The MLP Arena

Pony Talk => Pony Corral => Topic started by: Mana Minori on January 06, 2018, 10:40:30 AM

Title: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Mana Minori on January 06, 2018, 10:40:30 AM
 As rumors of gen 5 generate with the presence of leaks, and the inevitable conclusion of FiM draws near, I-like many, wonder what lies ahead for the future of this pastel pony franchise. With 36 years of history behind it, I am not worried in the least that it will continue on, bringing joy and smiles to the next generation. But what potential does the future generation hold? Well, perhaps we may have been given a foregleam through the season finale of MLP: FiM’s season 7, where ponies of the present are able to summon the pony pillars of harmony from the past, to live in their era. Now, there is a concern that the farther we advance into new generations, the past generations and its history could be lost and forgotten. But by bringing the past into the present, there is less chance of this happening.

The lyrics of an anime called Digimon Frontier explain this quite well:

“we look to the past
As we head towards the future
To reclaim the Digital world

With faith in ourselves
And trust in each other
We live by the lessons we learned”

Furthermore, the theme of this show is kids in the present use the power of the world’s guardians of the past to help save the world in the present, in a similar vein to FiM with its elements of harmony, and then literally dragging the guardians back from the past to live their lives in the modern day. This gives me hope that generation 5, whenever it comes, will incorporate the same “Past meets present” concept, but in a new way. (We've gotten names pulled from past pony genedations that were incorporated in the present, but their characters and personalities were completely reimagined) Digimon’s characters use devices that hold the DNA data of the pillars of the past, and can temporarily become the protectors of the past, using their appearance and powers. While that doesn’t quite seem fitting for My Little Pony, something similar can be done for generation 5.

With a rich history to draw on, and many branches on the MLP franchise’s tree, I would certainly like to see the more obscure gens and spinoffs get due attention with gen5.

For instance, while generation 1 is moderately known and somewhat respected by those fans in gen4, very few (if any) know of its roots that lie in a Japanese branch of MLP  done by toy company Takara (now Takara Tomy) which produced an adorable, region exclusive, version of ponies known as “Mai Ritoruu Ponii” (My Stylish Pony), with a cast of 4 characters- Pinky and Milky being the main 2, and their friends,  Lily and Popo coming into the picture later. With these g1 characters being region exlusive, having a very limited distribution,  and never even having their own animated tv series, I think that giving them a fair shot and incoporating them in fun ways with the characters in g5 could benefit both the fans of these old and obscure ponies, but also the next generation. 

Similarly,  the ponies of generation 2, which was known as “Friendship Gardens”, could benefit from the same treatment, and be incorporated into generation 5. Though starting off as a toyline in the U.S., their molds were not taken too well, production was stopped, (though I think they are the most realistic in appearance to real horses, and are really cute), and they were given a warmer welcome in Europe for a longer period of time. As a result, these ponies also left without ever having their own animated series, but only a computer game. Generation 5 could, once again, incorporate the ponies of this past gen in creative ways, as Digimon Frontier and the season 7 finale of MLP gen4 has done.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Zapper on January 06, 2018, 11:02:15 AM
I have talked about this at length in the leaks thread already, so I'll sum up what I hope/wish for (not necessarily think it'll happen):

-New characters
-More pony species (canon flutterponies or seaponies would be nice)
-Pony design should make use of longer snouts again, anything other than the humanoid front view the cartoon G4s have right now
-No sickly thin or steroid ponies
-Less gendering of colors, hairstyles or bodytypes. I would actually love it if they went G2 and made the male ponies look like the females. Never understood why G4 stallions are often regular horse colors with choppy manes. They're MLP, they should be pretty/pastelly
-Less pop culture shout-outs that ultimately date the show. No pony stand-ins for real life people or popular characters on other shows.
-Better toy tie-ins. I want to see most of the show characters on shelves and not just a core cast.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Leave a Whisper on January 06, 2018, 11:15:52 AM
You should check out the G5 Speculation thread Nightmare Muffin! You'll laugh till you cry. Especially since some of the jokey predictions came true in G4. Like the Potato Pony.

My hopes:
Better toys
A horsey design
Appeals to kids again
A better cartoon look
New cast of  characters
All proper pony species
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Zapper on January 06, 2018, 11:31:30 AM
Like the Potato Pony.

Sad that some of the pics are not working anymore, that thread is an MLP comedy classic. But when was there a potato pony in G4?
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Mana Minori on January 06, 2018, 11:37:14 AM
You should check out the G5 Speculation thread Nightmare Muffin! You'll laugh till you cry. Especially since some of the jokey predictions came true in G4. Like the Potato Pony.

My hopes:
Better toys
A horsey design
Appeals to kids again
A better cartoon look
New cast of  characters
All proper pony species
care to throw up a link?
Potato pony???
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: TheBeatlesPkmnFan42 on January 06, 2018, 11:44:43 AM
What I want out of G5:

1 - More Ponies!

Without having a set of ponies getting way more releases than the others. No exclusively releasing a limited amount of ponies for an extended amount of time like the Core 7, or an overwhelmingly large amount of releases for some ponies over others like the Mane 6. If it must have "core" ponies, have it like earlier G3 where characters are still plentiful and give the "core" ponies a couple more releases, like what earlier G3 did with Pinkie Pie, Sunny Daze, Wysteria, etc.

2 - More Poses!

G1 - G3 (pre-Core 7) had a wide variety of poses (G1 and G3 especially), and I would like to see that return. G4.5 has been a step above G4 in the pose department, but the basic standing pose is still more common than everything else, and I'd like to see that issue go away entirely.

3 - Good balance between Earth, Unicorns, and Pegasi

G1 and G4 are pretty good with having a relatively even amount of the main pony types. G2 was very heavily leaning toward Earth ponies with very few Unicorns and no Pegasi (clip-on wings don't count, dang it!). G3 was a tad better, but was still primarily Earth ponies, with not as many Unicorns or Pegasi (Unicorns were especially lacking here). I want to see a nice balance like G1 and G4 have with the three main species.

Beyond that, I also want to see a wider variety of other non-main pony species like we see in G1. Stuff like Flutter Ponies, Wingers, Sea Ponies etc.

4 - Bigger ponies!

G4s are too small, I'd like ponies the size of G1s or G3s again!

----

I don't really have too much of a preference when it comes to the designs of the ponies themselves. I love the designs of all the generations so far, G3.5 included, so I'd probably be content with whatever appearance they ultimately decide on. What I care most about is pony and pose variety above all else.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Al-1701 on January 06, 2018, 11:52:39 AM
I have talked about this at length in the leaks thread already, so I'll sum up what I hope/wish for (not necessarily think it'll happen):

-New characters
-More pony species (canon flutterponies or seaponies would be nice)
-Pony design should make use of longer snouts again, anything other than the humanoid front view the cartoon G4s have right now
-No sickly thin or steroid ponies
-Less gendering of colors, hairstyles or bodytypes. I would actually love it if they went G2 and made the male ponies look like the females. Never understood why G4 stallions are often regular horse colors with choppy manes. They're MLP, they should be pretty/pastelly
-Less pop culture shout-outs that ultimately date the show. No pony stand-ins for real life people or popular characters on other shows.
-Better toy tie-ins. I want to see most of the show characters on shelves and not just a core cast.
This is definitely my list.  I'd also add some more love for G1 characters.

I'd also get away from the pony control everything approach Friendship is Magic had.  It was a nice bit of whimsy in the first season, but it lost its novelty rather quickly.  I'd also like to see something other than Greek mythology form the backbone of the world.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: poniesthatsparkle on January 06, 2018, 11:59:26 AM
My hopes for G5 are:

Variety in the toys
One reason I'm tired of G4 is how similar all the toys are. Not only do we see so many repeats of the same characters, each release of the toys is almost indistinguishable from the others. The gimmicks aren't interesting, let alone the characters. I'm hoping G5 will be more like G1 or G3 where we got so many unique ponies and gimmicks without all them being so similar.

Better quality toys
I know I'm not the only one who hates how cheaply ponies these days are made, especially when it comes to the hair. I want larger ponies with softer hair that looks nice straight out of the packaging. I don't care if I'd have to pay more for better ponies. I'm just tired of cheap ponies.

A new cast of characters
The Mane Six have run their course. I feel like there's no way to continue working with these characters. They've learned all they can, yet Hasbro is still milking them. I want to see some fresh new faces in G5, not updated versions of the current ponies.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Safflower on January 06, 2018, 12:19:00 PM
I have talked about this at length in the leaks thread already, so I'll sum up what I hope/wish for (not necessarily think it'll happen):

-New characters
-More pony species (canon flutterponies or seaponies would be nice)
-Pony design should make use of longer snouts again, anything other than the humanoid front view the cartoon G4s have right now
-No sickly thin or steroid ponies
-Less gendering of colors, hairstyles or bodytypes. I would actually love it if they went G2 and made the male ponies look like the females. Never understood why G4 stallions are often regular horse colors with choppy manes. They're MLP, they should be pretty/pastelly
-Less pop culture shout-outs that ultimately date the show. No pony stand-ins for real life people or popular characters on other shows.
-Better toy tie-ins. I want to see most of the show characters on shelves and not just a core cast.
This plus bigger toys, more poses, and animals that actually look like horses.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Leave a Whisper on January 06, 2018, 12:22:56 PM
Like the Potato Pony.

Sad that some of the pics are not working anymore, that thread is an MLP comedy classic. But when was there a potato pony in G4?

Hmm. Can't seem to find the G5 Speculation Thread. That's sad. Its comedy gold! I did find the link to the Potato Head Pony however.

http://mlparena.com/index.php?topic=384209.0
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Miniature Sheep on January 06, 2018, 01:03:43 PM
Is this the thread perchance? I'm getting quite a few good chuckles out of it! :D http://mlparena.com/index.php/topic,339554.msg923149.html

(Ugh, my computer decided to post before I'd finished writing - why?!)
My hopes for G5 have pretty much already been covered:
- Decent quality toys
- Variety of characters
- Enough with the pop culture wink-and-nudge (holding my hands up, I have a snobby attitude about that in general)
- Variety of colours - nothing wrong with pink and purple, but it'd be nice to see a wider range of colour combinations
- Gimmicks. Even if it's just recurring stuff like ponies with butterfly wings, I love a gimmicky pony!
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Leave a Whisper on January 06, 2018, 01:05:55 PM
Is this the thread perchance? I'm getting quite a few good chuckles out of it! :D http://mlparena.com/index.php/topic,339554.msg923149.html

My hopes for G5

That's the one! Way to go taproot! :woot:
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Zapper on January 06, 2018, 01:18:41 PM
Like the Potato Pony.

Sad that some of the pics are not working anymore, that thread is an MLP comedy classic. But when was there a potato pony in G4?

Hmm. Can't seem to find the G5 Speculation Thread. That's sad. Its comedy gold! I did find the link to the Potato Head Pony however.

http://mlparena.com/index.php?topic=384209.0

Omg Potarity! She is a thing of beauty and should be in G5.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Leave a Whisper on January 06, 2018, 01:26:25 PM
Like the Potato Pony.

Sad that some of the pics are not working anymore, that thread is an MLP comedy classic. But when was there a potato pony in G4?

Hmm. Can't seem to find the G5 Speculation Thread. That's sad. Its comedy gold! I did find the link to the Potato Head Pony however.

http://mlparena.com/index.php?topic=384209.0

Omg Potarity! She is a thing of beauty and should be in G5.
I called it Rari-tater.  :lmao:
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: invaderhorizongreen on January 06, 2018, 01:35:58 PM
I am all for more diversity and better quality toys period.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Lilja on January 06, 2018, 01:42:40 PM
The current main characters are going to cross over into the next generation, I think that's unavoidable. It happened between G3 and G4, and for the current generation there are more kids attached to these characters than ever before. My hope is that the characters will be reimagined enough that they still feel fresh, and that the main cast does not have to stay exactly the same. Even if all of the mane 6 return in some form or other, I would like to see some new additions to the main cast.

For the show I'm not sure there's much I'd like to see changed. I think Hasbro really values having a show as a marketing device for MLP at this point. If the current staff stays and tries to learn from their mistakes from the last series, I'm sure it'll be fine. Although I doubt they'll be able to top FIM (flawed as it is, for an MLP show I think it's been very well written). The next show probably won't run for 8+ seasons in any case.

