The MLP Arena

Pony Talk => Pony Corral => Topic started by: MintySocks on January 24, 2012, 08:46:24 PM

Title: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: MintySocks on January 24, 2012, 08:46:24 PM
Hi everypony! I've had this on my mind for a while, so I figured the only way to get answers is to ask. Maybe I'm clueless, but I got into MLP at the age of 3, and as an adult I'm still in it for the ponies. I love to see those colorful smiles staring back at me. The G4 FiM phenomenon was something I originally chose to ignore, and then I started watching the show with my kids and got sucked in. Happily so. I :heart: the show and I :heart: G4's now!


I love this community and a HUGE portion of the discussion involves FiM.  I hear the word "Bronies" a LOT. Call me a culturally ignorant bumpkin if you like, but... what's a Brony? I have been able to deduce that they're adults (quite a few of them men) who like MLP. Is that it? Or is there more to it?


Please, for the sake of pure information gathering, don't reply to this thread unless you ARE a brony.


Tell me...
1. How you got into MLP and why you like it.
2. Single? Married? Any dads? Any moms?
3. Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss?
4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations?
5. Any other pertinent facts I should know in order to truly understand what bronies are about!


Thanks in advance for helping me out with my curiosity about you all!  :cool:
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: will2Bfree on January 24, 2012, 09:43:15 PM
It's a common misconception that the term "brony" refers only to men. That is not so.

It's true the word formed as a mashup of "bro" and "pony", but girls can also be bronies. In short, it's really just any fan of the FiM cartoon. They just decided to give themselves a nickname, like trekkies. However, generally when one refers to bronies, they're referring to someone outside the show's target audience. That can be boys or men of any age or older girls/women as well.

I think there is a much more prominent male community because they initially felt the need to band together for moral support; to know that others really liked the show as well. This is still very new territory for boys, after all.

I won't answer your questions since you only seem interested in the guys' perspective, but I just thought I'd drop some more info for you.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: MintySocks on January 24, 2012, 10:04:59 PM
Thank you for that, it's all news to me! Up till now I didn't know a girl could be a brony... this just gets more and more interesting, because by that definition, I'm one too!
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: DoctorMowinckel on January 24, 2012, 10:19:25 PM
Not every guy who's into ponies is a 'brony'. I don't need to stand behind a label to make playing with ponies okay. Screw that. I like buying plastic toys and playing with their hair, that's fine with me. If you have a problem with that take your assumptions about gender roles and stick 'em where the sun doesn't shine.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: Scraleos on January 24, 2012, 11:57:21 PM
Not every guy who's into ponies is a 'brony'. I don't need to stand behind a label to make playing with ponies okay. Screw that. I like buying plastic toys and playing with their hair, that's fine with me. If you have a problem with that take your assumptions about gender roles and stick 'em where the sun doesn't shine.

I don't think MintySocks ever said every guy who's into ponies is a brony. I don't think she has a problem with you buying them either...

Back on topic... I used to be a 'brony' when I first found the show. Back then though, I didn't know most of them didn't like anything besides G4 XD because I still loved the other gens when I rediscovered MLP. if it helps, most of my guy friend bronies are 17 and under. I think it's just and Internet fad at the moment.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: MintySocks on January 25, 2012, 12:05:13 AM
Not every guy who's into ponies is a 'brony'. I don't need to stand behind a label to make playing with ponies okay. Screw that. I like buying plastic toys and playing with their hair, that's fine with me. If you have a problem with that take your assumptions about gender roles and stick 'em where the sun doesn't shine.

Whoaa ok! Ouch! I hope you're making a general statement in answer to question #5 and not getting defensive at me personally. My object in asking wasn't to make gender assumptions at all, or label anybody.  Like I said, I have absolutely NO IDEA what bronies are and I just want to learn what other people think they are... I want to hear from people who consider themselves to be that.  If you don't, I accept that gladly, and thank you for pointing out something I hadn't realized...

Not all bronies are guys.
Not all guys are bronies.

Got it.

But can we assume the best of one another and have a pleasant discussion please?
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: StarLite on January 25, 2012, 06:25:25 AM
Not every guy who's into ponies is a 'brony'.

That all depends on your personal interpretation of the word 'brony'. In my opinion, if you like the show FiM, regardless of age, gender, sexual orientation, race, etc., etc., you're a 'brony'. And I know several people who would agree.

But onto the topic at hand.

1. How you got into MLP and why you like it.
...Yeah, probably for the best that I don't answer the first question (Suffice to say I have some unusual friends), but I like it because it's cute, genuinely funny, and reminds me of when I wasn't such a cynical, heartless person. Watching FiM makes me happy.
2. Single? Married? Any dads? Any moms?
Single.
3. Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss?
Oh, boy do I collect. I'm quickly running out of room to put them!
4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations?
I've watched 'Rescue at Midnight Castle' and enjoyed it, but I just can't get over the 90s graphics, so I can't really get in the other shows. As for the toys, I don't want to start collecting them or I'll go mad trying to get them all!
5. Any other pertinent facts I should know in order to truly understand what bronies are about!
As I said, in my opinion, a brony is someone who likes the show FiM. No more, no less.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: Dragonflitter on January 25, 2012, 07:31:43 AM
I've been a huge collector of MLP's ever since childhood, I have over 200. Although I think FiM is great too, I'm not as much into the show as I am into the G4 toys. I dunno if that makes me a 'brony' or not lol. Is a brony a regular fan, or a super fan? Haha I'm not sure, myself.

I thought originally that brony referred to the male demographic that are fans of the show. In fact, I was constantly looking for the female version of the word brony so I could call myself that! lol. (I have since heard it's 'pegasisters' however I don't see it used much in the cartoon or toy collecting communities.)

Well, I recently went to a video game convention in Washington DC and chose to wear my Rainbow Dash T-shirt one day and I was completely surprised by the amount of total strangers (mostly guys, some girls) who would walk up to me and refer to me as a brony! I was like "Uh thanks but I'm a girl...?" Haha. XD One guy even asked me for a bro-hoof. I felt very hip. *chuckle*

Anyway, now I know it's a gender-neutral term, though I was quite confused at the time.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: gravitationaltim on January 25, 2012, 07:45:11 AM
I think will2Bfree said it best. In essence, 'brony' is a term that some fans take on, much like 'trekkies', but some people find it offensive/don't want to be associated with it because it is often associated with people who are weird or perverted about the ponies. Sometimes girls who watch the new show call themselves pegasisters or bronies. Really it's up to each person on whether they want to refer to themselves as bronies or not, some think it denotes their association with the fandom as a whole, some think it make them a member of a large community of males who enjoy happy cartoons, and other bunches of interpretations. It doesn't really mean one solid thing, people fight over the definition a lot, it's best to just assume that if someone says they are a brony, it means they are in some way a fan of MLP, and probably safe to assume they got into it because of Friendship is Magic. Myself:
1. How you got into MLP and why you like it.
One of my friends was really into ponies and got me into it, this was RIGHT before the show started, and I got into it more as the show went on.
2. I'm in a relationship, I'm gonna be 22 soon
3. I collect, I liked unicorn toys before I liked MLP, so it seemed natural to start collecting. I was pretty casual before, but after buying about 14 at a pony con, I started to collect more regularly
4. Yes, like I said I started before the new show started. My first pony was G1 Glory that I got for my birthday. I mostly only collect G1 and G4, but I have a few G3 as well.

I hope that helps! I think DoctorMowinckel became offended not by you, but by the idea that some people hide behind the title of brony to defend their masculinity by taking cover in a community of like-minded people, whereas he thinks you shouldn't have to be ashamed of liking ponies and being a man. I agree in general, while I fit the bill, I don't really like being called a brony very much.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: RAMChYLD on January 25, 2012, 08:02:03 AM
Not every guy who's into ponies is a 'brony'. I don't need to stand behind a label to make playing with ponies okay. Screw that. I like buying plastic toys and playing with their hair, that's fine with me. If you have a problem with that take your assumptions about gender roles and stick 'em where the sun doesn't shine.
QFT. Not every one of us likes to be associated with the "brony" movement. Particularly after run-in with the not-so-well-behaved ones.

My answers:
1. Long time ago. MLP&Friends was one of the shows in my childhood. It had meaning to me because one of my earliest childhood crushes was Megan. Then came Tales, and I got a crush on Sweetheart and the Slice of Life format (Tales started airing here after a slice of life show I loved, Arthur, got pulled, and I started looking for shows with a similar format). I skipped G3 and 3.5 mostly, but went into G4 upon falling in love with some of the toys, finding out that various VAs I love is on the show, and then getting hooked full after listening to Winter Wrap Up.
2. Single
3. I collect. Though it must be said that I did not have much interests in MLP toys before G4 came along.
4. As stated before, my interest in ponies started long before G4, and prettty much blossomed first time round with Tales. G4 just rekindled my love for the franchise.
5. No answer. I think it's pretty diverse. Most are good. Some are obnoxious. I don't really understand them myself.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: Evening_Moonstone on January 25, 2012, 08:16:09 AM
1. How you got into MLP and why you like it.
My best friend recommended it to me, as we both grew up loving G1 ponies.

2. Single? Married? Any dads? Any moms?
Married.  No kids yet but perhaps by next year.

3. Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss?
Started with the show, collect ponies that are in the show and/or I like them.  So far I have only show-oriented ponies except for Lily Blossom and Dewdrop Dazzle.  I have all the mane 6 (some duplicates, because of the bangs in the hair), the CMCs, and the Royal Castle Friends.  Plus a bunch of blind bags.

4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations?
I was a G1 pony fan back in the 80s, and I've picked up some "bait lots" of G1s for customizing and restoring.  So far I have a handful of cleaned, restored G1s for keeping, and a bunch of baits for customs (although I have yet to complete a full custom yet).
I also have 2 G3s - Minty and Marshmallow Coco - which are being used as Christmas decorations.  Got to love the Target exclusives!

5. Any other pertinent facts I should know in order to truly understand what bronies are about!
I'm not really a brony, just a fan of G4. It rekindled my interest in ponies which I haven't had since I was very little.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: tehrin on January 25, 2012, 09:07:58 AM
I've become a pretty hardcore G1 collector, LOL! But I wouldn't be if it weren't for FiM. So I'll consider myself a Brony, or rather Pegasister! XD

Keep in mind, that when I say FiM, I am talking about the animated aspect of the G4 ponies. Not lumping all the toys in with it.

1. How you got into MLP and why you like it.
I had lots of ponies during my childhood in the 80's and early 90's and loved them! They were some of my favorite toys. But honestly, once I became a teenager, like many things I loved, I sort of discarded those interests for more "normal" things, like celebrities, clothes, makeup, movies, going to the mall... yadda yadda. In 2000's I considered getting some G3's early on, but I didn't. I didn't even know the G2's existed, except that a friend bought me the little computer game for my 19th birthday and I thought they looked a little funny. I just had a thing for 80's stuff really!

It wasn't until FiM came out, and my friend (you know her has Rayechu) started talking to me about ponies that I caved in. Not to mention, half the people on my facebook had changed their profile pictures to a pony. I went to Toys R Us and bought Rainbow Dash. Then I started watching. I was hooked. I started buying G1's too, first starting with my childhood favorites!

I think that many people who consider themselves bronies ONLY like G4. But G1s have always had a soft spot. Before I began collecting, I'd see them and feel all warm and fuzzy! They're so lovely! On the other hand, I have friends who loved ponies during childhood who wonder "WTF was wrong with me!?" when they look back at previous gens, and don't really consider collecting/hunting for their childhood ponies. :( I have one friend like this, but it's funny because about 6 months ago, she wasn't even into MLP at all, and now she's a total brony! <3

2. Single? Married? Any dads? Any moms?
I'm married! No children yet though! I was engaged when I got into the show last year, but got married in May.

3. Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss?
I collect, I also watch the show. But I don't really do a lot of discussing. I just appreciate. :3

4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations?
Definately! I have ponies of all gens, minus 3.5. I'll probably get a couple of them though, because they have grown on me. XD G1's are my favorite though, not only for the nostalgia, but the quality is much higher, and there's so many to collect. While I wait for more G4's to be distributed, I grab up lots of G1s! :D

5. Any other pertinent facts I should know in order to truly understand what bronies are about!
I like to think of Bronies, whether they are male or female as being teenage-adult fans of FiM, meaning the animation. :) Whether they collect G4 toys, or toys of previous generations is sort of irrelevant. It really comes down to really loving the show and the characters, and coming together because of it!

The pony toys and merchandise are simply a means for us to show that we like it. :) A lot of us come from the anime/gaming crowd, so it's pretty common for us to have anime/game figures and merchandise from our favorite stuff! So buying a pony toy for most bronies is pretty common. :3

Though if you're like me, you've amassed so much pony that you have to put your anime/game figures away to display your ponies.  I just have my Xenosaga figures out because I love that series as much as ponies (plus, they're small!)
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: kCherry on January 25, 2012, 09:14:27 AM
As these threads tend to veer over to the "Collectors vs. Bronies" subject this is an early warning to all. Keep it strictly on topic and without hostilities or we will be forced to lock it.  ~Cherry

  Now that's that's done, I iz a brony. :)

1. How you got into MLP and why you like it. I collected G1s as a child and started customizing in 2007
2. Married with two teen sons. They all think that I'm ponycrazy.
3. Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss? All of the above, although I just watch FiM, I don't try to analyze it. XD
4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations? I love All gens. Even the 3.5s!
5. Too much pony politics! :drunk:
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: ZennaBug on January 25, 2012, 09:16:02 AM
I know you asked for only bronies, but I'm just going to leave a tidbit here:

That all depends on your personal interpretation of the word 'brony'. In my opinion, if you like the show FiM, regardless of age, gender, sexual orientation, race, etc., etc., you're a 'brony'. And I know several people who would agree.

I love both FiM and the G4 ponies and I am certainly not a brony.  It's not that I have a problem with them, but I was a collector before bronies existed and liking FiM was a natural thing for me, as a pony fan.  The main reason I don't call myself a brony is because I don't associate with the fandom at all, since there are some sketchy bits that I don't care for at all.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: Kitkumi on January 25, 2012, 09:19:03 AM
1. How you got into MLP and why you like it.
I can't remember how i got in to it originally. I remember seeing the movie with the Smooze (spelling?) and being hooked from there. I got out of it for -years- until FIM came out. I happened to see a video of it set to Starcraft I think it was, and Nightmare Moon looked awesome so I went and watched the first episode. I was hooked at once.

2. Single? Married? Any dads? Any moms?
I'm in a relationship thats going in to its fifth year, and I'm about to turn twenty four. I got my boyfriend to watch the first couple episodes of FIM and after some eye rolling and cringing, he was hooked.

3. Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss?
I collect to customize, and thats about it on that front. The only ponies I collect to keep are Luna, and a Rarity brushable that I got for my birthday. I watch it every week but don't really discuss it that much.

4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations?
The G2 generation! I remember having a few as a kid and then donated them to a used toy drive when I got older DX Looking back I wish I had kept them, lol. My interest in the G2 generation has been rekindled, and I've started to develop an interest in the G1 stuff the longer I've been around here, lol.

5. Any other pertinent facts I should know in order to truly understand what bronies are about!
The term brony doesn't just refer to just the guys, which I think has been covered already, but just as an example I'm a girl and still they call me a brony. A brony can be of any age too; it doesn't have to just be the guys or girls that are twenty and up. They can be younger. Ironically enough, I don't often hear people refer to the age group that this show is supposed to be aimed at (girls ages six to ten or somewhere around there) being called bronies XD
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: Cool.Breeze on January 25, 2012, 09:31:12 AM
1. How you got into MLP and why you like it.

A: A friend asked me out of the blue in May of 2010 if I was a 'brony'. After asking for an explanation of the term (she said it meant "adult MLP fan), I replied "I suppose I am, I just finished gathering up some old MLP episodes and MLP Tales for nostalgia!" as I'd been on an old-school toon kick at that time, anyway. My friend then told me about MLP:FiM. I was intruiged, gave it a watch, and have been re-hooked on ponies ever since :biggrin:

2. Single? Married? Any dads? Any moms?

A: In a relationship of 5+ years with the man I intend to marry. No children for us yet, but that's something we wouldn't visit until we tie the knot and have a larger home. He's not a pony fan, but he thinks my love for ponies is adorable (thankfully!), and he watches the new episodes with me when they come out.


3. Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss?

A: I've always been a toy nut, but also a big animation enthusiast, so I'd have to say both the toys and show are equally responsible for my intense love of the new G4 line. The show got me hooked on the characters and made me care about them, and I think that played a big factor in my wanting to collect the toy line as well. Not to mention the toys are irresistibly cute!!


4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations?

A: Definitely- I was an early 80's kid, so ponies were my favourite thing as a little girl. I honestly can't remember when or why I decided to 'outgrow' them. Just before I discovered FiM, I re-watched 'Escape from Catrina', "Rescue at Midnight Castle" (shoo be doo! Shoo shoo be doo!) and MLP Tales just for nostalgia sake. Then giving FiM a watch right afterwards, I became smitten entirely by the pony bug, as if I were a little girl again. At the time I watched FiM I was pretty broke, so I'd begun my pony collection with G3's I'd find at second hand shops, and I'm definitely a fan of G3's, now. After my part time hours picked up, my G4's built up pretty quick (I still have more G3 than G4, though) I've even managed to find 8 G1's second hand since re-starting my pony collection. I have every intention of collecting all of the G1 wingers one day  ;)

5. Any other pertinent facts I should know in order to truly understand what bronies are about!

A: This is a difficult question for me to answer, because much like DrM, I hate labels of any sort- they are harmful in the sense that it causes people to put you in a 'box', and peg you as something without really knowing you. I think the term 'brony' means something different to everyone who feels the need to carry it. I've observed that a person who calls themselves a brony can be anything from a person who is just a general fan of the FiM toys and show, to exuberant, bordering on obnoxious fanatics who can once in a while take things too far (in a variety of directions, for example, GravitationalTim mentioned a more perverse love of ponies, which is a type of fandom I personally feel nauseated by). All in all, I think the term 'brony' started as something fun and cute, but because every person is so different in their specific interests in ponies, the title got dragged through the mud a bit and is now coated in controversy. ETA: That said, I have playfully referred to my own self as a brony because of how I ended up loving ponies again after FiM. I personally like to see the term as describing a person who is simply really enthusiastic about the toys and cartoon, but unfortunately the Internet has assisted in making the term 'brony' ugly in some respects.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: StarLite on January 25, 2012, 10:53:55 AM
I know you asked for only bronies, but I'm just going to leave a tidbit here:

That all depends on your personal interpretation of the word 'brony'. In my opinion, if you like the show FiM, regardless of age, gender, sexual orientation, race, etc., etc., you're a 'brony'. And I know several people who would agree.

I love both FiM and the G4 ponies and I am certainly not a brony.  It's not that I have a problem with them, but I was a collector before bronies existed and liking FiM was a natural thing for me, as a pony fan.  The main reason I don't call myself a brony is because I don't associate with the fandom at all, since there are some sketchy bits that I don't care for at all.

Sorry if I offended you. I don't mean to imply that everyone should consider themselves a brony if they like the show, I only mean that in my mind, I consider you a brony. Feel free to call yourself whatever you like.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: Dragonflitter on January 25, 2012, 11:44:40 AM
A bit off topic here but you know, this thread reminds me a lot of the anime fandom. There's some female anime fans that are happy to call themselves fangirls (meaning they are fans of Japanese anime, and they are female, and that is it). Others will take offense if you call them a fangirl because it implies you're crazy like some of those obsessive fans out there who are kinda scary...

I myself never minded the label until a close friend called me a 'fangirl' in the same tone of voice you would use for the scum you scrape off the bottom of your shoe. -.-

"Bad apples spoil the whole barrel" as the saying goes, eh?
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: hyenacub on January 25, 2012, 12:30:44 PM
I will answer this as a 35 year old man who likes classic MLPs.  lol

1. How you got into MLP and why you like it. - I don't remember how--I was too young to remember what initially got me into it.  I only remember loving them.  I liked them because they weren't the boring realitic looking horses.  They were soft vinyl, they had pegasi and unicorns, and cool colors.  (And I've always been a sucker for rainbows.  Still am!)  I liked looking at them and making up stories about them.  I still like making up stories, but don't generally use toys anymore.  XD  I graduted into writing and roleplaying.

2. Single? Married? Any dads? Any moms? - Single, and assexual.  lol  So...not a dad of course.  Aromantic too.  : P

3. Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss? - I collect mostly.  I watch an episode here and there though.  I like the first generation of MLP the best though I do hve s few G3s.

4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations?  Haha see above answer.  XD  Though I've seen some G4 customs that I like...and some of the unicorns looks okay.  but for the most part I don't care for the G4 toys.

5. Any other pertinent facts I should know in order to truly understand what bronies are about! - No clue.  There are too many definitions lol
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: Taxel on January 25, 2012, 01:39:07 PM
I used to identify as a brony so I guess I'll answer too.

1. How you got into MLP and why you like it.
My best friend, a collector of MLP before FiM, talked to me about the show a lot. How she was excited for it, how Zecora was cool, etc. I'm on Reddit and dA a lot, and with my friend's love of the show (we have extremely similar tastes, almost identical) and how popular it was I decided to watch an episode or two. I was immediately hooked. How familiar it felt to the cartoons of my childhood (Powerpuff Girls and Foster's of course, as well as others) was awesome. It was one of very few recent shows I'd allow my children to watch. The characters are fun and although Rainbow's technically not a lesbian or anything of the sort, seeing a positive character LGBT kids could identify with was just too awesome.

2. Single? Married? Any dads? Any moms?
I'm in a serious relationship, we just celebrated our third anniversary earlier this month. We have a son but I'm not sure I'd fit in the "mom" category for this, as he was adopted. Lol.

3. Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss?
When I identified as a brony I only really watched the show and discussed it with my friend, but was interested in collecting the figures with molded hair (that one set and blind bags). That was because as a photographer and collector of dolls from a very windy place I've grown to really hate dealing with photographing things with hair. Its so annoying. xD However I have since begun collecting G4s, but I still try and avoid them as much as possible because I dislike supporting Hasbroken and their show about dismissing gender stereotypes and their toys about enforcing them.

4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations?
I did, and that was one of the reasons I no longer identify as a brony. I fell in love with G1 and after buying my first one I was hooked. I'm now a collector of all generations although I mostly have G1s and G4s at this point.

5. Any other pertinent facts I should know in order to truly understand what bronies are about!
Personally, I do not ever wish to be called a brony. In my eyes, calling me a brony would be an insult (bolded 'me' because it just relates to only me, anyone can call each other/themselves bronies and I won't care, how others choose to identify themselves is their business. However I do know other people that consider being called a brony an insult). I was very active in the brony communities of Reddit and dA for quite some time, however the communities degraded more and more as time went on. They started out as wonderful communities, full of giveaways, kindness, and fun (of course there are always bad apples though). But that didn't last long. When I left the brony community and stopped identifying as one they were not happy places. They were full of rude, judgmental people as well as heaps of scammers (I've got my own horror stories about brony artists on dA and have heard plenty of others). Not to mention the not-safe-for-kids parts of the community/fandom growing like wildfire and no longer being "that awful thing you know is there but try not to think about" and instead being "that thing you cannot avoid and run into 10+ times a day in these communities". I also am very against the brony bashing of anything pre-G4 on dA. I've seen bronies jump on artists drawing in a G3 style and telling them "they're doing it wrong" and the only way to get views/feedback is to draw G4. The artist cried and deactivated their account it got so bad. Heck, even when my artist comments (basically a description) on pre-G4 pony photos state very clearly that the ponies are not G4 bronies still get their panties in a bunch and whine about how wrong they are.

And before anyone jumps down my throat, I don't have anything against bronies that are good people. The issue I have is with the brony community as a whole based on my experiences. I don't know if the specific brony communities I mentioned have gotten better or worse, but I do not wish to find out. I've never run into a rude brony here on MLPArena, heck I've only ever run into one rude person period, so obviously I am not talking about the bronies here, but the bronies in the communities I've mentioned. And if anyone decides to quote me out of context and try to say I hate all FiM fans or something and make me look like some awful person, prepare for extreme fakie grenades. XP
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: kmlv23 on January 25, 2012, 01:47:39 PM
I prefer the term 'pegasister' but technically, I still fall under the heading of 'brony' oddly enough.

Tell me...
1. How you got into MLP and why you like it.
I saw the hoopla on the internet over FiM and decided to see what the fuss was about. Ended up watching nearly the entire first season in a night, and it was all downhill from there.
2. Single? Married? Any dads? Any moms?
Single/open relationship. lol I'm only 21. Not planning on becoming married or a mother anytime soon.
3. Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss?
Both. A friend got me a FS Pinkie Pie, and I felt the need to get the mane 6 as FS ponies, and I got it into my head that maybe I should get some of the others too. Which led to a Goodwill trip that ended in a bag of ponies and...well now I'm here. haha.
4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations?
A bit. I don't really know the stories behind them, and seem to only really enjoy the G1 babies, but I'm not really a fan of the G4 toys either, apart from the FS and the blind bags. I've also taken to collect purple G3's, as purple is my favorite color, and I recently rediscovered that I had a G2 as a child, and have begun attempting to hunt her down as well.
5. Any other pertinent facts I should know in order to truly understand what bronies are about!
I really don't think, apart from a few trolls, that the bronies are really as bad as they're made out to be. The brony phenomena DID start on some other site after all, but I see the bronies as being harbingers for a kinder, gentler internet, when they're doing it right and not trolling for the sake of trolling. Don't let a few bad apples ruin the bunch, you know? Oh, and men are bronies, women are pegasisters. ;)


EDIT: I know the term comes with a LOT of controversy, but I'm proud to be a brony/pegasister/whatever. I wasn't around for whatever went down with the bronies that people allude to, but I'm of the opinion that I can be a pegasister and NOT be interested in the sketchy aspects, like the NSFW fanfic and pictures. People get their jollies out of whatever these days, and you know what? That's fine, just please please please leave me out of it. I read a few of the sketchier fanfics and try to pretend like I didn't because I was so disturbed. People are sick, and you're going to get sickos no matter WHAT fandom you're in. Discriminating against bronies is the same as them trolling the heck out of you, in my mind. I've been feeling a fair amount of hostility on a few of the boards, though likely I'm going to get shouted down about that, but I'm still going to stand on the nearest rooftop and yell at the stars that I'm a pegasister and I'm proud of it, dammit. I really honestly don't understand the hatred between the factions or whatever. If it bothers you, don't look at it! You know? Maybe I'm insane. That's entirely likely. But I just don't get it.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: ZettaMomo on January 25, 2012, 02:17:04 PM
I am a 17 year old girl and I call myself a brony. Not all FiM fans feel the need to call themselves bronies or care to be grouped into that. I call myself it not because I feel like it makes me feel 'better' because I collect and play with toys intended for little girls. People know that I do and I don't really care if they have a problem with it.

1. How you got into MLP and why you like it.
I don't remember having a childhood pony outside of a fakie that I loved, but mom said I had a few when I was pretty young.
I got into FiM because I was curious to see what the big deal with it was and I feel in love instantly. I love the animation style. Just the way the cartoon is it reminds me of the cartoons I used to watch as a kid. I think some of the character's personalities are easily relatable for some viewers (I find myself relating to Fluttershy because I am a shy person, but when it comes down to it I am not afraid to stick up for my friends.)

2. Single? Married? Any dads? Any moms?
I'm not married, but I have a boyfriend. I don't think he really considers himself a brony because he is not as into the show as I am, but he is more than happy to watch the show with me when I offer.
I still live with my mom and dad. Mom doesn't watch FiM with me, but she will buy ponies for me off the internet if I earned it. xD And dad watches it with me sometimes. He even picked out AppleJack as his favorite pony and he has a couple AppleJack figures I got him on his nightstand.

3. Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss?
I do both! I have ponies on my desk that I brush and take care of. I also will discuss it with my few 'brony' friends in real life and on my Tumblr blog.

4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations?
Yes! The arena has really helped that, too. I have a buddy on GaiaOnline who I was getting some art of my ponysona from and she suggested that I come here to get help with starting up a collection. I have one pony of every gen (except Gen 3.5 I honestly do not really care for how the ponies look in that gen)

5. Any other pertinent facts I should know in order to truly understand what bronies are about!
I really feel like you should know that the word 'brony' can get a bad reputation because there are some bronies out there who do not love and tolerate other fans or even people who do not like the show. There are some 'trolls' among the community, but that is not a big part of it. Some people think all bronies are trolls because they some that are and these trolls can ruin the reputation of the rest of the community.
There are certain parts of the community you do not want to ruin into or associate yourself with... but just about every brony I talk to is very nice and just like everyone else.

