The MLP Arena

Pony Talk => Pony Corral => Topic started by: ashlyne on June 29, 2017, 11:34:59 AM

Title: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: ashlyne on June 29, 2017, 11:34:59 AM
EDIT:   Now taking orders!   
http://mlparena.com/index.php?topic=387501.msg1658378#msg1658378
 :party:



(Previous information)
For those of you who don’t know what Adventure Cards are, see here:
Spoiler
Baby Blue Ribbon and the Adventure Card board game (poster) were available through the mail order and points program.  The game could be played with or without special Adventure Cards, which gave commands like Go Ahead 2, or Miss a Turn.   These cards were only available in specially marked packages of ponies sold in stores, two per package.  Since there are a whopping 42 cards, and they were only available for a short time, they are difficult to find and even harder set to complete.

http://mylittlewiki.org/wiki/The_Adventures_in_Ponyland_Game#Adventure_Cards

I’d like to get your thoughts on making replica Adventure Cards.    Every now and then someone will ask me about doing them and I’ve held off for a few reasons:

- potentially dropping the current value of the originals
Spoiler
on one hand, good for those looking for originals still, but not so good for those trying to sell them and those that already spent $$ on theirs and don’t want to see their collection value drop

- accidently/purposefully being sold as originals in the secondhand market
Spoiler
I’ve added a small statement on both sides about them being Custom Replicas, to distinguish them from the originals, nothing that impedes the image or text, but still noticeable should anyone resell them. 

- finding good quality card paper and printer for the job, something that meets people’s expectations
Spoiler
I found paper that’s a close match to the original card stock, glossy on one side, matte on the other, and it’s compatible with my printer.  They’re not exactly the same, pixel-to-pixel, but close enough and actually cleaner, brighter, and more consistent than the original scans. Also, while the paper front is glossy, the ink is not, so unlike the originals, they would not be completely glossy across the whole surface.

- copyright issues with Hasbro
Spoiler
If I go through with this project, I wouldn’t sell on ebay, etsy or other public shopping site. Basically, if someone wants a set, they could contact me and spread word of the project to others looking.   I care more about getting a good product to fellow collectors and also not overstepping my bounds with Hasbro’s products than I do about making a quick buck ;) 



If there's enough interest and positive reaction to the idea, I'd consider making and selling these sets to other collectors.

As far as pricing goes, I’m thinking around $55* due to the work that’s already gone into cleaning up the scans, the paper and ink expense, and I also cut these by hand and there’s time involved in that process.   
Spoiler
*Probably would include free USA priority shipping with tracking, or $50 for untracked economy only if paypal GIFT payment is sent, with the understanding that I won’t be responsible for lost or damaged packages;  International shipping would be worked out on a per-person basis


At least initially, only orders of full sets of 42 will be made. 
Spoiler
Individual card requests will be much harder to do because they artwork is laid out in groups to fill up a sheet.  I would have to spend time in moving around the requested cards, and depending on how many are requested, they may not fill a full sheet. So pricing would vary on individual cards, but would be at least $2 a card just for the time involved, and maybe more depending on how many is ordered.   
 

I’m working on the gameboard and die as well, although the gameboard is huge. It was made to use full-sized ponies as the game pieces!   I’m researching different options for large-scale printing but haven’t found a good option yet.


Anyway, I’d like to get your thoughts on this project – ethical issues, pricing, interest.   If there are a lot of legitimate objections, I won’t pursue it. If you don’t feel comfortable publicly posting, feel free to PM me.   I’m just trying to gather information (not orders) at this point :)   Thanks!

Update 06/30/2017  ORIGINAL CARDS vs TEST CARDS: 
visitors can't see pics , please register or login


Similarities:
Same size

A close match in thickness of card stock

Glossy on the front, matte on the back 
visitors can't see pics , please register or login


Original scanned artwork of rainbow and pony

A close match to the blue and purple colors used on the back

A close match to the font used


Differences:
Card stock is a brighter white

Copyright information removed and replaced with “2017 Custom Replica Adventure Cards” on both sides, to avoid mistaking them as originals.  Probably going to make this text a smidgen larger and bolder than what appears here. 
visitors can't see pics , please register or login


Glossy side is slightly different type of glossy;  ink is matte, so where the rainbow, text and pony is printed, it is not glossy like the background 
visitors can't see pics , please register or login


Back side artwork is recreated so that the colors are more uniform; scans used as templates for accuracy

Rainbow artwork on front is the same rainbow in the same place on every card (something that is not uniform on the originals)

Pony artwork may be bumped up or down a bit so that it doesn’t come so close to the edge of the card

     
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: Skeen on June 29, 2017, 11:46:11 AM
10/10 would buy this from you.  :)
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: nessa16 on June 29, 2017, 12:55:54 PM
That sounds so cool!  Especially, if you get the board figured out.  Was the dice paper/cardboard also?
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: LadyMoondancer on June 29, 2017, 01:01:34 PM
I think it's a great idea!

Imma be blunt:  I don't care one whit if originals (of MLPs or cards or anything else) is "devalued."  I think it's great when more people can afford replicas and complete their collection. People who want a guaranteed return on an investment should go for government bonds, not collect toys, lol.
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: ashlyne on June 29, 2017, 01:20:15 PM
That sounds so cool!  Especially, if you get the board figured out.  Was the dice paper/cardboard also?

Yes, and I could replicate that as well. Although I much prefer a hard die.  The paper ones get roughed up fast!

I think it's a great idea!

Imma be blunt:  I don't care one whit if originals (of MLPs or cards or anything else) is "devalued."  I think it's great when more people can afford replicas and complete their collection. People who want a guaranteed return on an investment should go for government bonds, not collect toys, lol.

I agree with that, anyone that's collecting ponies or most modern toys because they think they'll get rich on it is taking a huge gamble. Collecting is not a sound investment!  Too many variables.  But there are special cases where you need to liquidate a collection (severe illness, to save a pet, loss of job, new baby).   I can understand that in those cases, it would be important to get back something close to what you put in.    But I think there will always be people (like me) that will seek out the originals over replicas, whether it's flutter wings, seashells, princess accessories or adventure cards.  So they may still hold value.
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: lovesbabysquirmy on June 29, 2017, 03:11:54 PM
Simple answer:  DO IT! 
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: Freeindeed on June 29, 2017, 04:02:30 PM
That would be awesome if you made some reproduction sets available! As long as they say somewhere on them that they are not original, I don't see the problem... and I would imagine there will probably still be a market for the originals, because some people don't like having anything other than original items in their collection. I mean, look at the reproduction Sea Pony shells-- the original ones have still held their value fairly well. 

Besides, like LadyMoondancer said, people shouldn't be collecting toys as an investment. Thinking about value is important, but as long as you don't mass produce them, and as long as you make sure they clearly say they aren't original, I don't think it would affect things too much.

Also, the giant pony game board sounds awesome! I didn't realize it was so big. I do have Baby Blue Ribbon in my collection, but no accessories for her... I've never seen the whole set in person before, I bet it's awesome. :)
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: Carrehz on June 29, 2017, 04:08:11 PM
I have no problem with replica *anything*, personally, as long as it's very clear that it's not the real deal :) Sounds like you've got that covered. I'd go for it :)

I don't think it'd devalue the actual cards. I don't collect the Adventure Cards personally, but if I did I would probably want the originals no matter how cheap (etc) the repros were; I'm sure I'm not the only one :).
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: CrystalSnowflake on June 29, 2017, 08:23:20 PM
I actually like things like this. To me it's a form of preserving the past.
I wouldn't even mind if the cards had some custom border that made them larger and distinct from the originals.
I would be after the art and the game not that it is a perfect duplicate of the original.
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: Stormness_1 on June 30, 2017, 02:09:47 AM
I love this idea. I'd totally be up for buying replicas. I've looked into buying adventure cards before, but always decided against it, because it's a lot of money for a set I'll likely never complete.
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: ashlyne on June 30, 2017, 01:20:36 PM
Thanks for the responses. I'll take any concerns to heart for sure, but overall, I'm hearing a positive response. 

