Which Version Of Spike Is Your Favorite?

[DazzleKitty]

I didn't even know there was a G3 Spike!

When it comes to ponies, I think original is best. In the case of the shows, it's G4 for me. I really love how they did Spike in FiM. He is cute and funny.

[Buffy]

G3 Spike was in the Movie with Wysteria.
http://img.klebebildchen.net/cover/xl/panini-my-little-pony-2007-princess-promenade.4d0b574d2b4e2.jpg

I really love G4 Spike, as he is really cute. But I like also G1. Don't like the G3 one

[SALTY5621]

ewwwwwwwwww! yep G4 Spike 100%

[Malicieuse]

ewwwwwwwwww! yep G4 Spike 100%

To be honest, that image doesn't represent him all that well.

[Aurora]

In order of liking, G4, G1, G3. I like them all, but g1's voice really does bother me. What they did with him in G3 is interesting, completely different from the other Spikes, so I don't dislike him.

g3 spike was all grown up and really smart, and they found him under a pile of... something in the basement of the castle. I had lots of theories about timelines and history in Ponyland because of that episode (Princess Promenade, right?). He's in a couple more shows after that, but I'd have to actually go and look to see which ones. I know he isn't in A Very Minty Christmas!

[Mysticolt]

In terms of character design, I love G1 Spike!

He was adorable in Rescue at Midnight Castle, I loved his brotherly relationship with Scorpan, though I wasn't as into him from the movie onwards, as he started getting kind of goofy looking.

I remember really wanting Dream Castle when I was a child so I could have Spike, but my mother got me Castle Grayskull instead....

In terms of characterisation, I like how G4 Spike is used in the FIM show, though I don't like his design with the fins on his face, I wish he looked more like G1 Spike.

[StarDapple]

I like G1 Spike the best.  I love his gravelly voice, even though at times he sounds almost exactly like Buster Bunny (they are both voiced by Charlie Adler), which can be a bit jarring.

[RAMChYLD]

which movie was G3 Spike in?

I think there's an appearance in The Runaway Rainbow? At least, there was a Spike the Dragon in the game- although unlike G1 and G4 Spike, G3 Spike is technically an adult dragon.

[Majesty]

Oh yeaaah! I forgot there was a G3 Spike. I didn't like him at all. He was only in one movie wasn't he?
I'd have to say G4 Spike, but -only- cause the G1 voice for him drives me insane. xD

G3's were only movies and he was in most of them.  He wasn't in A Very Minty Christmas.  He was in Runaway Rainbow and I think he was in Princess Promenade.  I'm not sure about the others

[Brightglowpony]

I'd have to go with g1 Spike   I always liked him in the Midnight Castle pilot. 

[Dragonflitter]

ewwwwwwwwww! yep G4 Spike 100%

To be honest, that image doesn't represent him all that well.

Yeah that pic doesn't look like him at all. G3 Spike is fricken adorable. I love when they give him a bath and he gets covered in bubbles! X3

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

[josiekat]

I had forgotten all about G3 Spike.

Honestly, I like G1 Toy Spike the best, but I think I like G4 cartoon Spike the best.

[Tirac]

G1 Spike. I think he's the cutest.
BUT HIS VOICE. GAAHHHHH. ;A; It's so nasally and annoying.

[RedKitsune]

While G1 Spike will always be special to me, my absolute favorite is G4 Spike. I love his voice and personality. I also knew nothing of the existence of G3 Spike until this thread, so I reserve judgement on that one, LOL

[HavACrumpet452]

G1 design-to me its more dragon-like and slightly less anthropomorphic

G4 animation- because lets face it, G1 animators were smoking something, sometimes he'd be tall and skinny, other scenes he'd be short and chubby. I don't like the whole huge head on tiny body fad though.