I have just decided to place my whole wishlist here. I don't mind the ponies being loose, if they are in like new condition.
For all these ponies, I would like them to be like the characters in the TV show. So none of the fancy ones with marks on their faces or bodies please.
Shining Armor
Princess Cadance
Apple Bloom
Sweetie Belle
Scoot a Loo
Other Crusader classmates?
Twilight
Rarity
Rainbow Dash
Apple Jack
Fluttershy
Pinkie Pie
Princess Luna?
Princess Celestia?
Big Macintosh?
Princess Twilight (maybe)
If you have a few of these, I would consider any other unicorns too.