But I thought ___ was ___ color!

[Eldarwen]

I have no clue.  I did read somewhere that her symbols have a blue tinge to them. But seriously, I have never seen a white Windy myself. And as far as I know, some people still believe its just a faded Windy. Like Italy Firefly, she can fade to brilliant white too. Guess we'll never know.. Here's a thread about it too: http://www.mlptp.net/forums/mlp-discussion/62075-white-windy-vs-faded-windy.html

[Sunset]

I always considered Medley to be blue and it always surprises me how many people consider her green.

[rybett]

When I got a faded Sprinkles, I assumed she was a off white and tried to sunfade her.  Opps, she's light purple.

[Eldarwen]

I always considered Medley to be blue and it always surprises me how many people consider her green.

She's turquoise! 

[NoPonySpecial]

I know that (more current version/version used in gen 3.5) Toola Roola is pink, but for some reason I always picture her as a sandy color. I have no idea why! Then I try to imagine her as pink and my brain just insists on keeping her that sandy color. It's very weird!

[Starshinescustoms]

I've had that with quite a few ponies, but generally it was the fading pink hair ponies that got me. My Wind Whister and Up, Up and Away both have white hair, so that's what I thought it was meant to be. Even though I'd been watching the cartoon for years and Wind Whistler clearly had pink hair  I actually thought there were two versions, and pink and a white haired version of her.

[DancingPhoenix]

Haha the white flower Posey tricked me too! Pink fades so much, hair or symbol. I kind of like Bowtie with white bows though.

And Mimic has been weird to me. I see her as green and I see her as yellow. Her toy is more yellowish, but in the cartoon and box art she is very green.

visitors can't see pics , please register or login
 

I'm the same way with Surprise though, her hair is green, not yellow. It's a neon mix of green and yellow but it's not like, sunshine yellow

Color like that depends on how you view it though, but a white Mimic would be cool!

[Sabrina]

Definitely! A white Mimic would be awesome!

[Tap Dancer]

I always considered Medley to be blue and it always surprises me how many people consider her green.

She's always been green to me!

visitors can't see pics , please register or login
 

[hathorcat]

Pillow Talk is grey...and I refuse to listen to people trying to convince me she is purple

[kittybethy]

I always assumed that 4 Speed/Trucker was gray!

 I was surprised that he was supposed to be blue (I have yet to see a really blue one).

[Sabrina]

Pillow Talk is grey...and I refuse to listen to people trying to convince me she is purple

Seriously, she's purple?! I've honestly thought she was grey this whole time! Lol! I can't believe I didn't realise she was supposed to be purple.

[Sunset]

I always considered Medley to be blue and it always surprises me how many people consider her green.

She's always been green to me!

visitors can't see pics , please register or login
 

Still doesn't look green to me.  I agree with someone else who said she is turquoise or teal.  True she isn't the same blue as Firefly's mane/tail but she is also, imo, clearly not the green of the grass/trees below her.  The grass color is the color I think of when you say green.

[ChipsteRJ]

Here is Wash/Wipeaway Windy.... the purple just falls right off, you can't clean her- she's my collection pride:
visitors can't see pics , please register or login

[Tap Dancer]

Still doesn't look green to me.  I agree with someone else who said she is turquoise or teal.  True she isn't the same blue as Firefly's mane/tail but she is also, imo, clearly not the green of the grass/trees below her.  The grass color is the color I think of when you say green.

There are many shades of green.