See original post for updated comparison pics and descriptions  (points up)  :)
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: Carrehz on June 30, 2017, 02:15:11 PM
I wouldn't even mind if the cards had some custom border that made them larger and distinct from the originals.

Oooh, I like this idea :D.
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: shelvesofwhimsy on June 30, 2017, 02:37:18 PM
I personally think this is an awesome idea!

Just a few notes from someone who is savvy in photoshop:

I would maybe reconsider the watermark placement , and maybe have it go over some part of the image (I know it doesn't look as good). Only because I could see someone scanning a replica, erasing the mark in photoshop, and then reprinting. I hope no one would do that, but it is just much easier to erase on white, than to have it overlap some part of the image.

Or maybe the overlapping watermark could be on part of the rainbow on the back. I'm not sure if its really a big deal or not, but I wanted to mention it :)

Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: banditpony on June 30, 2017, 02:56:52 PM
I personally think this is an awesome idea!

Just a few notes from someone who is savvy in photoshop:

I would maybe reconsider the watermark placement , and maybe have it go over some part of the image (I know it doesn't look as good). Only because I could see someone scanning a replica, erasing the mark in photoshop, and then reprinting. I hope no one would do that, but it is just much easier to erase on white, than to have it overlap some part of the image.

Or maybe the overlapping watermark could be on part of the rainbow on the back. I'm not sure if its really a big deal or not, but I wanted to mention it :)

Eh.
Anyone who is good in photoshop is able to get around water marks with ease. Something that was scanned, printed on inkjet, and rescanned is going to get ugly moire pattern -- which would more of a general deterrent. 

So I don't think a watermark should be put over the art, because if someone wanted to rescan and reprint they are going to do it anyway.
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: sailorstitch on June 30, 2017, 03:00:21 PM
I'll repeat what I told you at the 2015 Fair after you completed your set. I don't care if you print them on regular computer paper. I just want a set so I can play the game!

sailorstitch
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: shelvesofwhimsy on June 30, 2017, 04:04:46 PM
I personally think this is an awesome idea!

Just a few notes from someone who is savvy in photoshop:

I would maybe reconsider the watermark placement , and maybe have it go over some part of the image (I know it doesn't look as good). Only because I could see someone scanning a replica, erasing the mark in photoshop, and then reprinting. I hope no one would do that, but it is just much easier to erase on white, than to have it overlap some part of the image.

Or maybe the overlapping watermark could be on part of the rainbow on the back. I'm not sure if its really a big deal or not, but I wanted to mention it :)

Eh.
Anyone who is good in photoshop is able to get around water marks with ease. Something that was scanned, printed on inkjet, and rescanned is going to get ugly moire pattern -- which would more of a general deterrent. 

So I don't think a watermark should be put over the art, because if someone wanted to rescan and reprint they are going to do it anyway.

I guess you're right! I didn't think about the quality loss of being scanned multiple times  :P
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: Freeindeed on June 30, 2017, 04:30:41 PM
The cards look really good, ashlyne. Very close to the originals but with enough differences that you can tell they're reproductions.
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: CrystalSnowflake on June 30, 2017, 04:36:29 PM
One thing I would like is to have the cards be a size that fits into the clear card sleeves you can get for other game cards.
And for the game board you could split it into panels rather than try to print it in one huge piece.

Come to think of it I actually have never seen the game board or all the cards.
Did this ever have an original box?
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: kitkatvintage on June 30, 2017, 08:27:10 PM
I think the repros look fantastic so far! I wouldn't mind the watermark/new info being darker or larger if necessary.

Come to think of it I actually have never seen the game board or all the cards.
Did this ever have an original box?

The game board & die were only available as a mail order with Baby Blue Ribbon. The cards were only available as individually packaged bonus items with specially marked ponies for a limited time. That's why the set is super hard to complete & a full repro card set is so desirable. ;)
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: CrystalSnowflake on June 30, 2017, 10:28:26 PM
I would love to see pictures of the set out on a table with a pony to get an idea of the set.
I only had one card and I don't know if I even still have it.
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: LNS on June 30, 2017, 11:19:47 PM
Honestly since it is noted upfront and there is something being put on the cards stating they are reproductions I don't see an issue with it. Very much all for it. :D I'd love to buy the reproduction cards if you do this.
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: Clipper on June 30, 2017, 11:51:40 PM
Sign me up for a set :)
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: tebrighteyes on July 01, 2017, 02:47:16 AM
Already replied to your facebook post but love this idea!!  Hope you are able to make the dice too.   
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: sweetbubbles on July 01, 2017, 04:30:43 AM
want Want WANTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT  :biggrin:

love love love it , I allready have a lot of the originals but would so love a repro set  yayyyyy
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: Taffeta on July 07, 2017, 08:45:42 AM
I think the repros look fantastic so far! I wouldn't mind the watermark/new info being darker or larger if necessary.

Come to think of it I actually have never seen the game board or all the cards.
Did this ever have an original box?

The game board & die were only available as a mail order with Baby Blue Ribbon. The cards were only available as individually packaged bonus items with specially marked ponies for a limited time. That's why the set is super hard to complete & a full repro card set is so desirable. ;)

I have a strong feeling the game also came as a pull out in a UK pony comic or something of that nature as I am ninety percent sure I have it from childhood, but I don't remember if the cards ever happened as well or if they didn't :/ the pony certainly didn't. Very odd.

Back to the original issue - If people are happy buying replicas that is generally their decision. So long as those replicas are clearly marked as replicas in a way that can't be mistaken for the original or resold by a nefarious person as the original, it's then a free choice situation really. I would support making the replica print text darker so it stands out more even if someone put it as a blurry auction image. The idea of giving them extra borders to make them stand out is also good because I imagine most people who would want this want it to play the game. If they were serious about actual exact cards, they'd probably go after the originals, so minor differences to make them stand out might be good to consider...
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: LadyMoondancer on July 07, 2017, 10:08:10 AM
I would 100% buy a set.  <3
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: kitkatvintage on July 08, 2017, 02:17:18 PM
I think the repros look fantastic so far! I wouldn't mind the watermark/new info being darker or larger if necessary.

Come to think of it I actually have never seen the game board or all the cards.
Did this ever have an original box?

The game board & die were only available as a mail order with Baby Blue Ribbon. The cards were only available as individually packaged bonus items with specially marked ponies for a limited time. That's why the set is super hard to complete & a full repro card set is so desirable. ;)

I have a strong feeling the game also came as a pull out in a UK pony comic or something of that nature as I am ninety percent sure I have it from childhood, but I don't remember if the cards ever happened as well or if they didn't :/ the pony certainly didn't. Very odd.

Back to the original issue - If people are happy buying replicas that is generally their decision. So long as those replicas are clearly marked as replicas in a way that can't be mistaken for the original or resold by a nefarious person as the original, it's then a free choice situation really. I would support making the replica print text darker so it stands out more even if someone put it as a blurry auction image. The idea of giving them extra borders to make them stand out is also good because I imagine most people who would want this want it to play the game. If they were serious about actual exact cards, they'd probably go after the originals, so minor differences to make them stand out might be good to consider...

I think I've seen Adventure Cards that are different than the US set which I assume would have been a UK set. From memory they were not full color... possibly only shades of blue ink? I really don't know anything about how they were distributed or how they may or may not match up the the US versions, but I'm sure I've seen pictures of them online over the years. :)
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: jrr74 on July 18, 2017, 07:38:30 PM
You know how we sometimes say *grabby hands* or *sneaks in and takes ....*?  Well that was not me  :P  I was finally blessed by the pony gods and managed to score a set of replica cards, and well...I am pretty excited about the whole thing

visitors can't see pics , please register or login


 :frolic:  <-- if I was a rainbow colored pony with magical powers, this is what I would look like right now because of these beautiful cards

PS-I was serving as a guinea pig, but all so worth it  ^.^
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: LadyMoondancer on July 18, 2017, 09:58:17 PM
So cool!  I only have two cards.  They came packaged with SS Angel as some kind of special promotion.  I believe there was also a brochure that advertised Baby Blue Ribbon as a mail order, but I lost the brochure as a child.
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: princessluna11706 on July 18, 2017, 11:22:18 PM
I think this is a great idea :)
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: Stormness_1 on July 19, 2017, 02:05:42 AM
You know how we sometimes say *grabby hands* or *sneaks in and takes ....*?  Well that was not me  :P  I was finally blessed by the pony gods and managed to score a set of replica cards, and well...I am pretty excited about the whole thing

visitors can't see pics , please register or login


 :frolic:  <-- if I was a rainbow colored pony with magical powers, this is what I would look like right now because of these beautiful cards

PS-I was serving as a guinea pig, but all so worth it  ^.^
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   
They look amazing framed!!! What size frame is that? Something I'll definitely think about when I get my set. I was thinking of doing a custom designed folder, but they look awesome in that frame.. I'm so torn now!!
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: Taffeta on July 19, 2017, 06:50:39 AM
I think the repros look fantastic so far! I wouldn't mind the watermark/new info being darker or larger if necessary.

Come to think of it I actually have never seen the game board or all the cards.
Did this ever have an original box?

The game board & die were only available as a mail order with Baby Blue Ribbon. The cards were only available as individually packaged bonus items with specially marked ponies for a limited time. That's why the set is super hard to complete & a full repro card set is so desirable. ;)

I have a strong feeling the game also came as a pull out in a UK pony comic or something of that nature as I am ninety percent sure I have it from childhood, but I don't remember if the cards ever happened as well or if they didn't :/ the pony certainly didn't. Very odd.

Back to the original issue - If people are happy buying replicas that is generally their decision. So long as those replicas are clearly marked as replicas in a way that can't be mistaken for the original or resold by a nefarious person as the original, it's then a free choice situation really. I would support making the replica print text darker so it stands out more even if someone put it as a blurry auction image. The idea of giving them extra borders to make them stand out is also good because I imagine most people who would want this want it to play the game. If they were serious about actual exact cards, they'd probably go after the originals, so minor differences to make them stand out might be good to consider...

I think I've seen Adventure Cards that are different than the US set which I assume would have been a UK set. From memory they were not full color... possibly only shades of blue ink? I really don't know anything about how they were distributed or how they may or may not match up the the US versions, but I'm sure I've seen pictures of them online over the years. :)

Maybe in the comic. Need to ask LadyG if she knows. In any case, it would make sense that something existed, but definitely not in packages.

Jrr74 they look great framed up like that.
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: Chrissytree on July 19, 2017, 01:24:02 PM
I think the repros look fantastic so far! I wouldn't mind the watermark/new info being darker or larger if necessary.

Come to think of it I actually have never seen the game board or all the cards.
Did this ever have an original box?

The game board & die were only available as a mail order with Baby Blue Ribbon. The cards were only available as individually packaged bonus items with specially marked ponies for a limited time. That's why the set is super hard to complete & a full repro card set is so desirable. ;)

I have a strong feeling the game also came as a pull out in a UK pony comic or something of that nature as I am ninety percent sure I have it from childhood, but I don't remember if the cards ever happened as well or if they didn't :/ the pony certainly didn't. Very odd.

Back to the original issue - If people are happy buying replicas that is generally their decision. So long as those replicas are clearly marked as replicas in a way that can't be mistaken for the original or resold by a nefarious person as the original, it's then a free choice situation really. I would support making the replica print text darker so it stands out more even if someone put it as a blurry auction image. The idea of giving them extra borders to make them stand out is also good because I imagine most people who would want this want it to play the game. If they were serious about actual exact cards, they'd probably go after the originals, so minor differences to make them stand out might be good to consider...

I think I've seen Adventure Cards that are different than the US set which I assume would have been a UK set. From memory they were not full color... possibly only shades of blue ink? I really don't know anything about how they were distributed or how they may or may not match up the the US versions, but I'm sure I've seen pictures of them online over the years. :)

Maybe in the comic. Need to ask LadyG if she knows. In any case, it would make sense that something existed, but definitely not in packages.

Jrr74 they look great framed up like that.

I have the set you're talking about. tbh I'm not totally sure where I got them but I'm thinking the UK Club. They are just blue and white. I'd coloured mine in and was working on removing the colour but seem to have been distracted :P They just came in a sheet that you had to cut up. The game board was paper as far as I remember.
This is most of them:

visitors can't see pics , please register or login
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: Taffeta on July 19, 2017, 01:29:12 PM
Ohh. Hrm. I was imagining blue paper for some reason. I think I may have some of those somewhere. Thanks for posting, Chrissytree. Not quite as high quality as the US one, but still cute ;) (Did the game also come with the club here then?)
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: LadyMoondancer on July 19, 2017, 01:35:29 PM
Do they have any instructions on the back?  The US Adventure Cards had stuff like "Move two space" or "Skip a turn", that kind of thing.
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: Chrissytree on July 19, 2017, 01:36:12 PM
Ohh. Hrm. I was imagining blue paper for some reason. I think I may have some of those somewhere. Thanks for posting, Chrissytree. Not quite as high quality as the US one, but still cute ;) (Did the game also come with the club here then?)

As far as I remember. Just a folded paper board, single sided? I don't think there was a dice.

And yes, there were directions on the back:
visitors can't see pics , please register or login

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

visitors can't see pics , please register or login


*edit to resize images.
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: Taffeta on July 19, 2017, 01:39:25 PM
Ohh. Hrm. I was imagining blue paper for some reason. I think I may have some of those somewhere. Thanks for posting, Chrissytree. Not quite as high quality as the US one, but still cute ;) (Did the game also come with the club here then?)

As far as I remember. Just a folded paper board, single sided? I don't think there was a dice.

I think so. A big folded out sheet of paper. Has US ponies on it and Baby Blue Ribbon but absolutely no explanation of what it was meant to be. I remember it confused me as a kid and only when I learned who Baby Blue Ribbon was and what she was meant to be did I know how it made sense. Wouldn't surprise me if the UK cards had nothing on them, being that the game I don''t think had any actual instructions or information. It was almost sort of a poster O.o. I don't know if I have a picture of it in my files somewhere, but definitely an afterthought that was nothing like the US concept.
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: jrr74 on July 19, 2017, 02:43:08 PM


They look amazing framed!!! What size frame is that? Something I'll definitely think about when I get my set. I was thinking of doing a custom designed folder, but they look awesome in that frame.. I'm so torn now!!

It is a 18 x 24 frame opening.  Perfect size for this card set.  I also ordered a post-it memo board from Target.  It has a tacky surface, just like the post-it notes, maybe a little more so.  Downside to board was when I reposition a card once in a while because I did not like how it laid, I was concerned about causing creases in them.  Didn't happen, but felt like I came close a couple of times
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: Stormness_1 on July 21, 2017, 02:30:56 AM
Thank you for the info, jrr74!
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: mylittELLEpony on July 21, 2017, 07:46:59 AM
You know how we sometimes say *grabby hands* or *sneaks in and takes ....*?  Well that was not me  :P  I was finally blessed by the pony gods and managed to score a set of replica cards, and well...I am pretty excited about the whole thing

visitors can't see pics , please register or login


 :frolic:  <-- if I was a rainbow colored pony with magical powers, this is what I would look like right now because of these beautiful cards

PS-I was serving as a guinea pig, but all so worth it  ^.^
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 
I HAVE A MIGHTY NEED!  :dropjaw:
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: lostpony on July 21, 2017, 04:34:42 PM
I didn't read through the whole thread so some of what I'm about to say might not be original....

You could address the concern of competing with the originals / misrepresented as originals by having something clearly printed small on them somewhere that says "replica" or something like that.

I think these would be fun for those who want to collect them for enjoyment, either as uncut sheets or cut into cards, and I especially think this would be waaay cool to have available for us to buy as games for small pony meets.  I'm in talks with another member here that I found who lives near me and I'd love to have some fun little original pony game for us to play, in replica so we don't have to worry about play damage, to offer as part of a small meet if we do find enough members to get together for one.

$52 for a 42 card set seems pretty cheap and isn't exactly making you a huge profit so hopefully you won't run into any copyright issues.  I think based on the eBay G4 traffic that Hasbro is happy enough letting small operators go under the radar so long as they don't ramp up a big enough operation to compete with Hasbro so hopefully you'll be fine.

Great idea and you've already put in a lot of work.  Sounds great!  Do it please!

Oh wait I just noticed:  this set is the answer to the question of life, the universe, and everything.  :frolic:
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: plushroo on July 21, 2017, 07:33:44 PM
Put me down for a set once you start taking orders. I have only a dozen or so original cards and they are so hard to find. I'd be happy with a replica set.
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: Kazzellin on July 23, 2017, 02:37:08 PM
That's the one where there was a giant poster printed on the back of the game board, right? I'd take a set, just for the poster! Aurora has one for her pony room, and it's awesome!

As for printing the huge thing, I would contact the guys over at Offworld Designs. They do custom work, can get you a quote, and memory says they have a giant printer for making wall scrolls, so could probably make the board.
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: Aadra310 on July 23, 2017, 04:00:25 PM
Oh, cool!  I'm all for replica stuff.  I have replica princess wands, crown clips, and adult sea pony shells!  Great for those of us that have to complete everything!  I'd probably buy a set, too!
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: Kazzellin on July 26, 2017, 11:10:30 AM
I apologize, apparently it's Legion Printing that I'm thinking of, not Offworld Designs. Pretty sure my sister has their business card; we're going to try finding it.

Edit: Found it!  http://legion-bhm.com
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: ashlyne on July 26, 2017, 12:03:58 PM
I apologize, apparently it's Legion Printing that I'm thinking of, not Offworld Designs. Pretty sure my sister has their business card; we're going to try finding it.

Edit: Found it!  http://legion-bhm.com


Thanks, although there may be copyright issues in going with an outside printing company.  Sometimes they can be pretty strict about that.  Checking it out though ;)   

Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: sweetbubbles on July 30, 2017, 12:20:51 PM
I see a replica set omg want !!! are you allready taking orders?am looking like grazy but must overseen something !!! where can I orderrrrrr ^^
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: ashlyne on July 30, 2017, 02:51:22 PM
I see a replica set omg want !!! are you allready taking orders?am looking like grazy but must overseen something !!! where can I orderrrrrr ^^

I'll set up a sales thread next week.   Got all the details worked out and have begun printing some sets, but it's going to be a crazy busy week getting ready for a ponymeet.   So after that's over (next weekend), I'll be ready to focus on taking orders. I'll post the sales link here when it's all set up ;)
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: wizzer218 on July 30, 2017, 04:15:28 PM
Doesn't bother me any...I would buy a set ;) $55 is good deal.
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: baby_gusty on August 03, 2017, 03:30:15 AM
Can't wait until I can order a set! <3 this is amazing! What a great work you've done!
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: sweetbubbles on August 03, 2017, 04:34:44 PM
You are the best ^^ I take a set for sure

enjoy the ponymeet ^^

I see a replica set omg want !!! are you allready taking orders?am looking like grazy but must overseen something !!! where can I orderrrrrr ^^

I'll set up a sales thread next week.   Got all the details worked out and have begun printing some sets, but it's going to be a crazy busy week getting ready for a ponymeet.   So after that's over (next weekend), I'll be ready to focus on taking orders. I'll post the sales link here when it's all set up ;)
Title: Re: Thoughts on a replica Adventure Card set??
Post by: ashlyne on August 07, 2017, 08:00:59 AM
Now set up to take orders!
http://mlparena.com/index.php?topic=387501.msg1658378#msg1658378

 :rainbow:
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal