The Most Sought After

[Brightglowpony]

I agree with Diamond Dreams!  And Munchy seems to be quite popular lately!

[minty-fan]

lyra is most sought after G4

[SkyCakes]

I gotta add some babies. Like sandcastle and shovels and baby leaper. Its always the odd colors that people go after. Oops I forgot baby leafy and lucky leaf too. ><:

[ladybrooklyn]

How about the G3 birthfower ponies?


 They are so hard to find!

Gotta agree there! I want my Birthflower (May) so badly! But I can't find her...

As for my most sought after... probably NBBE Baby Heart Throb ATM...

[Dewprincess]

The Tales ponies were a tough set for me to complete...I also dont know when I'll ever get Red Roses or Ice Crystal due to their popularity!  I'll add Baby Cherries Jubilee to this list, too!

[Marlin]

Lol - anything I'm bidding on on ebay! I'm always getting pipped! 

Feels like Cherry Treats is in demand at the mo, especially a nice one. And Blueberry Baskets and TE Bright eyes.

[thatg33kgirl]

How about Rapunzel? Punzie always seems to go for an arm and a leg.

For me personally, a plush Honeycomb. I've seen a total of one sold since I've started collecting (several years ago) and it went for way more than I had spare at that time. Someday!

[clones_rebellion]

At the moment mine is Baby Katie. Seems like just a few years ago she was about $10. Now I can't seem to find one under $40!  

[StarlightGaze]

I really want a G4 Minty. 

[xkelpiex]

Oh, what about Blueberry baskets? Whenever she comes up in a thread people seem to fawn over her.

[invaderhorizongreen]

The Tales ponies. This was the only MLP show I watched when I was a kid and I've always wanted to have the actually toys...

Darn, I want them all but they are expensive and hard to find !

I do have clover but that is the ONLY one i have so far i am still looking for her friends.

[rayedelsol]

Definitely Ice Crystal!!

G4 Blossomforth was hot for awhile, although I am happy to say that I have her now 

G3 Caribbean Delight is a total want for me too! *sigh*

[Ariadna]

Ice Crystal definitely, what a lovely pony, but always out of reach

I find it hard to track down any TAF babies, especially Baby Sugarberry who I want so badly, but I cannot find

[Starly]

Earlier G4s seem to be sought after because many people didn't buy them cause "wah, not show pony why" especcily Blossomforth, and Lily Blossom (for people making her into Pony) and cause they're, well, not made anymore.

[Rosencrantz]

I can no longer remember if I have a Red Roses hidden away somewhere in my house, which makes me so glad I had that newborn custom made of her years ago. She's so pretty, which explains why she's popular.

EDIT: Sweet! Cake in my post!