What if....

[CottonTALE]

What if you were in charge of making another Favourites Collection? who would you put in it?

the first Favourites Collection contained the following with glitter symbols:
-Nightmare Moon
-Pinkie Pie
-Rainbow Dash
-Trixie Lulamoon
-DJ-Pon3
-Lemony Gem
-Flower Wishes

for me, I would follow with the tradition of glitter symbolds, an Alicorn, 2 Main character, 2 Secondary characters and 2 new characters:

-Alicorn Twilight Sparkle
-Applejack
-Fluttershy
-Lyra Heartstrings
-Spitfire
-Golden Harvest
-Tea Love

What ones would you pick?

[Tirac]

Hmmmmmm...

King Sombra
Lightning Dust
Lyra
Applejack
Orion/whatever (I happen to love both the unicorn with the constellation cutie mark and the pegasus with the same cutie mark)
Colgate
Luna

Doesn't fit with how the actual favorites collection was, but alright.

[reanna-mator]

Mm, just to be interesting I'll follow your format.

Chrysalis
Fluttershy
Rarity (she's not a background pony yet!)
Colgate
Golden Harvest
Kiwi Tart
Firecracker Burst

[CottonTALE]

Mm, just to be interesting I'll follow your format.

Chrysalis
Fluttershy
Rarity (she's not a background pony yet!)
Colgate
Golden Harvest
Kiwi Tart
Firecracker Burst

Ooo, I forgot about Chrysalis... that would make an awesome toy using the Alicorn mold!

[lovesbabysquirmy]

I would stop production entirely and go with a new design.  :-p 

[reanna-mator]

Mm, just to be interesting I'll follow your format.

Chrysalis
Fluttershy
Rarity (she's not a background pony yet!)
Colgate
Golden Harvest
Kiwi Tart
Firecracker Burst

Ooo, I forgot about Chrysalis... that would make an awesome toy using the Alicorn mold!

I'm sure they'd forego the cool holey limbs, though, as it might be a little complicated. Watch people drill holes in theirs! But she would definitely have gauzy wings like Breezies. Ooh man, now I really want a Chrysalis toy!

[Glitzy Gems]

Oooh!

Queen Chrystalis
Applejack
Fluttershy
Fancypants (shoe-horn in my favorite supporting character? DUH)
Octavia
Fizzypop
Cherry Spices
Stardash

[Eily311]

Queen chrysalis
Fluttershy
Applejack
Drama Pony
Celestia
Big Macintosh
Granny smith
Minty

[josiekat]

I would completely break your mold. For me a favorites set would include G4's versions of:

G1 Snuzzle
G2 Copper Glow
G3 Autumn Skye
G4 Twilight Velvet, Tea Love, 70's Mustache Tennis Boy pony
Then I would have Rainbow Dash without wings....the way Discord changed her, and Rarity with her correct fake wings from that episode...but they wouldn't be too huge...and made out of the material that G1 winger wings are made out of.
And.....The Buffalo


In short.....no one would buy my set but me. Which is why I don't design sets. lol

[Tropical_Sunset]

Ooh, good topic!  Let's see...

-Queen Chrysalis
-Bonbon/Sweetie Drops
-Big Mac
-Apple Fritter
-Rainbowshine
-Lotus Blossom
-Lotus Blossom's twin sister

I think the spa twins would make FANTASTIC brushables.  So sad they didn't package them with the crystal spa thingy. :/

[achab1984]

I wish they would make some differnt molds for the G4 ponies! But I know they have to save money somewere

[MaronaPossessed]

-Big Macintosh
-DramaPony
-Discord
-Lyra Heartstrings
-Lily Blossom
-Queen Chrysalis
-Minty

[BrightIdea]

Chrysalis
Fleur de Lis
Spitfire
Lightning Dust
Cloud Chaser
Apple Fritter
Pipsqueak

I can't think of other favourites. I think my mind is broken.

[KarentheUnicorn]

Hmmmmmm...

King Sombra
Lightning Dust
Lyra
Applejack
Orion/whatever (I happen to love both the unicorn with the constellation cutie mark and the pegasus with the same cutie mark)
Colgate
Luna

Doesn't fit with how the actual favorites collection was, but alright.

We need a favorite bad guy collection. Then we could have a, discord, king sombra, swish cheese legs queen, etc. etc.

[Evening_Moonstone]

Queen Chrysalis as the big alicorn

Minty
Bon Bon
Changeling minion pony
Big Mac
Octavia
Minuette "Colgate"

Alternately, I think there should be a "classroom favorites set" that comes with:
Apple Bloom
Twist
Diamond Tiara
Silver Spoon
Snips
Snails
and Cheerilee!