As for what I'd like from the toys. I feel I have to be somewhat realistic in what to expect, the toy market has changed a lot since I was a kid. Variation would be nice, not just in colors and poses, but I also think it would be fun to see ponies of different sizes, shapes and facial expressions. I don't need there to be huge amount of characters, and certainly not if the characters are going to look similar anyway. I'd like to see more attention paid to the accessories, since those have been pretty mediocre for most of G4. I'd like to see more animals/creatures other than ponies included in the line, but I don't think that's very likely to happen. Especially now that Hasbro has Littlest Pet Shop for that.

For instance, while generation 1 is moderately known and somewhat respected by those fans in gen4, very few (if any) know of its roots that lie in a Japanese branch of MLP  done by toy company Takara (now Takara Tomy) which produced an adorable, region exclusive, version of ponies known as “Mai Ritoruu Ponii” (My Stylish Pony), with a cast of 4 characters- Pinky and Milky being the main 2, and their friends,  Lily and Popo coming into the picture later. With these g1 characters being region exlusive, having a very limited distribution,  and never even having their own animated tv series, I think that giving them a fair shot and incoporating them in fun ways with the characters in g5 could benefit both the fans of these old and obscure ponies, but also the next generation. 
I love the Takara MLPs personally, but I doubt anyone at Hasbro is aware of them. And even if they were, they'd have no reason to reference them. And even if they wanted to, how would they even do it? There's very little to pull from. We have a character named Pinkie, even if it's by coincidence, I think that's the closest we could realistically get. :)
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Deep Purple Crystal on January 06, 2018, 02:41:53 PM
As the original creator of the G5 speculation thread (honestly, I have no idea how it spiralled into the beautiful insanity that it did, but 'twas definitely for the better), I feel the need to step in here and give my own hopes for G5:

- An entire set of potato ponies. Hasbro did good by giving us one, but it's not enough. An opportunity the size of a 3,000,000-piece alicorn is being missed here. Hasbro could issue a special collector set of the famous and beloved Potater Six (Potato Pie, Rootvegetable Dash, Tubershy, Taterjack, Potarity and Twilight Starchle) and they'd literally be printing money (with bonus collector tear vial for teaching little girls the value of watering their beloved toys). But why stop there? It isn't enough. There will never be enough potato ponies. Because potatoes.
- Larger pony eyes. We don't want to visually impair the poor equines by asking for smaller eye sizes, now do we? Remember, "open up your eyeeeeesss..."
- Longer pony names. Teaching kids the value of quality vocabulary is important. How will a pony named 'Fizzy' or some other stuff like that compare to the loquaciously resplendently descriptive name that is Princess Sparkle Sweetie Apple Cutie Dazzle Glitterbelle Sprinkles?
- Even more limited distribution. People really should get off their flanks and pursue that collecting passion of theirs. Damn, I've always wanted to visit Outer Mongolia on camelback anyway.
- Every pony is a princess. Because everyone is special. Eveeeeryone...
- Every single pony should be sold with major imperfections (heads may not be included - good luck finding the special 1-head extension pack at select bargain stores in western Siberia for $145!) at the price of $50 apiece to remind little girls of the important message that life isn't perfect, they should learn to deal with it anyway. Like a princess.
- Wider variety of profession playsets. What four-year-old kid doesn't want a nice Builder Applejack? Princess power drill included may not be safe for children under 21 years.
- Smaller ponies. Teaching kids to embrace the wonders of microscopes and science is a beautiful thing.
- More pink. More pink is more pink. Pink is more, thus more is pink. It's a symbiotic staple of the universe as we know it.
Of course, this will all come crashing down on the Doomsday of 2026, when Minty shall have her revenge, and hereafter all ponies shall be mint green and all shall come with socks and a new golden green age will descend upon the earth, causing a flourish of fluffy sock-adorned unicorns to descend from the sky dancing upon green rainbows and joyously singing the musical numbers from A Very Minty Christmas on repeat.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Jorgito93 on January 06, 2018, 02:47:38 PM

Of course, this will all come crashing down on the Doomsday of 2026, when Minty shall have her revenge, and hereafter all ponies shall be mint green and all shall come with socks and a new golden green age will descend upon the earth, causing a flourish of fluffy sock-adorned unicorns to descend from the sky dancing upon green rainbows and joyously singing the musical numbers from A Very Minty Christmas on repeat.

This wouldn't even bother me tbh
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Zapper on January 06, 2018, 03:10:33 PM
- Smaller ponies. Teaching kids to embrace the wonders of microscopes and science is a beautiful thing.
I've always wanted to inhale them!  :lol:

- More pink. More pink is more pink. Pink is more, thus more is pink.
Sounds like G3 Pinkie brought this back etched in a stone plate.

Of course, this will all come crashing down on the Doomsday of 2026, when Minty shall have her revenge, and hereafter all ponies shall be mint green and all shall come with socks and a new golden green age will descend upon the earth, causing a flourish of fluffy sock-adorned unicorns to descend from the sky dancing upon green rainbows and joyously singing the musical numbers from A Very Minty Christmas on repeat.

I wouldn't mind this either. Minty is the best character this franchise has ever birthed, imo. We should all worship her. Minty 4 Santa 2026!
Spoiler
visitors can't see pics , please register or login

"This is my flesh" - depiction of St. Minty breaking the cake with apostle Kimono
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Safflower on January 06, 2018, 03:23:25 PM
XD :lmao: Minty 4 Santy 2026 for sure! I can't wait for Greenie Pie, Green Applejack, Emerald Rarity, Green Dash, Grasshoppershy, and Twilight Green!
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Flitter on January 06, 2018, 03:56:53 PM
Shopkins beat you to your G5 design, Hasbro!
visitors can't see pics , please register or login


resemblance to the leaked image much?
Spoiler
visitors can't see pics , please register or login




Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: sd_dreamcrystal on January 06, 2018, 04:03:53 PM
Shopkins beat you to your G5 design, Hasbro!
visitors can't see pics , please register or login

Ok I got to find this now! Strange MLP copycats I need!
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: TheBeatlesPkmnFan42 on January 06, 2018, 04:04:48 PM
Shopkins beat you to your G5 design, Hasbro!
visitors can't see pics , please register or login


resemblance to the leaked image much?
Spoiler
visitors can't see pics , please register or login






Hah, that looks pretty cute!
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Al-1701 on January 06, 2018, 05:24:45 PM
Shopkins beat you to your G5 design, Hasbro!
visitors can't see pics , please register or login


resemblance to the leaked image much?
Spoiler
visitors can't see pics , please register or login
This is what they get for not bothering to innovate for ten years and just resting on the fame of their property.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Leave a Whisper on January 06, 2018, 05:34:03 PM
Shopkins beat you to your G5 design, Hasbro!
visitors can't see pics , please register or login


resemblance to the leaked image much?
Spoiler
visitors can't see pics , please register or login

She's pretty cute! Love all the little extras.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Zapper on January 06, 2018, 05:48:28 PM
Whoa, that looks like Pinkie became a lolita model nurse.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Leave a Whisper on January 06, 2018, 06:13:47 PM
Whoa, that looks like Pinkie became a lolita model nurse.

