Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - MJNSEIFER

Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 ... 54
16
Off Topic / Re: Happy Holidays!
« on: December 16, 2023, 03:35:44 PM »
Happy Holidays to everyone here!

17
Off Topic / Re: Let's help motivate each other to reach our goals
« on: December 16, 2023, 11:27:48 AM »
In addition to doing more writing for my projects, my ultimate goal for 2024 is to give my YouTube channel a lot more attention - I only uploaded one episode for my Animation Review Show this year, and that's supposed to be my main show...

Next year, I not only aim to work hard to get more Animation Reviews done, but to basically "be a YouTuber", and upload things more generally, like while I'm working on the things that take longer to finish (like the reviews), I'll do something that can ultimately be done in a day, like a Gaming episode, or a Vlog, and upload that.

I also aim to do some My Little Pony related videos in someway, in addition to obviously reviewing the cartoons.

18
Pony Corral / Re: Hasbro's Most Baffling MLP Decisions
« on: October 29, 2023, 10:19:36 AM »
I think G4 is the one generation where it is hard to claim there are separate canons.

I mean, of course individual fans can have their own ideas, I don't mean that. But I just remember how at the height of G4, whenever you went near a brony space, you would see people insisting that certain things had to be seen a certain way or the person wasn't a fan (or even a human being, apparently).

Toys were expected to have show-accurate hair. 100% that never happened in MLP before.

So G5 is a successor to the canon those bronies drummed into the asphalt. G4 did not promote individual canons and nor did the most vocal elements of the fandom. The fact there are bronies like you, MJSNEIFER, who see things differently, is great - but we're still talking about a fandom, the vast majority of which struggled with the existence of prior generations (even if they did not actively mock them).

I don't have a problem with G5, I just don't care about it. The ponies, toys, show are all bland to me. But by the same token I think G5 needed that blandness, to neutralise the toxicity from the previous iteration.
Agree on those kind of bronies not getting it, but G4 itself was promoted into separate canons, like all generations - the toys, cartoons, comics, books, etc. were all their own canon, which bronies tended to miss (hence them referring to the comics as "non-canon" which is incorrect, they were just their own canon.) There is also stuff that contradicts G4's cartoon canon in G5, so it is likely part of it's own canon (somethingly, at least one thing about G5's canon actually aligns with my G4 headcanon... and it's one of the headcanons that bronies probably wouldn't agree with!)

I know what you mean about those kind of bronies though - I've seen them, and I thought they were silly even back then. They still exist today (and the same applies to those who view anything that isn't "cartoon-canon" as "non-canon") but I at least like to assume that it's getting better. I definitely know that it exists, and never got it, even back then (and I even admit that there are some established "brony headcanons" that I use, but only because I personally like them)

But yeah, what you're talking about is/was definitely a thing. Unfortunately. I think you're right and it connects to the fact that some bronies didn't acknowledge the previous generations, and thus didn't get how MLP worked and the like (and some didn't even get how fanon works, for some reason...) Thank you for being okay with the fact that I view things differently.

I personally don't find the G5 ponies bland, I get so much inspiration from the personally, same as I do with all generations, but I respect that you do. Basically for me, all generations are what bronies view G4 as, if that makes sense, but of course, that's just my own personal opinion.

19
Pony Corral / Re: Hasbro's Most Baffling MLP Decisions
« on: October 26, 2023, 07:54:31 PM »
Quote
instead [G5 is] this grim dystopian future where the Mane Six failed and are all presumably dead.
This is kind of off topic, but I keep seeing this view point, and I just don't relate to it, no offense. This isn't the vibe I get with G5 at all...

What I get from G5 is that the Mane Six were successful, and that friendship is still, and will always be, "magic", because of how easily things were put right - pretty much the worst of it was the A New Generation movie, and even that showed hints that the magic of friendship wasn't gone, it just needed to be rediscovered, and the fact that it still existed to be rediscovered shows that the Mane Six were successful, which is what I personally feel that G5 is trying to say - it's like saying that a marriage is bad just because you argue at times, but that's not how it works; loving someone doesn't mean never fighting with them, it means that you always make up when you do. That's ultimately a simplified version of how I look at G5 following G4, Equestria just had a bad patch, albeit one that lasted (in my headcanon at least) a few centuries, but a bad patch that could be solved, and pretty easily from the look of it (and yes, I get that's because they had to make it MLP as soon as they could.)

Also, as much as I love the Mane Six, I don't get the problem with them being dead in G5, as it's basically centuries in the future - of course they're dead, but they're still alive in their own time, so it's not like G4 ended with them dying (which in itself, also shows that if anypony did fail, it wasn't the Mane Six, as this all happened after their time, most likely.)

And in any case (though this seems to be something that a lot of bronies seem to miss), My Little Pony has multiple canons in each generation anyway, right? So if one wants to, they can view G5 as being a sequel to its "own" G4 rather than "our" G4 (and what "our" G4 is, is different to everyone, at the end of the day, or it should be because that is one of the beauties of My Little Pony) I mean, G5 already feels like it's own generation, with its own rules - it's just saying it's taking place after one of the previous generations as part of its storyline, but as everything else is going its own way, and the idea of how things work has again changed for this generation, it may very well be a sequel to the G5 version of events of what happened to the Mane Six, rather than G4 itself.

But at the end of the day, the overall vibe I get from G5 is that the Mane Six succeeded.  :lovey:

EDIT: And to be fair... G5 may not be that hated by bronies, I mean, those who hate it exist, but I've seen a lot of people (who are at least likely to be bronies) just getting on with it, and enjoying G5 - in some cases, it's probably just the kind of bronies who only like G4 to an excessive degree, and the haters being louder than the fans again (like with the bronies who hated the previous generations Vs. the ones that did.) I dunno, it's probably more balanced than it seems, at least. I also don't think that Hasbro are trying to discourage bronies (or at least G4 fans) either, as G5 seems pretty respectful and nostalgic towards it (and G1 for that matter) while still being its own thing.

And yeah (getting back on topic) I doubt that anything happened to the rights with the G4 ponies, the same as I no longer think anything happened to the rights with the G1 ponies - they just want to focus on the newer ponies (or the ponies they want to focus on.)

20
Pony Corral / Re: Is there a Midnight Castle DVD?
« on: October 22, 2023, 03:27:50 PM »
I'm from the UK (and live there) so I think my VHS is PAL/Region 2 or whatever, so I should be fine. Thanks for the heads up though.  :good:

Somethingly, I actually had to get a region free DVD player in order to play the G1 DVD, as it was American.

21
Pony Corral / Re: Is there a Midnight Castle DVD?
« on: October 21, 2023, 03:24:55 PM »
Thank you to all who answered.

It looks like there isn't a full DVD version (at this point?), which is shame - I love that I have all the episodes together, but it's a shame that my favorite is edited. I'm still pleased to have it, but it does feel incomplete, I have to say (not only is it missing Applejack and Glory's adorable moment, but edit surrounding it is so jarringly sudden, that it's glaringly obvious that the episode was edited - like it jumps so suddenly to the next scene, it just looks wrong in my opinion - though that may be because I know that something's missing.)

I know the "MLP in Dreamland" PAL tape is definitely uncut but not sure if there were any later releases over here.
At least I have the knowledge that this exists, so thanks for this. I know it's VHS (at least that's what it sounds like it is), but it's something - maybe if I see this I'll get it.  :good:

22
Pony Corral / Is there a Midnight Castle DVD?
« on: October 15, 2023, 12:31:38 PM »
Does anyone know if there is a DVD of "Rescue From Midnight Castle" in its entirety? Even if (and especially) if that is the only episode on the DVD?

I have the DVD that shows all episodes of G1, and I love it, but it shows the edited version of RFMC, which is very disappointing to me, as that is my favorite G1 episode, and it looks very butchered as the edited version, in my opinion (they even cut out the most adorable G1 scene ever, in my opinion. ^_^)

So yeah, is there a separate DVD that shows the full version?

23
Pony Corral / Re: Hasbro's Most Baffling MLP Decisions
« on: October 15, 2023, 12:24:41 PM »
At the end of the day, I don't think Hasbro had any disdain towards G1, or any of their previous generations - I know that they released some joke videos about it towards the end of G4, but I think that's all they were - jokes, like you can playfully mock yourself, but that's probably all it was (I will admit I didn't watch them, so I don't know for sure - I only glanced at the Megan one.)

The thing is, Hasbro put a thing online where they asked bronies to be nicer to the pre-"Equestria" ponies, and to give them a chance too - I remember bronies being surprised that Hasbro would stand up for the generations before G4, as they weren't making money from them, which obviously isn't the point, but yeah... Hasbro stood up for G1-G3.5, so ultimately I don't think they have anything against it...

I mean, they even payed homage to G1 in G5 not that long ago (though that may have been the writers, rather than Hasbro) and it was beautiful in my opinion - at the end of the day, I think Hasbro appreciate where they came from, even if some bronies don't.

24
Pony Corral / Re: how are we classifying/labelling the basic fun ponies?
« on: September 08, 2023, 12:08:17 PM »
I personally view them as "new" G1s, and that no generation is every truly "over".

Or at the very least, they're new ponies in G1 style (but I stand by my point about no generation really ending.)

25
Pony Corral / Re: Who is your favourite Celestial pony?
« on: September 02, 2023, 12:54:27 PM »
I like both Aurora and Nova - Aurora has a beautiful color scheme (despite, yes, it being a color scheme that MLP has already done a few times) and her symbol fits the theme of what they appear to be trying to do with toyline.

Nova also has a beautiful color scheme, and it fits the space theme a little more in my opinion - I am mixed on her symbol, because I find lightning symbols cool, but there's kind of a lot going on with it.

I actually feel that a pony with Nova's color scheme and Aurora's symbol (albeit slightly recolored) would have been perfect.

26
Pony Corral / Re: What's the thing you enjoy most doing with your ponies?
« on: September 02, 2023, 12:47:02 PM »
I haven't done this for a while, but I love relaxing on the sofa while hugging one of my pony plushies - especially if I'm watching something MLP related. ^_^

I remember loving watching my G3 DVDs while hugging a G4 Pony of my choice (I only have G4 plushies, but I loved imagining that they enjoy watching the G3 movies too.  :lovey:)

27
Off Topic / Re: What would you collect if money and space was no issue?
« on: August 22, 2023, 10:21:00 AM »

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

Before I mention my next example, I'd like to point out that this looks beautiful, IMO - it looks like it could be from a movie!  :happy:

Any way, here's a weird thing I'd a collect, and yes there's another sort of explanation; Eyeshadow Palettes.

The reason it's weird and requires an explanation is that I have no idea of how to apply make up, and have no interest in doing so, but I am fascinated by the different palettes people create based on themes, and how they come up with names for each shade based on the theme, so I'd kind of like to have an example of each palette out there, so I can just casually look at them physically at any time, and check what the shade names are when I felt like it, because that is the part that interests me, and it's nice to have them physically, I guess, even though they'd be purely display and never actually used... strange I know.

28
Pony Corral / Re: Arena Interview - MJNSEIFER
« on: August 21, 2023, 08:38:20 AM »
Thank you. :good:

29
Pony Corral / Re: Arena Interview - MJNSEIFER
« on: August 20, 2023, 01:47:50 PM »
Thank you for the interview! It's interesting seeing somebody who is a little more focused on the shows here. G3 indeed has a very cute cartoon.
Thank you. I will admit, I have actually been pretty nervous about how I focus on the cartoon more than the toyline - basically because I didn't want to look like I was making the show out to be more important than the toyline.

30
Pony Corral / Re: Arena Interview - MJNSEIFER
« on: August 19, 2023, 07:13:02 AM »
Thanks again for reviewing me.  :good:

Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 ... 54

SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal