So whose your bad penny?

[himmie]

NBBE Baby Cuddles...I must have at least six of her now. Ugh.

[CottonTALE]

Surprisingly G4 Applejack in various forms still have yet to find the elusive FS one, but I can dream!

[Applejack]

Pinkie pie....every store I go to (Walmart......CVS....Family dollar....EVERYWERE)

With how many pinkie pies I find I could easily start an army...which I am thinking about doing.

[Shenanigans]

G4- Twilight Sparkle. G1- Baby Shaggy.

[TwistedWindSox]

Skyflier. At one point I think I had 7 of her. x_x

[Mermaid]

It used to be pony bride. At one time back in the "come home with 10 g1s a week from thrifting" days, I had 12 of her!!

Now for me it's baby glory. I currently own 3 and recently sold 3.

[Private_Bubbles]

G1 Bow Tie, I have somehow ended up with three of her.

[Cate_Dartfinger]

Oh, Sundance for sure! From the last three lots I won, I ended up with 5 of her, plus one SS version.  I'm not even that big of a fan of her either...

[Bow Tie]

Sundance! I have 3 now. 1 SS and 2 regular and if I go through with this one lot purchase, I'll soon have 4 of her. Oh joy.

And of course Pinkie Pie.

[scarletjul]

G3 Pinkie and Rainbow Dash but it used to be Sparkleworks - I used to find her at every.  Single.  Thrift store.

G1 s would be baity Moondancers.  I actually don't find the CP ponies that often (even Peachy.)

[foalpatrol]

G3 Wysteria.  I ended up with every single version of her (and then some) without even trying.  I don't find her that appealling!

[Baby Sugarberry]

For the longest time, it was High Flyer of all ponies.  She turned up constantly, I think my record was two in one day.  Not that I really minded, She's a childhood pony and still one of my favs.

[Einhornbaby]

for me? Family ponies. If I find a pony, chances are super high that its one of the family ponies lol.

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

[kayveryn]

I seem to end up with a lot of Sherbet... I do like her, but don't really need 8, and they're kinda hard to customize...(the couple that are in bait condition...)

Kayveryn

[PinkRosedust]

for me? Family ponies. If I find a pony, chances are super high that its one of the family ponies lol.

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

I get them a lot too, mainly the Sweet Celebrations! But for G1s it's probably Sundance, regular and TAF (though I love her so I don't mind too much). For G3, I find Baby Romperooni all the time.