In the garbage, on the ground, in the woods...

[Enolaalone]

I was at a flea market and there was this guy selling used paint, tools, and whatever else you can find in a garage. He had a small trailer FULL of all this rusty, oily junk. In the middle of all of that, I saw a Peachy. I went up to him and was like "I want the pink pony!!" He gave me a strange look. He didn't even realize it was in there. She was full of grease...

Aww poor Peachy! I love Peachy. Did you successfully rescue her?

[Mermaid]

When I was younger I found a Speedy in a church at a wedding. She was in the play room. I begged my mom for her and she let me take it, but left a note with $20.00 in it. <3 Love my mom. But sometimes I wonder if any kid was sad that the pony was gone...

[Tilas]

...This guy was a complete punk, right down to the huge green shaved mohawk and shock value clothes. Well he stopped on the spot holding up this sofa and started demanding that someone "Get the pony! Get the pony!" I can only imagine the image for the employees.

OKay, that would have been pretty funny to see. Course, when my brother found the pony he brought home for me he's all goth with piercings galore, long hair, and all the black clothes n stuff so that would have been funny too.