Which Minty?

[Shaiyeh]

All the Minties.

[Evening_Moonstone]

[img2]http://i.chzbgr.com/completestore/2012/4/5/c12a33ae-5706-4692-90ad-d8e61e004cd7.jpg[/img2]
Sorry, that's all I could think of what I saw your post, Miss Tuneful!
 

[hathorcat]

G1...easy - the original, the best...!!!!

[Flitter]

Mint green is my fav. color so naturally I like them all but I only collect G4 and I love the brightness of her colors, so G4 Minty is my favorite. Gosh I hope we see a release of her soon.
I would really love to see a G4 pony with a shamrock cutie mark someday too.

[tinrobo]

I like them all! Minty is a lovely pony. <3

[MLPMegaLover]

G1 It's more cute. I don't like G3 and G4 Minty.

[Lon-san]

G4 Minty. I'm so sorry G1. I'm blinded by my need to possess her and those big shiny eyes. If it's any consolation, I wish G4 had inherited your awsome butt-clovers instead of the candies and you are still one of my favorite G1s ever.

G3, I don't care for your heehawing first pose but love you regardless. Just not as much as the other two. Oh well.

[lovesbabysquirmy]

G3 Donkey Pose Minty!  I'd also love the TAF one...

[Rococo]

I like G3 Minty the most followed by G4 Minty, who just needs to see the light of day, Hasbro.

[Sora]

G3 Minty! I love her personality too

[Baby Sugarberry]

There is only one real Minty, G1 forever!

[Firehooves]

As a toy? G1 Minty. As a character? G3 Minty

[partypony566]

G1 every single time, the original and the best

[WickedWonderland]

G4 Minty.

I think the G3 Minty usually has white streaks in her hair as well.

[Ice Crystal]

It's a tie between G3 and G4.