If she had a normal horse head, it would balance out the big hooves and long legs.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: sd_dreamcrystal on January 06, 2018, 09:33:11 PM
Apparently some sneak peeks of those ponies were posted on youtube and on another site.
*wants to keep an eye out for the releases lol*
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Leave a Whisper on January 06, 2018, 09:34:30 PM
Apparently some sneak peeks of those ponies were posted on youtube and on another site.
*wants to keep an eye out for the releases lol*

Ooh do tell!
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Taffeta on January 07, 2018, 01:19:59 AM
This discussion continues to prove that ponypeople are a tiiiiny bit eccentric ;) and would probably terrify Hasbro ;)

In serious terms, I wouldn't want Hasbro to touch Takara ponies as an inspiration. Moreover, they're not going to. Takara ponies happened in 1985, and were Takara licencing the MLP brand from Hasbro to sell their own toys. Many Nirvana ponies were made by other companies under licence but Takara is probably the most extremely separate because absolutely no aspect of the packaging resembles anything G1. Also, even the Japanese barely know what Takara ponies are (trust me on that). More Japanese people grew up with mainstream G1 ponies due to travelling with families to America or Europe because of a parents' work position than did with Takara ponies, which basically says everything to me about the Takara ponies. If they were more common they would be less expensive, but even in Japan they are not easy to find and as lot of people don't know about them. Hasbro are not going to base their entire product on a toy design that essentially failed in the bigger picture, because a handful of G1 collectors like them. I mean, they basically imported the themes of Jem into MLP EQG because Jem failed as a toyline in the 1980s, and Jem was much more widely known and available than something like Takara (as well as being made by Hasbro).

My hopes for G5, if there is one would be...
-Kill the mane six concept entirely and go back to individual ponies with individual identities
Hopefully kill the current mane 6 characters too, or most of them. Applejack is the only one I find acceptable to carry through because of her long heritage through the generations.
-Bring out more variety of ponies, styles, and characters each year, rather than repetition.
-Unicorns, pegasus ponies - yes. Alicorns -no. It's overkill, we don't need it and never did.

I don't care if there is a TV show, but I'd like Hasbro to do more to promote the individual stories of each pony beyond the TV show. I don't mind if G5 look at all like G1 or not, but I would like a toy line for which the toy is primary and the TV series secondary advertising again. When the TV show becomes primary, it creates crazy.

Alternatively, they could just take on DarkPurpleCrystal's entire suggestion list. It would at least be something to see if they did ;)
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Zapper on January 07, 2018, 03:30:15 AM
Whoa, that looks like Pinkie became a lolita model nurse.

If she had a normal horse head, it would balance out the big hooves and long legs.

I think it looks creepy either way. The MLP concepts have horsey torsos. This creature looks like she's wearing a corset.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Al-1701 on January 07, 2018, 06:02:28 AM
I think it's supposed to be a saddle, but yeah.  Wow does she pinch in at the waist.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: sd_dreamcrystal on January 07, 2018, 06:22:18 AM
Apparently some sneak peeks of those ponies were posted on youtube and on another site.
*wants to keep an eye out for the releases lol*

Ooh do tell!
Well after I typed up everything, I decided this would be better suited in ToyBox lol
So check for the topic there :D

*heads off to make the topic and leaves other speculation here!*
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Al-1701 on January 07, 2018, 05:20:47 PM
Something to chew on.  Can we have an actual queen this time?  Really, what many people probably think of when they hear "queen" is Queen Elizabeth II.  So, why not have the queen be a sweet grandmotherly type (who can kick all kinds of tail when her country is threatened like Majesty in G1)?
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Leave a Whisper on January 07, 2018, 05:28:11 PM
Something to chew on.  Can we have an actual queen this time?  Really, what many people probably think of when they hear "queen" is Queen Elizabeth II.  So, why not have the queen be a sweet grandmotherly type (who can kick all kinds of tail when her country is threatened like Majesty in G1)?

Novo wasn't a bad queen, she was willing to give a chance but she was willing to unleash queenly wrath when Twilight Dummy tried to screw her over.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Al-1701 on January 07, 2018, 05:56:53 PM
I'm talking about the ponies themselves.  No more abomination princesses.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Cadence on January 07, 2018, 06:07:39 PM
Like the Potato Pony.

Sad that some of the pics are not working anymore, that thread is an MLP comedy classic. But when was there a potato pony in G4?

Hmm. Can't seem to find the G5 Speculation Thread. That's sad. Its comedy gold! I did find the link to the Potato Head Pony however.

http://mlparena.com/index.php?topic=384209.0

Omg Potarity! She is a thing of beauty and should be in G5.
I called it Rari-tater.  :lmao:

I love these punny names!  :lol:

My hopes for G5:
- New characters
- G1 designs/characters brought into the G5 world
- No more Mane 6 (or have them grow up but not be the main characters)
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Mana Minori on January 07, 2018, 06:20:09 PM
Like the Potato Pony.

Sad that some of the pics are not working anymore, that thread is an MLP comedy classic. But when was there a potato pony in G4?

Hmm. Can't seem to find the G5 Speculation Thread. That's sad. Its comedy gold! I did find the link to the Potato Head Pony however.

http://mlparena.com/index.php?topic=384209.0

Omg Potarity! She is a thing of beauty and should be in G5.
I called it Rari-tater.  :lmao:

I love these punny names!  :lol:

My hopes for G5:
- New characters
- G1 designs/characters brought into the G5 world
- No more Mane 6 (or have them grow up but not be the main characters)
Tater Trot?
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Mana Minori on January 07, 2018, 06:22:02 PM
Something to chew on.  Can we have an actual queen this time?  Really, what many people probably think of when they hear "queen" is Queen Elizabeth II.  So, why not have the queen be a sweet grandmotherly type (who can kick all kinds of tail when her country is threatened like Majesty in G1)?

Novo wasn't a bad queen, she was willing to give a chance but she was willing to unleash queenly wrath when Twilight Dummy tried to screw her over.
Novo is a lot like Rosedust, I've notices.  Initially not wanting to help the outsiders, and foremost concerned with protecting her subjects, but softening up when she takes time to reconsider. I hope we get flutterponies in gen 5
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: WingsOfMasquerade on January 08, 2018, 04:43:28 PM
I have only 1 real wish:

Ponies that look like ponies in a variety of poses/colors/sizes.

Simple as that.

I am tired of emoji faces or circle smily faces on 4 legs.
Tired of the same 6 characters and nothing else.
I want pretty AND cute. Or even just pretty.

How hard is it to make horse face horses?
No more eye-flounder, no more human faces, no more backward bending 'arms', no more cash-grab cheap-o toys. (Looking at Chrysalis brushables and other horrible stuff where it was just like 'churn it out fools buy anything dur dur'. I want something I can get genuinely excited about owning and buying and collecting again.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: KarentheUnicorn on January 08, 2018, 05:01:06 PM

I will second the ponies that look like ponies aspect.

I really don't care about if the cartoon does or doesn't exist or change, it's intangible, I can take it or leave it. I like it, I watch it but as a toy collector it doesn't affect me as much as what is on the toy shelves. I'm more focused on the toy line. If Hasbro wants to make actual money, they'd invest more in good toys instead of the cartoon.

So that is what I hope for as a collector.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Mana Minori on January 08, 2018, 05:09:32 PM
I have only 1 real wish:

Ponies that look like ponies in a variety of poses/colors/sizes.

Simple as that.

I am tired of emoji faces or circle smily faces on 4 legs.
Tired of the same 6 characters and nothing else.
I want pretty AND cute. Or even just pretty.

How hard is it to make horse face horses?
No more eye-flounder, no more human faces, no more backward bending 'arms', no more cash-grab cheap-o toys. (Looking at Chrysalis brushables and other horrible stuff where it was just like 'churn it out fools buy anything dur dur'. I want something I can get genuinely excited about owning and buying and collecting again.
so basically, briging back Dream Beauties or Friendship Garden horses.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: KarentheUnicorn on January 08, 2018, 05:18:33 PM
I have only 1 real wish:

Ponies that look like ponies in a variety of poses/colors/sizes.

Simple as that.

I am tired of emoji faces or circle smily faces on 4 legs.
Tired of the same 6 characters and nothing else.
I want pretty AND cute. Or even just pretty.

How hard is it to make horse face horses?
No more eye-flounder, no more human faces, no more backward bending 'arms', no more cash-grab cheap-o toys. (Looking at Chrysalis brushables and other horrible stuff where it was just like 'churn it out fools buy anything dur dur'. I want something I can get genuinely excited about owning and buying and collecting again.
so basically, briging back Dream Beauties or Friendship Garden horses.

Technically pony is different from horse so I don't know that when collectors say ponies that look like ponies, they think Dream beauties.

Besides, G4 don't even really look like ponies, they look weirdly more like deer than pony (and I'm thinking about the toy not the cartoon).
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Leave a Whisper on January 08, 2018, 06:59:05 PM
I have only 1 real wish:

Ponies that look like ponies in a variety of poses/colors/sizes.

Simple as that.

I am tired of emoji faces or circle smily faces on 4 legs.
Tired of the same 6 characters and nothing else.
I want pretty AND cute. Or even just pretty.

How hard is it to make horse face horses?
No more eye-flounder, no more human faces, no more backward bending 'arms', no more cash-grab cheap-o toys. (Looking at Chrysalis brushables and other horrible stuff where it was just like 'churn it out fools buy anything dur dur'. I want something I can get genuinely excited about owning and buying and collecting again.


Yeeeesssss
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Taffeta on January 09, 2018, 02:23:44 AM
Something to chew on.  Can we have an actual queen this time?  Really, what many people probably think of when they hear "queen" is Queen Elizabeth II.  So, why not have the queen be a sweet grandmotherly type (who can kick all kinds of tail when her country is threatened like Majesty in G1)?

That kind of underrepresents the considerable number of European countries who have their own monarchic systems, and probably don't think of our Queen over their own. It's not like Britain is the only monarchy in Europe, or even the world.

I suspect Majesty probably was based around that concept, to be honest ;) albeit it's said that there are a lot of people who wouldn't want to mess with the Queen even at her age...
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Al-1701 on January 09, 2018, 03:22:19 AM
Something to chew on.  Can we have an actual queen this time?  Really, what many people probably think of when they hear "queen" is Queen Elizabeth II.  So, why not have the queen be a sweet grandmotherly type (who can kick all kinds of tail when her country is threatened like Majesty in G1)?

That kind of underrepresents the considerable number of European countries who have their own monarchic systems, and probably don't think of our Queen over their own. It's not like Britain is the only monarchy in Europe, or even the world.

I suspect Majesty probably was based around that concept, to be honest ;) albeit it's said that there are a lot of people who wouldn't want to mess with the Queen even at her age...
I meant she is probably the most globally recognized queen (especially ruling queen rather than wife of the king), there are obviously many of them across the world and history.  I just think the "people think of queens as evil" justification for making Celestia a princess was faulty.

I've always pictured Majesty as an older and stately lady.  She mostly stays in her castle because she is physically delicate in her old age and she can use her powerful magic to help her young subjects from there with her magic mirror.  However, when a crisis compels her to leave her sanctuary and deal with it personally, Hell is five steps behind her.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Taffeta on January 09, 2018, 03:33:14 AM
Something to chew on.  Can we have an actual queen this time?  Really, what many people probably think of when they hear "queen" is Queen Elizabeth II.  So, why not have the queen be a sweet grandmotherly type (who can kick all kinds of tail when her country is threatened like Majesty in G1)?

That kind of underrepresents the considerable number of European countries who have their own monarchic systems, and probably don't think of our Queen over their own. It's not like Britain is the only monarchy in Europe, or even the world.

I suspect Majesty probably was based around that concept, to be honest ;) albeit it's said that there are a lot of people who wouldn't want to mess with the Queen even at her age...
I meant she is probably the most globally recognized queen (especially ruling queen rather than wife of the king), there are obviously many of them across the world and history.  I just think the "people think of queens as evil" justification for making Celestia a princess was faulty.


I think there are reasons for that, largely that the originating country doesn't really see the point in a Queen, since they got rid of the monarchy a long time ago. Evil queens have thus dominated popular fiction since. I think that's why Majesty was dominant in the stories here but occluded in the US. It wasn't as culturally relevant to use her in that context.

In my childhood canon, Majesty had gone a bit senile and Sapphire ruled in her stead (when she wasn't trying to stop her mother turning everything into chaos). But I was a bit odd as a kid. I don't think Majesty was ever an evil queen. She was just the figure of authority and as you say, if she got serious, that was it for the bad guy. But it did also explain why people wanted to steal her invisibility shoes (eat your heart out Harry Potter) and her magic mirror. She did have some pretty cool stuff, as well her endless collection of sing-songy unicorn spells...
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: KarentheUnicorn on January 09, 2018, 06:20:28 AM
I seem to remeber something in context of queen in association with g4 as to why celestia is a princess and not a queen. It was some nonsense about kids seeing queen as negative or something like that.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Mana Minori on January 09, 2018, 06:29:00 AM
I seem to remeber something in context of queen in association with g4 as to why celestia is a princess and not a queen. It was some nonsense about kids seeing queen as negative or something like that.
yup, that's it exactly. Becuse kids have been brainwashed by Disney to believe that.  But even now, Isney is backpedaling by making QUEEN Elsa from Frozen, and throwing jabs at their own formula with what defines a Disney Princess, in Moana, with Maui's lnes of dialogue.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Taffeta on January 09, 2018, 07:09:38 AM
I find this interesting given that I do representation of stuff. I really wonder whether it's all about the Queen being something that the US associate with Britain, therefore previous colonial crimes and such like, and as a result, want to separate away from it as an 'evil' thing not democratically elected. Let's not forget that British characters/actors are also often villains in US shows, maintaining that slightly chilling upper class clinical stereotype (or the exact opposite. I find this hilarious xD).

I have noticed that when the President appears in kids shows, it's usually a positive portrayal. Correct me if I'm wrong. The one that sticks in my mind is that awful Jem episode with that awful song at the end, where the President helps save Synergy after Synergy and Jem help to save the President (and he's told Jem's secret). There are some not so positive representations of cold war Eastern Europe and monarchy in the series as well.

On the flip, though, it might not be the concept of monarchy at all. I mean, we do have a lot of royal fantasy coming out of the US in spite of the apparent dislike of Queens. It might be the idea of a Queen in her own right as being somehow too independent in the times past. When you consider Disney history and the really patronising presentation of female characters in the much older stuff, you can see where that idea might have come from, with 'evil' queens and innocent maidens or princesses who require a prince to rescue them. Then he would become King and by default, she'd be Queen. Which is really out of date, not least in real monarchies, where Queens have ruled in their own right for a very long time. (See Boudicca, Cleopatra. and others!)

Let's not forget that Hasbro didn't ever call Majesty Queen. Not even in the UK, although it was pretty much understood and a lot of the fantasy countries in the comic did have Queens or Kings or both.  Still Majesty never got that official title, which is interesting. Hasbro was fine with a lot of Princesses, which may suggest this is more about women holding the top spot than it is anything else...

Interesting food for thought, but I tend to agree that it's about time Ponyland had a Queen rather than a Princess, if indeed it needs a royal monarchy.

As for Disney, they have only just begun to get the point that a story doesn't need to have a Prince to marry for it to be a happy ever after. Frozen sort of began it, but Moana really broke away from the idea that a woman is only complete when she finds her prince and marries him. It makes me suspect that this is the real root core of it all - that princesses wait for princes, while Queens rule and we can't have women doing that O.O. now can we? ;)
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Al-1701 on January 09, 2018, 03:37:19 PM
I seem to remeber something in context of queen in association with g4 as to why celestia is a princess and not a queen. It was some nonsense about kids seeing queen as negative or something like that.
yup, that's it exactly. Becuse kids have been brainwashed by Disney to believe that.  But even now, Isney is backpedaling by making QUEEN Elsa from Frozen, and throwing jabs at their own formula with what defines a Disney Princess, in Moana, with Maui's lnes of dialogue.
That logic doesn't work either.  There have been a grand total of TWO evil queens in the Disney canon (and the Queen of Hearts was less so much evil as bat you know what insane) and both were based off their EUROPEAN origins.  The queen in Snow White isn't even evil in the context of being queen but being incredibly vein and jealous to the point of unhealthy obsession her step daughter is better looking than her.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Leave a Whisper on January 09, 2018, 04:40:49 PM
I seem to remeber something in context of queen in association with g4 as to why celestia is a princess and not a queen. It was some nonsense about kids seeing queen as negative or something like that.
yup, that's it exactly. Becuse kids have been brainwashed by Disney to believe that.  But even now, Isney is backpedaling by making QUEEN Elsa from Frozen, and throwing jabs at their own formula with what defines a Disney Princess, in Moana, with Maui's lnes of dialogue.
That logic doesn't work either.  There have been a grand total of TWO evil queens in the Disney canon (and the Queen of Hearts was less so much evil as bat you know what insane) and both were based off their EUROPEAN origins.  The queen in Snow White isn't even evil in the context of being queen but being incredibly vein and jealous to the point of unhealthy obsession her step daughter is better looking than her.

She did try to kill her  twice. That's pretty evil. A lot of Disney protags are usually raised by one parent anyway.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Al-1701 on January 09, 2018, 05:16:33 PM
I meant her evilness did not come out of her being queen but being the jealous stepmother.  Make her the mistress of a manor, and you've not really changed anything about the story.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Leave a Whisper on January 09, 2018, 05:44:02 PM
I meant her evilness did not come out of her being queen but being the jealous stepmother.  Make her the mistress of a manor, and you've not really changed anything about the story.

Yes I know that.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Zapper on February 10, 2018, 02:57:05 AM
I agree, give us a queen. In G4 they had King Sombra and Queen Chrysalis as evil rulers and the pony princesses and that yak prince as positive portrayals. It was lame. If one is a prince or princess it always begs the question "and where is the king?" :P
It implied that Celestia and Luna have a higher-up or boss instead of being the bosses themselves. Just dumb semantics, girls don't hate queens. They did QUEEN Novo and I didn't see any outrage from parents.

It was also interesting to see in the MLP movie that princess Skystar had no ruling power because her mum was sitting on the throne.
So if Celestia's parents suddenly appeared again (coming back from their forever vacation) they would just take over and it would be bye-bye filly :lol:
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Leave a Whisper on February 10, 2018, 06:43:23 AM
I hope for bigger ponies. At least Flutter or G3 size.

That they desist with deformity.

Diversity in pose, species, gender, color and sets.

No more main six

No more friendship

New characters

That Blindbags and moulded ponies will not take over the core line.

That it doesn't attract another mostly embarrassing and terrible fanbase.

That. it  panders to kids and not adults.

Screw Queen, I want an Empress!

Prince, Emperor and King Ponies.

I want Unipegs back.

Playsets that aren't Castles #1, #2 and #55. Variety people!

More green ponies.





Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Zapper on February 10, 2018, 07:12:40 AM
That. it  panders to kids and not adults.
(...)
I want Unipegs back.

You are an adult so if you want them to pander to kids they wouldn't do anything on your list because you are an adult who demanded it :lol:

Also I have no clue if "unipeg" was ever used in MLP canon but it's an ugly word, imo. It's like a pony with a peg leg. "'Tis my peg leg. I only have one so call me Unipeg. At your service!" :lol:
I wonder why we even need an extra word for it, it's literally a winged unicorn so why not call it that.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Miniature Sheep on February 10, 2018, 07:18:11 AM
All I have to say is...
...
Zodiac ponies.
*mic drop goes here*
...

Silliness aside, I think if they had a similar gimmick to the Glow 'n' Show ponies but with zodiac-themed symbols, they'd make a very fun set.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Leave a Whisper on February 10, 2018, 08:25:27 AM
That. it  panders to kids and not adults.
(...)
I want Unipegs back.

You are an adult so if you want them to pander to kids they wouldn't do anything on your list because you are an adult who demanded it :lol:

Also I have no clue if "unipeg" was ever used in MLP canon but it's an ugly word, imo. It's like a pony with a peg leg. "'Tis my peg leg. I only have one so call me Unipeg. At your service!" :lol:
I wonder why we even need an extra word for it, it's literally a winged unicorn so why not call it that.

You know what I mean. :p

I demand a pirate pegleg unipeg ye mutinous sea dog!

Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: otocolobus_manul on February 10, 2018, 08:36:22 AM
That. it  panders to kids and not adults.
(...)
I want Unipegs back.

You are an adult so if you want them to pander to kids they wouldn't do anything on your list because you are an adult who demanded it :lol:

Also I have no clue if "unipeg" was ever used in MLP canon but it's an ugly word, imo. It's like a pony with a peg leg. "'Tis my peg leg. I only have one so call me Unipeg. At your service!" :lol:
I wonder why we even need an extra word for it, it's literally a winged unicorn so why not call it that.

But it's not just a winged unicorn - it's technically a horned pegasus as well. Also

No more friendship

but why
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: otocolobus_manul on February 10, 2018, 08:37:33 AM
In all honesty, I hope they're digital just so I won't be tempted to collect them. I'm running out of display space and need to reign in my spending - I really don't need another generation of plastic to collect :lol:
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Leave a Whisper on February 10, 2018, 08:42:37 AM
@Zapper-I know its a flying unicorn. Eh I've been calling em unipegs for ages. Even wrote a story as a kid for a school project about the first unipeg ever born from a unicorn and pegasus parent.

@Mr. BrightSky-Because they force it down our throats too often. Makes Care Bears and Captain Planet look subtle when it comes to peddling life lessons.

Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Zapper on February 10, 2018, 08:46:49 AM
Ah so "unipeg" is a fanterm you want them to make canon  ;)

I guess I want them to have Flutterponies again. Some of them can have horns.


Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: sd_dreamcrystal on February 10, 2018, 08:52:31 AM
I kind of read a little on the queen stuff and I have to ask, as for MLP.. What about Queen Novo? I haven't watched the movie yet but she's a queen also XD
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Zapper on February 10, 2018, 09:06:50 AM
I kind of read a little on the queen stuff and I have to ask, as for MLP.. What about Queen Novo? I haven't watched the movie yet but she's a queen also XD

Yeah but when they were doing G4 concepts Lauren Faust wanted Celestia to be a queen and Hasbro was like "nope, girls don't want queens".
That was ages ago, so now they warmed up to the title and use it on positive characters like Novo.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Leave a Whisper on February 10, 2018, 10:04:33 AM
Ah so "unipeg" is a fanterm you want them to make canon  ;)

I guess I want them to have Flutterponies again. Some of them can have horns.

Not at all. Its just what I've called them since I was a kid. I'd rather they just be called Winged or Flying Unicorns tbh.  Alicorn sounds dumb.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Dreamer on February 10, 2018, 10:13:27 AM
Pegacorn?
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Leave a Whisper on February 10, 2018, 10:16:04 AM
Pegacorn?

The Majestic Horned Flap-flap Horsey.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Leave a Whisper on February 10, 2018, 10:17:23 AM
In all honesty, I hope they're digital just so I won't be tempted to collect them. I'm running out of display space and need to reign in my spending - I really don't need another generation of plastic to collect :lol:

Go stand in the corner and think about what you've said! :mad:


:silly:
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Zapper on February 10, 2018, 10:32:27 AM
Pegacorn?

Peggy's corn is the best corn in all of Equestria!
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Leave a Whisper on February 10, 2018, 11:04:13 AM
Pegacorn?

Peggy's corn is the best corn in all of Equestria!

 :lol:
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Sparkle Pony on February 10, 2018, 04:56:29 PM
I would really love some Pegasus toys with really gorgeous bird-like wings.  Something a bit less stylized and with a bit larger than we have had in previous generations.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Leave a Whisper on February 11, 2018, 07:43:13 AM
No more symbol equalling a pony's destiny. It's unbelievably stupid.

No more symbol-less foals.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Sunset on February 11, 2018, 09:22:18 AM
On that note, I do hope that other species have symbols.  G4 seems to have decided that only unicorns, Pegasus, and earth ponies are allowed to have them.  Even species that should be directly related to ponies, like the Breezies and the Hippogriffs, don't have them.  I really like the inclusion of the Hippogriffs, it's new and different but could still be made to be very pony with th right design.  So I hope in G5 they bring them back, make them not quite so leggy with hoof hair to help simulate the classic pony leg sillouhette and most importantly, symbols.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Khayman81 on February 11, 2018, 10:04:28 AM
I have to agree and put some more on the basket.
I bought a Twilight Sparkle just for the Spike she came with, and it was amazing how tiny she is, compared to my G1 and XXL G3 she is like microscopic. For strage and collecting it’s cool, but l could choke on her.
The yesterday l showed her to my bae saying “look how cute she is, so tiny....” and he replied “hum, she looks like a deer... l prefer the older ones, but tiny is nice”...
Please horse/pony like toys... or if you want to do deer-with-huge-eyes-like then out horns on it.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Taffeta on February 11, 2018, 10:57:30 AM
I now want a pirate wingyhorn. Not opposed to a three legged horse with an artificial leg. MH did it with Vandala. Why not?

 (I am actually now wondering why G4 has never had an on screen pony in any kind of wheelchair or similar, given the pushes the team are apparently making for voice diversity in G5, maybe they could consider this as well? Again, MH did it. And if the pony is too hard, then there's EQG and no real excuse not to do it except they haven't.)

I have never known what to call them either, but as a kid I had a colouring in sheet with a bunch of them on in classical style and I gave them all names and called them unicus ponies. O.o. Thinking back...not totally sure why that seemed more logical o.O.

On that note, I do hope that other species have symbols.  G4 seems to have decided that only unicorns, Pegasus, and earth ponies are allowed to have them.  Even species that should be directly related to ponies, like the Breezies and the Hippogriffs, don't have them.  I really like the inclusion of the Hippogriffs, it's new and different but could still be made to be very pony with th right design.  So I hope in G5 they bring them back, make them not quite so leggy with hoof hair to help simulate the classic pony leg sillouhette and most importantly, symbols.

Let's not forget that we've got to a point with FIM where it's fine for the ponies to go into other cultures (I'm thinking Gilda and company here), undermine their cultural structure and, after the loss of their significant relic, tell them that it's fine because they have friendship now. And we're getting a school where the ponies get to 'educate' everyone else as to the proper way to be friends. I have some problems with the implication of those messages to kids, which is why I really support what LAW said about no more friendship. Respect, yes. Respect and learning about other peoples/customs/culture and accepting difference - yes. But forcing your concept of friendship on others - not a fan. As for the CM thing, I guess if you don't come from a population that promotes friendship, you don't get a destiny. But on the other hand, you're not tied into a destiny, so maybe it's a good thing?
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Zapper on February 11, 2018, 11:01:24 AM
Taffeta, FiM had a pony in a cool steampunk wheelchair. You just didn't watch that episode.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Taffeta on February 11, 2018, 11:04:55 AM
Taffeta, FiM had a pony in a cool steampunk wheelchair. You just didn't watch that episode.

Ah, ok then. In that case comment retracted ;) But that is still one small sideline in a big franchise. There's no toy or anything like that. Maybe G5 can make a more rounded view of diversity overall without thrusting it as a social comment in someone's face. (Normalise it maybe?)

Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Sunset on February 11, 2018, 11:09:58 AM
OH, I definitly agree with getting rid of the cutie mark =destiny thing.  I just want pretty ponies with symbols.

And I also agree with loosening the ties of "friendship". Not that it is a bad thing in general.  But I would like more adventure and less reliance on every moral lesson having to be a friendship one.  Or even that every episode has to have a moral outside of maybe "teamwork."


I also hope we can move away from the more urban aspects of FiM and move more towards high fantasy.  That is one of the things I really like about some of the new concept art.  It really looks like it lends itself to a more fantasy type setting and not an urban one.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Zapper on February 11, 2018, 11:10:43 AM
The character was designed and voiced by a kid in a wheelchair as part of the Make A Wish foundation. That's why there is no toy.
Otherwise, I think Scootaloo is intended to be disabled. But they are skirting around the issue just like parent death can't be mentioned, same-sex couples can't be mentioned... etc.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: invaderhorizongreen on February 13, 2018, 11:37:56 AM
I would be happy with no store exclusive ponies the ONLY TRU around me within six hours is closing in April then there will be none near me.  My wall mart did not get ANY of the baby sea ponies and has 40+ boxes full of scenes of equestra singles. Even on mark down they are not selling, other than amazon I am sheer out of luck.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Taffeta on February 13, 2018, 12:38:55 PM
I would be happy with no store exclusive ponies the ONLY TRU around me within six hours is closing in April then there will be none near me.  My wall mart did not get ANY of the baby sea ponies and has 40+ boxes full of scenes of equestra singles. Even on mark down they are not selling, other than amazon I am sheer out of luck.

Baby Sea Ponies weren't store exclusives, were they? They sure weren't exclusives here, they've been everywhere, although wave 1 only appeared briefly on immediate clearance. ><
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Leave a Whisper on February 13, 2018, 01:23:16 PM
I would be happy with no store exclusive ponies the ONLY TRU around me within six hours is closing in April then there will be none near me.  My wall mart did not get ANY of the baby sea ponies and has 40+ boxes full of scenes of equestra singles. Even on mark down they are not selling, other than amazon I am sheer out of luck.

Baby Sea Ponies weren't store exclusives, were they? They sure weren't exclusives here, they've been everywhere, although wave 1 only appeared briefly on immediate clearance. ><

Not the first set. They popped up in Target and TrU, but I never saw em in Wal-Mart.
Title: Re: Hopes and speculation for gen 5
Post by: Al-1701 on February 13, 2018, 01:46:58 PM
This is show related, but I'm hoping they are more open to using the 10 minute episode format.  I felt like this last season of FiM had episodes were they could have been done in 10 minutes and were dragged out to 20 with tedious repetition.  By making some episodes 10 minutes, they could have more episode slots.  Though, I would also suggest more two-part stories as some stories could use two episodes as well.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal