Real ponies that seemed like fakies

[Koudoawaia]

To be honest, all of G2 look like fakies to me

[LadyPinwheel]

I think that Piggy ponies at first where thought to be fakies too.

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

[Miss_Pompon]

I thought my UK variant tail-less Romper (happy tails pony) was a fakie, so I donated her in a shoebox to a child during the one of the Balkan conflicts.

Serves me right for not giving her one of my good ponies.

Oh my ! I feel for you Starfall !

[Leave a Whisper]

The G2s and the Piggy Ponies look like fakies, especially the jointed G2s

[otocolobus_manul]

A lot of the more gimmicky g1s and g4s, and any poseable ponies look off to me. Also the g1 eyebrow princesses - I find them terrifying.

[Leave a Whisper]

A lot of the more gimmicky g1s and g4s, and any poseable ponies look off to me. Also the g1 eyebrow princesses - I find them terrifying.

Really? I think they're hilarious! Cracks me up every time I see em. They just need glasses and a mustache to complete their disguise.

[otocolobus_manul]

A lot of the more gimmicky g1s and g4s, and any poseable ponies look off to me. Also the g1 eyebrow princesses - I find them terrifying.

Really? I think they're hilarious! Cracks me up every time I see em. They just need glasses and a mustache to complete their disguise.

They could be undercover investigators in the pony world - "I mustache you a question! Haha get it? Now who robbed Megan's house" 

[CloudyGlow]

The g1 plush ponies.  Even though the first time I saw them was on the mylittlewiki site, I couldn't believe they were for real.

[mlp_loving]

I think that Piggy ponies at first where thought to be fakies too.

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

I can definitely see that lol.

Post Merge: May 12, 2015, 12:41:12 PM

Swirly Whirly kinda reminds me of an eligible fakie.  The Secret Surprise ponies as well.

visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login


Pic credit to Google for both.

[flyawayraven]

Yeah the Sundae Best ponies definitely rank up there. I think we had determined they were sculpted using a blend of the CP mold and whatever else Hasbro had on hand. O.o

[Leave a Whisper]

A lot of the more gimmicky g1s and g4s, and any poseable ponies look off to me. Also the g1 eyebrow princesses - I find them terrifying.

Really? I think they're hilarious! Cracks me up every time I see em. They just need glasses and a mustache to complete their disguise.

They could be undercover investigators in the pony world - "I mustache you a question! Haha get it? Now who robbed Megan's house" 

Doo doo doo doo doo Inspector Pony doo doo doo doo doo Woohoo! Go Pony go!


....the piggy ponies eyes are disturbing, they must be related to BBEs 

[Diamond]

My daughter thought the Hair Do Pony Bangles we found at a thrift store was a fakie.  Good thing I study the books!  LOL  Though what a UK pony was doing in a thrift store in the US is beyond me.

Oh and when my daughter first started collecting G3's we had some G2's we though where fake till we got our first book on ponies. 

[Galactica]

I thought G2s were fake when they first came out- I remember I was outraged that they said My Little Pony on the packaging.  After they didn't go away I realized they were real...

[Shenanigans]

When I was little I thought the Sweetheart Sisters were fakies and didn't like them

[hathorcat]

Secret Surprise! They are just so different - I think if I did not know I would probably have clicked by those assuming them to be fakies or at least a different toy brand.