Also, the above poster did mentions that boys are bronies and girls are pegasisters, but not all girls like to be called pegasisters. I personally like bronies. I do not feel like just because you are a girls does not mean you cannot use the 'male term'. I don't like feeling like I must be something separate because I am a girl.
Just my opinion at least. :3 If somepony wants to be called a pegasister I am more than happy to call them that and not a brony.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: kmlv23 on January 25, 2012, 02:20:46 PM
Also, the above poster did mentions that boys are bronies and girls are pegasisters, but not all girls like to be called pegasisters. I personally like bronies. I do not feel like just because you are a girls does not mean you cannot use the 'male term'. I don't like feeling like I must be something separate because I am a girl.
Just my opinion at least. :3 If somepony wants to be called a pegasister I am more than happy to call them that and not a brony.
Fair point, I was over generalizing. Sorry!
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: Snapdragon on January 25, 2012, 02:50:12 PM
Heh, I might not be the type of Brony you want to answer your survey, since I'm sort of an old-school fan who likes the new show and originally identified as a Brony but now dislikes the direction the Brony movement is taking and wouldn't want to be called a Brony in Brony-only spaces but still feel the title sort of concerns her because she likes the new show and a lot of the creativity surrounding it despite the problematic elements ... SO... feel free to disregard my post if you so please. ;)

Tell me... I SHALL!
1. How you got into MLP and why you like it. I grew up with MLP, obviously, but I got into the G4 show more so because it was 'the latest pony thing' and I wanted to see if it was good. Not really out of any desire to watch it BECAUSE it was a good show, but more because it was Pony. I was told by my brother, of all people (not a Brony himself) that a lot of people were talking about the show before it even started, so I went and checked out some online spaces for it and got into the Brony swing of things! :D
2. Single? Married? Any dads? Any moms? Single! I'm one of the prototypical mid-twenties collectors who had ponies as a kid and is hunting down the nostalgia. :P
3. Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss? I collect and watch the show! Lately, I restrict my discussion to here, the TP, and another community because I just don't like the direction things take at Brony-only spaces. :/ Slurs against female characters, and the like. Fleur-de-Lis ... didn't have a very nice name at first, thanks to Bronies.
4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations? I've always had an interest in the other generations, since I grew up with them! But I have noticed a lot of Bronies who initially start out liking G4, then branch out into G1 and G3! :) Two female Bronies I hung out with got into G2, very much so!
5. Any other pertinent facts I should know in order to truly understand what bronies are about! Well, a lot of them hold offensive views, so be aware that people who like the G4 show and "Bronies" are often divided into two groups. Bronies tend to be younger, and a lot less worldly, so they sometimes hold some offensive views that they think are okay because it's "just the internet."


slight edit for content ~ashes
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: ZettaMomo on January 25, 2012, 02:54:45 PM
Also, the above poster did mentions that boys are bronies and girls are pegasisters, but not all girls like to be called pegasisters. I personally like bronies. I do not feel like just because you are a girls does not mean you cannot use the 'male term'. I don't like feeling like I must be something separate because I am a girl.
Just my opinion at least. :3 If somepony wants to be called a pegasister I am more than happy to call them that and not a brony.
Fair point, I was over generalizing. Sorry!
No need to apologize! I just saw you say that and thought that I should point out that not all girls are pegasisters just like all boys who like FiM is not a brony~
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: Shelltoon on January 25, 2012, 03:58:47 PM
1. How you got into MLP and why you like it.
Well, My Little Pony was one of those things through my childhood I really didn't care about. Most people would go "ewwww, girly toys!" I just didn't really care. Now that we've gotten that out of the way and established I had very little interest in My Little Pony, let's get to FiM. Back in late 2010 when I was on /co/ happily discussing Adventure Time, Regular Show, and SymBionic Titan, one day I stumbled upon a huge thread that was discussing My Little Pony. The first thing going through my mind was "this can't possibly be real, it has to be a massive trolling effort." When Lauren Faust's name popped up, I went to her DA and watched the first episode on YouTube. Needless to say, my mind was blown. How could something associated with girly, frilly, frou frou nonsense be so good? Needless to say, I decided to just stick with the show, and before I knew it, I was hooked. What is it about this show that got me hooked? Several factors. The stylish, cartoony animation allows the animators to really break free and create some wacky facial expressions. Maybe it's the writing, how it manages to be family friendly, and never talk down to kids. Perhaps it's the characters having distinct personalities that makes them likeable. Maybe it's the world these colorful ponies live in. It's full of little details, and well defined that we can immerse ourselves into it. For me, it's every little aspect of this show coming together to actually spark a certain magic that so many cartoons just can't create. If magic is real, this show is proof.

2. Single? Married? Any dads? Any moms?
I have a family consisting of a brother, mother, and father. They all think it's silly that I'm into ponies, but they are just as curious as I was when I got into the fandom. I'm very single, and struggling to find a decent relationship.

3. Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss?
I do both. Honestly, for me it started out as I had no intention of buying pony toys. I was just a fan of the show, nothing more. Then I bought the gift set and said to myself, "this is all I'm getting. Nothing more." Soon the brushables were making their way into the states and I had decided "I'm only buying Twilight Sparkle, no more." That one didn't last as I ended up getting her along with Rainbow Dash. Again, telling myself that was it, I suddenly caved and started buying ponies like no tomorrow. I think the toys had a certain alluring charm that sucked me in. This doesn't mean I collect all of the toys. The So Soft Newborns I won't collect, not because ewwww hideous monstrosities, but rather those are baby dolls, and that's something I could never get into. Yet I got into colorful, brushable equines... go figure!

4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations?
I used to be one of those bronies who would be all "ewwww, previous gen?! KILL IT WITH FIRE! DIEEEEEEEEE!!!! MY EYES!!! OH THE HUMANITY!!!... equinity?.." However, that was to be expected. I had no real knowledge of the previous generations, and I didn't care for it. One day, out of boredom, I decided to try stuff from the previous generations. As far as G1 was concerned, G1 had a great world, and Rescue at Midnight Castle seemed to be a great place to build a My Little Pony cartoon, but from there on it becomes difficult to watch because I'm struggling to endure the voice acting. Tales I can't really relate to anymore because I'm not in high school, but I do respect their efforts for trying to give the ponies some distinct personalities. G3 had A Very Minty Christmas, which I will defend to the death as the best thing to come out of G3 animated, otherwise it's just been a dull and pointless mess for me. One time in Wal*Mart, when looking for new FiM toys, I somehow found a G3 Golden Delicious just sitting on the shelf and had to buy it. Since then, I've been sucked in by the older toys, and have developed something of an interest in certain ponies from previous generations.

5. Any other pertinent facts I should know in order to truly understand what bronies are about!
Just be careful if you associate yourself as a brony, because for some people "brony" means horsef[censors!!!!], or a social degenerate. You'll more than likely be lumped into this group, no matter how much you try to defend yourself. However, every fandom is guaranteed to have its bad apples, and yes, it's hard to get away from these bad apples, but that doesn't mean go all hipster.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: Jocelyn on January 25, 2012, 04:29:54 PM
By my own definition, I don't consider myself a brony. I don't want to connect myself with the whole fandom side of things - I just want to like what I like without it being a label :) But my interest in MLP was rekindled by FiM, so by definition I'm a brony (but not male! :P ).

1. How you got into MLP and why you like it.
In February, my brother told me to watch FiM, which I really did not expect from (before I'd learned about bronies). It's sincere and a pretty good show, and it reminds me of the shows I loved as a kid and the ponies I used to have. And I'm a sucker for cute, nostalgic things.

2. Single? Married? Any dads? Any moms?
I'm in a relationship, not married or no kids.

3. Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss?
I used to just watch the show, now I collect. Heck, I mostly just collect now. If I discuss, it's probably mostly about collecting rather than the show :')

4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations?
Oh, yes. Far more than G4 now! I've gotten really into G1s, which is what I used to have as a kid. At first, I thought they were a little strange, but there was one moment where it just 'clicked', and suddenly I couldn't stop trying to get them! I have several G3s too, but mostly because I find them in thrift stores. I only actively search for G1s and specific G4s now.

5. Any other pertinent facts I should know in order to truly understand what bronies are about!
It seems like the most obnoxious and annoying ones are always the ones people hear about most and base their opinions on. Not all pony fans that came through FiM are like them :)
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: ElleDatura on February 04, 2012, 02:13:17 AM
19yr old girl who likes collecting and occasionally playing with cute plastic ponies, of the toy variety. =P I duno if I should be considered a Brony or not. Some people have been called bronies because they collect MLP, regardless of generation or if they watch the show.

1. How you got into MLP and why you like it.

Long story short, I heard about it when I was a girl and couldn't get any. About 14 my mum sent me some at boarding school, I was having a tough time and fantasy-type things cheer me up. Years later I dug my small G4 heard out and cleaned them up. I have since added some G 3.5s but am dying to get my hands on some G1's.

2. Single? Married? Any dads? Any moms?

Mum and Step-dad. Single forever.

3. Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss?

I looked at the show and thought it was fine. I take ages for me to sit down and watch/read anything though as I tend to pull giant marathons of whatever it is I'm watching/reading. So I may actually get around to seeing all of it one day. But really, I'm just here for the toys.

4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations?

My main interest has always been in the G1's. My prefernce list for pony style/art is pretty much: G1, G3, G2, G4, G3.5.

5. Any other pertinent facts I should know in order to truly understand what bronies are about!

I admit to being a little sour to the FiM fandom... I try not to spread hate nor will I be rude (I hope). The person isn't the fandom after all. The biggest deal for me though is the obnoxious hate of older gens SOME (some not all I understand this concept) have. Is it really hard to admit Gen 4 wasn't here first? Is it really that bad that Rainbow Dash wasn't always the brash tomboy we all know and love? I guess I don't understand.

EDIT: Okay.. I sounded a bit angry there but Taxel's post reminded me of some stuff. It also made me nervous about a small project I had been planning. But what I seriously meant, being over emotional aside; They are all just ponies. Some pony lines were less liked then others. Some shows were. And to be brutally honest the show is and has always really been a comercial for the pre-existing toyline. FiM just managed to take it a step further.

So does that make anyone who likes ponies a potential "Brony" or is it just the show? Is that extended to the Gen 4 toyline? I'm now interested in how to define a brony, other then personal labels, LOL.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: Taxel on February 04, 2012, 02:22:50 AM
"Some people have been called bronies because they collect MLP, regardless of generation or if they watch the show."

Bronies are FiM fans, and only FiM fans. It is not a blanket term for MLP collectors.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: terabithianprince on February 04, 2012, 03:09:15 AM
1. How you got into MLP and why you like it.
I used to have ponies as a kid and then I found out about the new show and started watching. Helped my friend open her blind bags and became addicted to collecting them and watching MLP: Friendship is magic.

2. Single? Married? Any dads? Any moms?
Single

3. Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss?
Both. I like the older G1 ponies the best though but I do enjoy the show. I prefer to chat here or with fellow pony collectors on trademe through my e-mail rather than hit the brony fan sites.

4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations?
I like all generations of my little pony but G1 is the best. Especially trying to collect all my grails!

5. Any other pertinent facts I should know in order to truly understand what bronies are about!
I think people think bronies are all the same and try to lump them altogether based on their reactions or the bronies they have met. I think that being a guy and liking my little pony people bring up all sorts of old-school gender issues but if I'm a guy and like my little pony then that's my choice right? Lol.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: Saiko on February 04, 2012, 10:54:23 AM
Hi MintySocks! I pitched your question to my local Brony friends, they're all university students and the nicest, most geniune and funniest people I've ever met. They also had no clue earlier pony generations had such a big fan base until I told them about the Arena. I won't include my answers as I feel I'm half-Brony / half MLP collector. Here are their answers, I'll edit to add as more people answer (its gonna be a long post!):

#One (female)
1. Saw reaction faces of it and decided to watch it.
2. Technically married to [friend - name removed], but not really.
3. I has ma ponehs :D
4. ...No.
5. We're pretty cool dudes. Watch ponies and don't afraid of anything.

#Two (male)
1. I surf the Internet.
2. I surf the Internet.
3. I just watch.
4. Nopa!
5. The whole charm of MLP is the vibrant personalities, the community and the good plot.

#Three (male)
‎1. A friend posted it on Facebook, I looked because I like cartoons.
2. Forever alone (that's a joke, laugh)
3. Collect and watch and discuss.
4. Ee-nope.
5. In general, we're the nicest community on the internets.

#Four (male)
1. Saw a parody video, ignored it for a few months. Eventually got curious enough to watch it.
2. Apparently I am also married to [friend]. This is against my will...
3. I'll order a pony or two at some point
4. NOPENOPENOPE [I'll add here that he doesn't mean he dislikes older gens, he just feels like the two fanbases should be clearly defined and not merged, to save confusion]
5. Uh, I don't really know how to explain the community. We're a pretty unique phenomenon.

#Five (female)
1. My flat mate would not stop going on about it so I gave it a watch
2. Single
3. Watch
4. No
5. What always seems to make a good show is one that shows that no matter what your friends will be there for you.

ETA
#Six (male)
1) [A friend] wouldn't shut up about it. So I watched it. And got addicted. 2) Engaged, to a girl who is basically a human Fluttershy. 3) Watch 4) NO

#Seven (female)
1. The Internet said it was rad. Can't argue with the Internet. 2. Single all the way. 3. I watch it and draw. Draw ALL the ponies! (will also buy Applejack because she is favourite pony) 4. No. I saw some of it as a kid and it was terrible.  5. Watch the show, enjoy the show, notice increase of happiness in life.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: Timepiece on February 04, 2012, 12:30:33 PM
I'll take this as a "survey" thing.  :blush:

1. How you got into MLP and why you like it.

Last year, March-April 2011. I was hestitant to watch FiM at first, but when Lapfox Trax musicial Renard replied to a Brony who questions about the "CMC" background soundtrack, the question also included a full-blown episode. Because i want to understand why ponies was so popular, I watched it. Half edgy, but when the episode gets to the hot encore where the CMC sang the off-tune 80s rock music, I find that HILARIOUS! So... Yea. I got warped into the fandom after that.

WHY I like it? I guess for me is because it's "cute"... Like "anime chibi" cute. I also like how it was written, and making sure that the female cast remains interesting and "awesome", that you wish that they were your friends! ^^;

2. Single? Married? Any dads? Any moms?Single, do have siblings and a mom. But none of them are "bronies". I think it was my bro that stayed away from me because I was collecting pony merch. thanks to FiM. ^^;   3. Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss?I do watch the show, but I buy ponies if I can. Buying them is like a way to support the awesome guys that praise the fandom, and even kind enough to keep the full episodes at YouTube! :)      Then again this is pretty much how marketing works. Watch the show, get hooked, have the urge to buy ponies. And I don't mind, since I think it's the closest, cheepest toys I can afford! I could have discuss, but ti's a children's show... So I let it go lightly and enjoy Rainbow Dash being awesome and Pinkie Pie just being Pinkie. :)   
4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations?

Sort of. I mean- Thanks to Strawberry Reed and MLP Arena, how could I not ignore the previous gens that carry a key element to creating G4! Thanks to quick research on the looks and features of the previous generation toys, I know which one is a G3 or a G1. I did have 2 G1s (Fifi and Baby Nibbles), 4 G3s (Waterfire, Minty, and Pinkie Pie, McD Toola-Roola), G2 McD toy (Iris?), and McD 3.5s: Sweetie Belle, Starsong, and Cherielee, two of which I have as a gift from my RL friend). Oh and Ponyville... Toothbrush pony with a hot air balloon and clouds for a Cutie Mark. 5. Any other pertinent facts I should know in order to truly understand what bronies are about!
Well, there have been fans that would just love to being called "MLP:FiM fan" instead of a "Brony", just like how fans of Star Trek would prefer just being called a "fan" than a "Trekkie". I have seen good "explanation" blog posts from various Bronies/MLP fans like all of us. As for the girls, they are fine being called "Brony" or "Pegasister". I'm one of them that are okay being labeld as. (And easier for me I guess.) Finally... "Bronies" are probably the most kindest and most-open of all compared to a certain bunch who uses a certain discussion/picture board site. *Double-cough* There are a few bunch who are ever-so-kind enough to pull charies like "Bronies for Good", which give a ton of love from the VAs from BroNYcon!
I think that should be enough from me, heheh. ^^;

P.S. Sorry if my post is being VERY GLITCHY. D: I can't do much about the formatting.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: Dojo on February 04, 2012, 12:57:29 PM
1. How you got into MLP and why you like it.
Me and one of my friends from my gaming group online are known for liking to you image macros to reply to peoples posts with on our forum. At one point other members challenged me to reply to posts with only images for a month. Eventually, in January 2011 my friend started replying with lots of FiM image then someone challenged him to do the same, only with FiM images. I got curious and was wondering why in the world he liked it. He linked me to youtube. Watched first two episodes and he recommened me to Winter Wrap Up and Bridle Gossip. I was hooked.

As for why do I like it? Oh wow. Short version: the characters, general cuteness and/or awesomeness, voice acting, animation, music, stories, humor, references, staff interaction with fanbase, fan art, fan music (I listen to EverFree Radio at work), fan comics, etc. Ever single piece of this is a major part of why I like it. They all come together to create something amazing. Yeah, even the fan works. The quantity and quality is amazing. Heck, it makes me proud how much the community has contributed to charities too. Yeah, there are parts of the fandom I don't like. But hey, I wouldn't like anything if I let the moronic side of the fandom get in my way.

2. Single? Married? Any dads? Any moms?
Single. ;-;

3. Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss?
I mostly watch the show and discuss. I'll be aquireing more G4 toys other than my Rainbow Dash little by little. (Can't wait for them to come back to McDonalds! I missed out the first time around)

4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations?
I think I might have seen a bit of G1 when I was little. I'm not really interested but I'd definitely take it over the other generations besides FiM. As for the toys, on.




5. Any other pertinent facts I should know in order to truly understand what bronies are about!
As with any fandom, there is both pure awesomeness and bad eggs. Don't let those bad eggs get in the way of your enjoyment of the series or all the talented fan works. Mean there are bronies out there who make trance/eurobeat/ other electronic music based on FiM or remixed by FiM. As well as many other styles, hey theres even "The Beatles Bronies" who pony-ize The Beatles songs. Theres teams out there working on video games like melee/fighting games or MMORPGs. People make tons or awesome music videos, parodies, and tons of fan art too. All the this quality and quantity just vastly outweighs any bad things about the brony fanbase for me.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: ashes on February 04, 2012, 01:23:46 PM
I agree with what Zenna said - I like FiM, but I don't consider myself a brony since MLPs were my favorite toys as a child in the 80s, and I began to actively collect them in the early 90s.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: Ice Crystal on February 04, 2012, 01:29:53 PM
I am a fan of FiM/G4 but don't personally consider myself a brony, just a fan. I will answer the questions anyway since I was introduced to pony collecting through G4, if that's ok. :3

1. How you got into MLP and why you like it.
G4, as mentioned. I always knew of MLP's existence, of course, but fell in love with the cartoon and researched the franchise's history a bit more. Many of the pony designs really appealed to me so I wanted to start collecting a few (or a lot)! I was looking for something new to collect anyway.
2. Single? Married? Any dads? Any moms?
Single.
3. Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss?
Both!
4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations?
All of them, but particularly in G1 and G3.
5. Any other pertinent facts I should know in order to truly understand what bronies are about!
I guess I'll skip this one haha.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: butterflybuttons on February 04, 2012, 01:36:30 PM
There are some interesting answers.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: LilSpark on February 04, 2012, 02:12:55 PM
I know you asked for only bronies, but I'm just going to leave a tidbit here:

That all depends on your personal interpretation of the word 'brony'. In my opinion, if you like the show FiM, regardless of age, gender, sexual orientation, race, etc., etc., you're a 'brony'. And I know several people who would agree.

I love both FiM and the G4 ponies and I am certainly not a brony.  It's not that I have a problem with them, but I was a collector before bronies existed and liking FiM was a natural thing for me, as a pony fan.  The main reason I don't call myself a brony is because I don't associate with the fandom at all, since there are some sketchy bits that I don't care for at all.

This!
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: ZennaBug on February 04, 2012, 08:50:09 PM
I know you asked for only bronies, but I'm just going to leave a tidbit here:

That all depends on your personal interpretation of the word 'brony'. In my opinion, if you like the show FiM, regardless of age, gender, sexual orientation, race, etc., etc., you're a 'brony'. And I know several people who would agree.

I love both FiM and the G4 ponies and I am certainly not a brony.  It's not that I have a problem with them, but I was a collector before bronies existed and liking FiM was a natural thing for me, as a pony fan.  The main reason I don't call myself a brony is because I don't associate with the fandom at all, since there are some sketchy bits that I don't care for at all.

Sorry if I offended you. I don't mean to imply that everyone should consider themselves a brony if they like the show, I only mean that in my mind, I consider you a brony. Feel free to call yourself whatever you like.

You didn't offend me at all  :)  I just wanted to drop a line from the other side of the fence, as someone who loves FiM and G4, but doesn't care to associate with the majority of the fandom.  :hug:
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: ElleDatura on February 04, 2012, 09:01:06 PM
"Some people have been called bronies because they collect MLP, regardless of generation or if they watch the show."

Bronies are FiM fans, and only FiM fans. It is not a blanket term for MLP collectors.

Ah sorry. Just saying what I have heard before.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: Taxel on February 04, 2012, 09:12:47 PM
Its alright. Its just that some collectors don't want to be referred to as bronies, and some would find it offensive to be personally called a brony. MLP was around before FiM and bronies and some people don't understand/respect that and older collecters can get really upset/angry/defensive/etc about it. It can be a touchy subject is all. :3
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: TheFuzz on February 04, 2012, 09:47:37 PM
I don't quite consider myself a brony, but it IS FiM that got me back into ponies.

1. How you got into MLP and why you like it.
One of my sisters friends collected, I spent a lot of time playing with her ponies when I was young. I even got two of my own to play with. When I heard the new show was a legit good cartoon, I started watching. It brought back my love of ponies instantly.
2. Single? Married? Any dads? Any moms?
Single, no kids.
3. Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss?
It started out just watching the show, but as I collect other toys, it was bound to happen.
4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations?
I like them all, as G1 and G2 were part of my childhood, G3 looks the best imo, and G4 is what's currently in stores/look like the characters from the show.
5. Any other pertinent facts I should know in order to truly understand what bronies are about!
I can't say first-hand, but I think it has something to do with guys (and ladies) needing some sort of social acceptance in liking something that's marketed towards a much different group, and/or having people of their own age/gender to talk about ponies with.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: Bounty Trotter on February 17, 2012, 02:42:15 PM
1. How you got into MLP and why you like it.
Started watching the new show, and I got hooked.

2. Single? Married? Any dads? Any moms?
Married, no kids, parents live out of state.

3. Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss?

We watch the show, and just this week started our collection.

4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations?

Not me. I'm not much of a fan of the look of the older generations. My wife though grew up on G1.

5. Any other pertinent facts I should know in order to truly understand what bronies are about!
I'm 33, male, and I totally consider myself a brony. To me, a brony is anyone outside the age demographic who got started with MLP:FiM. I know there's some negative connotations with the term, but from what I've seen, the community is all about sharing a show they love with each other through art, music, and collecting. And I'm all about that.


edit: fixed a formatting error
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: cesprins on February 17, 2012, 04:14:15 PM
To me, a brony is anyone outside the age demographic who got started with MLP:FiM. I know there's some negative connotations with the term, but from what I've seen, the community is all about sharing a show they love with each other through art, music, and collecting. And I'm all about that.[/size][/font]

edit: fixed a formatting error

I think that's the most accurate description. The most important part being "Brony" implies fandom involvement and with what gen they started liking mlp.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: mlpfan on February 17, 2012, 04:23:37 PM
1. How you got into MLP and why you like it. I used to watch it growing up, then by chance i rediscovered it a few months ago, and have been very much into it! I like the animation,charactors,music, everything!
2. Single? Married? I am single
3. Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss? I both collect and watch the show
4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations? I like all of the generations
5. Any other pertinent facts I should know in order to truly understand what bronies are about! a brony can be anyone, so it is hard to understand how a brony becomes a brony or a pegasister:)
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: Cool.Breeze on February 17, 2012, 05:03:21 PM
To me, a brony is anyone outside the age demographic who got started with MLP:FiM. I know there's some negative connotations with the term, but from what I've seen, the community is all about sharing a show they love with each other through art, music, and collecting. And I'm all about that.

edit: fixed a formatting error

I think that's the most accurate description. The most important part being "Brony" implies fandom involvement and with what gen they started liking mlp.

I think I have to agree on this, what Bounty Trotter said does sum up my general opinion of the MLP:FiM fandom. I think I got too wordy and focused on the shadier underbelly when I responded to the 5th question. I still don't know if I'll ever feel comfortable with labeling myself personally as a brony, I don't really feel comfortable with applying labels of any sort to myself;  I would not be offended to be called one, and I definitely fit the bill since FiM is what sucked me back into the ponyverse ;) In any case, one thing is for certain- some incredible and awe-inspiring things have been created by this fandom, and I am no less moved and amazed than any other fan :heart:


Edited to correct quoted user's screen name
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: rearing_palomino164 on February 17, 2012, 07:32:23 PM
Tell me...
1. How you got into MLP and why you like it.
I've always loved horses and I never got to experience mlp when I was younger so, I thought why not start now?

2. Single? Married? Any dads? Any moms?
Does engaged count? lol

3. Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss?
I used to collect g3's and some g1's and stopped, but since then only watch FiM.

4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations?
Not really. The new ponies I'm not a fan of.

5. Any other pertinent facts I should know in order to truly understand what bronies are about!
Ummm, all have a love for ponies.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: Chai on February 17, 2012, 08:39:02 PM
I love both FiM and the G4 ponies and I am certainly not a brony.  It's not that I have a problem with them, but I was a collector before bronies existed and liking FiM was a natural thing for me, as a pony fan.  The main reason I don't call myself a brony is because I don't associate with the fandom at all, since there are some sketchy bits that I don't care for at all.

this. the sketchy bits bother me. i personally know some guys who are into FiM, and who are rude and make it into this dirty thing that takes away from the fun, in my opinion.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: dippindot on February 17, 2012, 09:52:40 PM
1. How you got into MLP and why you like it.
Had the toys as a child in the 90's, owned the movie and watched it over and over and over. I also love Lauren Faust, so whenever I heard she was doing the new G4 ponies show, I gave it a shot, and thoroughly enjoyed it.

I love the variety of ponies and just the general small pony cuteness of them.  They are great toys!

2. Single? Married? Any dads? Any moms?
Married, no kids

3. Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss?
Both

4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations?
Don't care for G3.5.  Their heads freak me out.  The rest though, are all equally awesome to me.


5. Any other pertinent facts I should know in order to truly understand what bronies are about!

Bronies are 'bros' who watch 'ponies', specifically the FiM show.  But it's not like the word is in the dictionary.  The meaning is always evolving.

The way I look at it, bronies are the mid-20 year old guys who check out memebase and 4-chan, and the people who can identify with that culture.  That means, you can be a 30 year old woman, or a 50 year old man, or a 15 year old boy, and still be a brony, because you are identifying with the culture that consists mainly of 20ish guys who watch MLP:FiM and make creative transformations (fics, videos, memes) about them. 
 
I don't identify as a brony, mostly because I'm interested in ALL the ponies Hasbro is releasing, and I haven't met a brony yet who gave a hoot about any of them that weren't in the show.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: Icecrystalline on February 18, 2012, 03:01:26 AM
This would be so much easier for me if I knew the set-in-stone definition of a brony....! Well, I am me, and I collect G1's. I own several G2's that I got as a child, and a few G3's that I decided to keep because they are cute. I am a girl, and I love watching F.I.M, until the other day I swore never to even look at it because I just don't have the time and have a very strong love for G1's and wasn't going to be distracted by G4's! I absolutely adore FIM, it is good for when you want a little 'me' time and a laugh :) So, I'm not a brony, I don't think, but I am a fermale G1 collector and watcher of FIM. :D xxx
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: MintySocks on February 18, 2012, 07:34:47 AM
Thanks everyone who not only answered but interviewed their friends! XD This is shaping into quite a nice, meaningful discussion. :heart:
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: TheBeatlesPkmnFan42 on February 18, 2012, 08:10:57 AM
Ooh, I wanna do this:

1. How you got into MLP and why you like it.
Some people I watch on DeviantART were into it and I got curious. I then found out that Lauren Faust made and I felt I HAD to see it. I started watching it from episode 1 and got addicted.
2. Single? Married? Any dads? Any moms?
Single. Plus I'm only 15...3.
Do you collect or just watch the show and discuss?
Collect. A lot.
4. Have you developed an interest in the other pony generations?
I decided to watch the other generations out of curiosity I liked the G1 cartoons (both the original and Tales), I thought G3 was decent, and thought the only good 3.5s were Waiting For the Winter Wishes Festival (long title) and Twinkle Wish Adventure. As for the G1, G2, G3, and G3.5 toys and merch, I'm way to addicted.
5. Any other pertinent facts I should know in order to truly understand what bronies are about!
First, what I think a Brony is. Someone outside the target demographic who likes G4 of MLP. Most only like G4, while others like more than that one generation (like me). Some bronies make fan art, fan music, fan fics, etc

Wow. I typed to much.
Title: Re: Bronies, come answer my questions!
Post by: TokiBear on February 18, 2012, 09:05:00 AM
I know you asked for only bronies, but I'm just going to leave a tidbit here:

That all depends on your personal interpretation of the word 'brony'. In my opinion, if you like the show FiM, regardless of age, gender, sexual orientation, race, etc., etc., you're a 'brony'. And I know several people who would agree.

I love both FiM and the G4 ponies and I am certainly not a brony.  It's not that I have a problem with them, but I was a collector before bronies existed and liking FiM was a natural thing for me, as a pony fan.  The main reason I don't call myself a brony is because I don't associate with the fandom at all, since there are some sketchy bits that I don't care for at all.

This is me as well.  I don't have any issues with Bronies just don't associate much with the fandom.  The responses in this thread are really great to read though.  Love em.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal