The MLP Arena
Pony Talk => MLP Nirvana => Topic started by: Tiara546 on March 16, 2017, 08:15:10 AM
-
Hello all,
I have bought this Pinwheel variant a little while ago from a seller in Newzealand and couldn't find info on her anywhere yet, including the wiki which I would like to add her to.
According to the seller, she would be an Argie. Her first impression look from her colour scheme is like someone had painted a Pinwheel symbol on a Peachy, but she has different eye colour, the hair/body plastic texture is what I know from Argies and she doesn't have any "regular" hoof markings either. Her symbol looks quite genuine, too.
Can anyone confirm her being an Argie, or does anyone have further info on her?
visitors can't see pics , please register or login
Hooves:
visitors can't see pics , please register or login
Thank you in advance!
-
Wow!! Never seen it before!!
ETA: I have just spoken to a friend from argentina, and she said that these are considered false. That the symbol has been painted on an argie CC or such.
But let's see what others say ^^
-
She's so pretty!!! I'm following this thread to learn more about her :)
-
I just found out in a little research that Argie Cotton Candy has these caracteristics including the eye colour, perhaps they did a Pinwheel out of a symbolless Cotton Candy?
-
http://mlparena.com/archive/gallery2/main.php?g2_view=core.ShowItem&g2_itemId=469555
Unconfirmed :)
-
She is one of the unconfirmed Argie ponies :) Quite a few odd CP and other pose ponies have cropped up with the wrong symbols, you can see some of them in the nirvana gallery.
http://mlparena.com/archive/gallery2/main.php?g2_view=core.ShowItem&g2_itemId=348289&g2_page=2
Quite a few of the Argie ponies have NC hoof markings too :bigups:
Love pkw xxx
-
Thank you Caro!
I looked up the member who submitted her to the gallery and it is indeed someone from Newzealand. I have asked her via PM if she is the one who sold her to me, would love to find out wether or not there is a second one known.
Also thank you PKW, will take a look!
-
Could she be like the unfinished Nova ponies with different symbols ?
-
Wondering, are they really called unfinished if they have everything a pony should have, just in a different way? To me, ponies with non-matching eyes/symbols would rather be hybrids than unfinished ones?
-
Wondering, are they really called unfinished if they have everything a pony should have, just in a different way? To me, ponies with non-matching eyes/symbols would rather be hybrids than unfinished ones?
I think they are called Unconfirmed rather than unfinished. The album has both types of ponies ^^
-
I understand, thank you :)
-
oh cool variant, even if unconfirmed - hey, is the paint stamp a bit thick on her?
I have some of the sparkler variants and Delaney's flutterby, and a butterscotch/microphone argie. All to me have somewhat thicker than what I would consider normal argie symbols... and since they all technically could have started life as another regular argie, I agree that some stock could have been "wiped clean" and re-stamped as I think there were stencils found or some such reported similar a few years back
it would be neat to know if they did test ponies before final production runs ... dunno
-
I recall, awhile back that someone was "making" these and selling them on eBay. It was during the time of the "repaired hair" Argies. If I remember rightly, I think someone had factory stamps and the blank trotting pose ponies, as well as other bits and they were cobbling ponies together.
It must have been in 2004-2005 and there were LOADS of Argies on eBay, many real and some "made up" and some "repaired hair".
It's hard at this point to know what is genuine, what is truly unfinished and what is made up.
I need to go back and refresh my memory on this subject.
Love pkw xxx
-
Wow, she is pretty. This is really interesting!
-
Thats an interesting information pkw. From the other "unconfirmed" ponies in the gallery, it really looks like someone made them from usual and less expensive CP ponies of the first six. It's a shame I paid that much for her, $100.
The member who submitted the pony to the gallery is indeed the one who sold her to me via Ebay and answered: "pinwheel is one of about 30 i bought directly from argentina from a very dodgy seller,as luck would have it,I got my ponies whilst many did not,I have at least 10 other argies that are somewhat unknown [...]
And indeed, she has other ponies in CP and Walking pose, most with butterfly symbols in different colours, some unfinished, also a Minty with Sweet Stuff's symbol. Seen as a whole, all of these definately look made-up. I will add this story to the wiki I think, this is quite valuable background information.
Another question, what are those "repaired hair" ponies about?
Maycrestmom, could you perhaps post pictures of yours? Would love to see.
I checked back her symbols and find it difficult to tell if they are a bit thick, they are definately well made but have slight imperfections to one side where the paint is a bit thinner than it should be, and it is visible that it became thinner in the process of making these, during when they were still wet. Also, both sides do not have the same colour.
Close-up DS (click to enlarge!):
visitors can't see pics , please register or login
visitors can't see pics , please register or login
Close-up NDS (click to enlarge!):
visitors can't see pics , please register or login
visitors can't see pics , please register or login
Post Merge: March 17, 2017, 07:10:45 AM
Wow!! Never seen it before!!
ETA: I have just spoken to a friend from argentina, and she said that these are considered false. That the symbol has been painted on an argie CC or such.
But let's see what others say ^^
Btw thank you LadyPinwheel, I saw your edited comment just now. This is what I thought, will add the info on the wiki accordingly. :)
Post Merge: March 17, 2017, 02:21:30 PM
Well I have edited the wiki by putting warnings in the main Argie page and also marking my variant as fake, together with the history stated that pkw provided, see here:
http://mylittlewiki.org/wiki/Argentina#Collector_Pose_Ponies (http://mylittlewiki.org/wiki/Argentina#Collector_Pose_Ponies)
http://mylittlewiki.org/wiki/Pinwheel#Argentinian_Pinwheel_Variant_IV (http://mylittlewiki.org/wiki/Pinwheel#Argentinian_Pinwheel_Variant_IV)
http://mylittlewiki.org/wiki/G1_Cotton_Candy#Argentinian_Cotton_Candy_Variant_IV (http://mylittlewiki.org/wiki/G1_Cotton_Candy#Argentinian_Cotton_Candy_Variant_IV)
But browsing through the other Argie ponies, I noticed many which with my new knowledge I would estimate as "made up" ponies, too. I would like to raise awareness inside the community, but don't want to give out any false information either, at the risk to mark a real prototype as "fake". Do you have any idea how we could identify the fakes together so that proper mentions can be added in the wiki afterwards? If anyone would like to help with editing, that would be great but the next step right now really is the identification part.
Of course, any more "history" info would be welcome, too!
-
It's hard to know for sure either way, but I have also heard the story about the symbols being added on to more common Argie ponies later on. The vast majority have the same body/hair colour base as one of the original six ponies, so it is plausible. The walking ones are believed to be unfinished ponies, but the symbols may have been added later. It has been discussed a few times on here before, but not for a while.
'Repaired the hair' was a common thing for some Argie sellers back in the day, so sadly it is entirely possible that they are later modifications. In addition, there used to be a LOT of MOC Argies around, and none of these have ever shown up on card :/
If it is the seller in New Zealand I'm thinking of, she bought them in good faith and hasn't really been around the community since we started hearing the stories.
-
Thank you for posting LadyG :bigups: I knew you'd remember this.
Love pkw xxx
-
Here we go :)
http://mlparena.com/index.php/topic,382493.msg1589880.html#msg1589880
Love pkw xxx
-
Interesting, thank you! ^_^