-
I don't homeschool my kids, but then again, we live in one of the best public school districts in the country, so I don't feel bad about sending them to school. And they love it - they love their teachers, their friends, all the field trips and projects. *shrug* I guess it just depends on each individual family.
I do know a few families that homeschool their kids.
-
I might be a bit biased (based off of my own profession), but I dont think I could homeschool kids if I ever end up with any.
That said, id have to know the school inside out. Its not just about public v.s not, im really sensitive with the smaller things because of my own childhood.
Its not to say that homeschooling isnt the way to go--if it works for that individual family, it works^^
-
From what I've seen, homeschooling is probably not something I'm going to do. I've known people who were home schooled, and they ended up fairly sheltered and clingy towards their parents. But that's them, I'm sure everyone comes out differently. I'm all for private school, though! I went to a very small private school for middle and part of high school. Everything was very personal and everyone knew everyone.
Public schools are just atrocious.
-
its nice to know some people understand why we are doing it the schools over here in the uk arnt that great my brother was home ed and he is doing well has his first job and is hoping to move out last i heard bless him.
i mean not all parents are up for home schooling and thats fine each person family is diffrent we are just lucky that are kids feel the need to be involved we have help as im dyslexic so some things i cant do but we muddle through its just nice to know that there are others out there that do it too.
-
I was homeschooled! I was pulled out in first grade. My struggle with reading ended in a couple weeks of being taught by my mom lol. I went back to public school for 6-7 grade, then homeschooled during everything else.
I'm tempted to homeschool my own children someday, but I'll have to play it by ear since everybody is different.
-
In the unlikely event that I'm ever a parent, my kids would definitely be home-schooled. I had some not-so-nice experiences in public school and no child of mine will ever set foot in one.
-
In the unlikely event that I'm ever a parent, my kids would definitely be home-schooled. I had some not-so-nice experiences in public school and no child of mine will ever set foot in one.
same with us we didnt want our two to go through the nasty stuff we did glad people understand because when i tell some people the looks i get make me angry or the oh no you should send them to school to give your self a break if i wanted to have a break i get my sister to babysit and i go out for the day
-
I personally wouldn't homeschool any kids I might have. I think it's important to be exposed to other children, even the nasty ones because it teaches us how to deal with them. Plus I'm hoping to be living in an area with half decent state schools by the time I breed :P
-
I personally wouldn't homeschool any kids I might have. I think it's important to be exposed to other children, even the nasty ones because it teaches us how to deal with them. Plus I'm hoping to be living in an area with half decent state schools by the time I breed :P
we take ours to met ups of other home ed kids so they do mix with others thats not a problem
-
Personally I wouldn't wish any child of mine to go through what I did at public secondary school. They were the worst years of my life.
But of course, each area is different.
-
Personally I wouldn't wish any child of mine to go through what I did at public secondary school. They were the worst years of my life.
But of course, each area is different.
my entire schooling was the worst for me so i know how you feel
-
I've homeschooled my boys for the majority of their educational careers and am very proud to say that my eldest will graduate high school with Honors in 2013. :accomplished:
It's been a little harder on my youngest boy since he's very social, but we have made a point to get involved in our community and he is very happy to spend time with his other homeschooled friends. They are both very well adjusted and not clingy at all!! XD
I had a horrendous public school experience myself, so when my boys started having issues in school I was more than happy to pull them out. Best decision we ever made; and we All think so. :)
If you ever need some support from a fellow Homeschooling parent feel free to PM me!! :lovey:
-
Wow, lots of hate for public school. Everyone is of course entitled to do what they want with their kids, but personally the only thing I'd want for my kids would be to go to public school. I just think there's no substitution for the experience. I can understand that schooling is hell for many kids (and honestly that's sad and there's NO excuse for it - pity some kids are so cruel to their peers) but for the majority, I think it's a good thing. And I don't mean the academics, as I'm sure most homeschooled kids get a good education - I'm actually talking about everything else. Exposure to lots of other kids, activities and field trips, and just the experience in general.
ETA: I notice a lot of parents who homeschool their kids had a bad school experience themselves. I personally feel that homeschool would have been completely wrong for myself, and that's one big reason I wouldn't want to homeschool my own kids.
Also, I wanted to say that I honestly feel like kids should be able to choose what they want themselves (assuming the parents are willing/wanting to homeschool) - if they're happy and well rounded being homeschooled, fine. But if they want to go to public school, I think they should be allowed to. I've heard stories of kids who wanted to go to public school but their parents wouldn't let them - I think that's really sad.
-
For me it won't be about "bad experiences". I am not satisfied with the lack of education that goes on in public schools. My nephew is currently in public school and thanks to no child left behind, all he's learning is how to pass a test. That doesn't cut it for me. I want my child educated and given options in life that public schools fail to offer because "there's not enough interest" or "no funding". There are other ways for children to interact with other children outside of a school setting. There is no reason that a home schooled child has to grow up sheltered and clingy or lacking social skills or experiences. Personally, I would prefer the private school option, but even then I will still be very involved with my child's education.
-
I am not satisfied with the lack of education that goes on in public schools. My nephew is currently in public school and thanks to no child left behind, all he's learning is how to pass a test. That doesn't cut it for me. I want my child educated and given options in life that public schools fail to offer because "there's not enough interest" or "no funding".
Got to agree there. The public schools in the state I live in are terrible. They don't offer much in the way of extracurricular activities or field trips or even classes (my high school didn't have calculus and even one year didn't have a foreign language; no band or music; no advanced placement courses). And funding continues to be cut for them.
As far as socializing homeschooled kids, there's homeschool groups that meet, and things like Scouts and 4H, and religious-related activities if you're religious, and some libraries offer programs for kids, especially in the summer, but ours will do activities throughout the year too. And some museums will offer classes. Then there's things like summer camp and Space Camp (Space Camp offers scholarships, or used to anyway, that's how I was able to go).
-
But if they want to go to public school, I think they should be allowed to. I've heard stories of kids who wanted to go to public school but their parents wouldn't let them - I think that's really sad.
All of the children who are homeschooled in my community do so by Choice, not force!! As a matter of fact, my youngest boys best friend is homeschooled and his sister goes to public school. Both of my sons, the younger, more social one included, chose to be homeschooled. They are both smart enough to see that the one real gain they'd make in public schools is social, Not educational. When I put my children back into public schools for the second try after an out-of-state move their grades went from As and Bs at the beginning of the year to Cs and Ds by the end. Next Homeschooled year they were back up to As and Bs again. 'Nuff said.
I certainly don't think that homeschooling is for every child and nor for every parent. For those who are lucky enough to have good school systems, Great!! But, for those of us who find our public schools to be a place of horror... well, I seriously pity the individuals who don't have the choice for an alternative. I find that to be sad and am sooo thankful that my children don't have to live in a nightmare..
-
My mom started homeschooling my little brother and youngest sister last year.
-
But if they want to go to public school, I think they should be allowed to. I've heard stories of kids who wanted to go to public school but their parents wouldn't let them - I think that's really sad.
All of the children who are homeschooled in my community do so by Choice, not force!! As a matter of fact, my youngest boys best friend is homeschooled and his sister goes to public school. Both of my sons, the younger, more social one included, chose to be homeschooled. They are both smart enough to see that the one real gain they'd make in public schools is social, Not educational. When I put my children back into public schools for the second try after an out-of-state move their grades went from As and Bs at the beginning of the year to Cs and Ds by the end. Next Homeschooled year they were back up to As and Bs again. 'Nuff said.
I certainly don't think that homeschooling is for every child and nor for every parent. For those who are lucky enough to have good school systems, Great!! But, for those of us who find our public schools to be a place of horror... well, I seriously pity the individuals who don't have the choice for an alternative. I find that to be sad and am sooo thankful that my children don't have to live in a nightmare..
Hey, sorry, I wasn't directing this at anyone here. =)
Like I said, I think it's fair when the child chooses what works best for them. If they choose homeschool, more power to them! My main issue is if a kid really desires to go to school and at least see what it's like for a year or two, I think it's wrong to not give them that chance. It's a chance that they'll never get again, you know? And if they do poorly, then the parents should definitely investigate what's wrong and see if anything can be helped.
I think I'm actually kind of biased or something because people talk about how awful public schools are but I never thought mine were bad. I think that's probably because I supposedly attended a really really good school system. I'm not going to say everything was totally perfect, but when people talk about horrors I just don't really know what they mean because - I guess - I never experienced it.
Is it that the teachers are uncaring? Or is it that the schools are dirty or unsafe? Are the materials way out of date? I'm just curious.
-
I wouldn't only because I want my future kids to attend school in French, and my French is not really something I'd want them learning lol I speak Quebecois slang with terrible grammar and that's about it lol! But, I do have to say that if they ever started feeling like they absolutely hate school, I might consider it. I had horrible experiences as well, but then I had some really good ones, too, so I can't say I'm prejudiced about public school. I just wish there was a better system in place for bullying, which I think should be illegal.
-
As someone that is intimately involved in the school system, I honestly don't know whether or not I would send my kids to a public school (I don't have any, nor do I want children of my own). I've seen both sides of the educator coin - I was schooled privately throughout my secondary education because the public schools where I grew up were terrible. However, I also graduated before the implementation of the No Child Left Behind Act. I think that it makes educating children that much harder, especially as the state assessments aren't really being used to measure what they say they measure. The assessments might be reliable but they are not valid indicators of how well a school district can teach children.
My biggest issue isn't the lack of learning - since I have still seen many many kids be able to learn what they would like, my issue with with the sheer indoctrination that these kids go through. They aren't being taught to think or question things. They are being taught to look so called facts up in a book with little regard as to how they might be biased. As someone that works in "special education" I find it incredibly frustrating what teachers, administrators, and kids have to put up with because of the laws that have been passed. While I certainly don't begrudge anyone an education, school is VERY different than when I attended and that was only 10 years ago. I work in a very good school district in my area and I still don't think I would want my 'kids' to attend there.
Pink Rosedust@
To address some of your questions: I think that there is a mixture, there are a lot of teachers that are uncaring. I've done some classroom observations when a child is referred to me and have to then explain that I don't think it's the child since 2/3 of the teachers class is failing. Some of the teachers care, but get SO burnt out dealing with all of the other issues that arise that honestly, teachers really don't get to TEACH anymore. They are forced into very narrow confines of what is okay to teach based on the state curriculum standards (usually there is a legislative code). As teachers can, and have!, gotten fired if too many of their kids fail the state assessments. Many of the kids that are at my schools also never GET homework - everything is done entirely in their classes.
I also think that schools are more unsafe now than when I was in school, honestly, some of the garbage that goes on there would have gotten kids kicked out of school when I was attending. School administrators aren't allowed to do things like that anymore. Parenting is also another issue, for every 2 parents I get that are fabulous, amazing, and wonderful to work with, I get 8 that don't care one way or the other. It's very frustrating to me. While I haven't personally worked in dirty schools, there ARE a great many that are outdated and with the funding cuts they just don't have the money to keep up the building, the staff, the materials, and everything else. It's really sad.
-
If you ever need some support from a fellow Homeschooling parent feel free to PM me!! :lovey:
first of all thank you so much i will do.
secondly i agree that each child should be able to chosse wear they go school or home and if my son or daughter want to go to school later on then i shall do what it takes to get them there.
i shall keep in mind everything everyone said on here
-
Hey, sorry, I wasn't directing this at anyone here. =)
No worries. I didn't think you were directing your comment at any of the ponies posting here. ;)
If you ever need some support from a fellow Homeschooling parent feel free to PM me!! :lovey:
first of all thank you so much i will do.
Anytime. :)
-
I an honestly say that I went through my entire schooling career in one of the "best" school districts in the country. Socially, I had three friends, and honestly it was beause the calibur of people available in the school to socialize with was...lacking. I have high standards of behavior I guess. You know, I didn't drink, smoke, or have sex. Oh and drugs were right out. So that eliminated 98.8% of the population, thus leaving me with five friends. Plus TWO from middle school! (One of which moved to PA and one of which became home schooled!) Wow. So there goes the argument for public schools being a socaial haven. At least in this (super awesome) School district I'm in.
My Brother is currently going through the same hgh school I went through, and has all A's and B's in his subjects EXCEPT for algebra which he is failing. He is highly functioning Apergers, and has an IEP plan which his algebra teacher is staunchly ignoring. His teacher, councilor, and principals areCONSTANTLY ignoring and passing the buck on to the next person whenever my mother emails them about trying tosolve the problem. Oh, and did I mention that this teacher is the SAME one that taught ME?
Every day I (he) we roamed the halls thanks to redrawn district lines, we have (had) to deal with the constant presence of lowlifes who made it a daily hobby to start fights in the hall. I can tell you from personal experience that you haven't LIVED until you've gotten stuck in the middle of a Latina catfight with an 8 high stack of books in your arms. Terrifying. @_@
So, when you stack the factors of burnt out uncaring teachers, unsavory student populations (of EVERY RACE), poor standards of education, and just a general feeling of failure; go ahead, ask me if I'll home school my son.
YES. I will. He can join swim teams, Boy Scouts, church groups, service groups, tennis teams, choruses, kids' theater groups, WHATEVER his heart desires, but he will not step FOOT in a public school. We will meet with local home shool groups for socialization, and he can have whatever activities he wants otherwise, but public school is out of the question. As far as I'm concerned, its my responsibility as a parent to make the big decisions for him as far as his welfare goes. If we move to a more desireable district where the kids act like human beings instead of monsters, I may reconsider. But until then, I think I'm pretty dead set on home schooling him.
-
bunny after reading that i do not blame you at all it sounds scary.
when i put this up here it was just to see who was and would and to find out why i had no idea that so many people had bad schools around them or expriences in school it just makes you wonder why school has to be so bad.
dont get me wrong there are some fantastic schools out there and some children do better than others. im not saying home schooling should be done by everyone god no not everyone wants to or can im just saying im glad ive done it, and those whos children love going to school and are doing well thats brillant it proves some schools are great.
the schools close to us here are well how would you put it not to my liking at all so im glad we have home schooled.
-
I went to one of the best school districts in the country (the same one my kids are attending), and I never experienced any problems. I loved going to school. True, there were the trouble kids (as there are in every school), but the majority of the student population was pretty even tempered. Bullying was rare, horrible teachers did get replaced (I know, I had a bad one for Algebra II and she was replaced the following year), and most of the kids wanted to do well to go to college. *shrugs*
At the school my daughter attends now there is high parent participation in everything, an active program to promote being a peacemaker instead of a bully, and teachers and yard duties alike will give kids notes to take home when they catch them doing something positive (like pick up trash, or being nice on the playground, or being helpful to another kid) to promote positive reinforcement of good behavior. So I don't think all hope is lost for public schools.
I might add that I used to teach private art classes from my home studio in the afternoons to school-aged children. About half of my students were home-schooled kids, and I often had the most discipline problems arise from them. They had a different frame of reference socially from my other students who went to public or private schools, and they had authority issues (they were always the ones back-talking to me and I constantly was discussing their behavior with their parents. I mean really, it's an art class. Why so argumentative?) I'm sure not all home-schooled kids are like that, but that was just my experience with them. Right now I definitely take our great public school over the option of home schooling.
-
Reading through this thread is starting to make me remember my days in public high school...
As I said before, I went to a private Christian school for 7th-10th grade. My parents would threaten to send me to public school if I didn't make good grades at said private school (tuition was crazy expensive!). After 4 years of only having one good friend and constantly being picked on and sent to the headmaster for being the odd-kid out (I was the weird kid who liked anime, manga, and video games. People at that school thought all of that was "the devil".) I'd finally had enough and I asked my parents to put me in the public high school in our area. It was fun for a while. I got to meet up with people I hadn't seen since 6th grade and we sort of formed our own little "clique". To me, it was much better than private school. I actually had friends and I wasn't being picked on for being odd.
Now that I look back on it, I really don't think it was all that great. Sure, I had friends, but I don't really feel like I learned anything and just the atmosphere was... It felt like I was in a prison. I saw people being put in handcuffs by the security guards on several occasions, there were fights, I saw kids being outright disrespectful to the administrators when they were being escorted to the main office for causing trouble, there was a rather large drug problem... One guy in my math class in 11th grade had a rather large back of weed in his pocket and he felt the need to show it to me! ><
My biggest gripe was that some of the teachers just had no idea how to teach. My 11th grade US history teacher would just read off of PowerPoint slides and make us take notes. There was nothing interesting or exciting about it and this is coming from someone who LOVES history. Even though the class was a subject I liked, the teacher's teaching method just made it so dry and boring. Half of the class was failing! Then there was my 12th grade math teacher. Math is not my strongest point, so I picked the senior math class that everyone said was a breeze. They must have had a different teacher because this guy was just... ugh! His teaching method was just deplorable. He never explained anything clearly and when someone asked a question, he'd repeat what he'd just said, ask the person if they had been listening, then move on with the lesson. He always said he was available after school for extra help, but when I went to his classroom after school, he was NEVER there! I had a friend who was in another one of his math classes, and he got a recording on his phone of the teacher practically screaming at the class and calling them stupid because they didn't understand the material. Not sure if the recording was ever presented to the principal or not. I asked my guidance counselor if I could switch to the lower level of that class (the one with the better teacher. I don't remember what the level below CP was at my high school) and she flat out said no even after I told her about all the problems I had been having. I ended up failing the class and had to take it in summer school, meaning that I didn't get to graduate with m class and had to graduate out of summer school. I'm also convinced that teacher stole my cell phone. I left it in his classroom and when I went back to ask him about it, he said he didn't find a cell phone anywhere.
*breathes* And there's my public high school horror story. I shudder to think what that school is like now. I want to go back and visit my crime scene science teacher but I'm afraid the kids there now are much worse than the ones I went to school with. ><
I wouldn't wish public high school on anyone's children.