Which Minty?

[Evening_Moonstone]

Just out of curiosity, which version of Minty is your favorite?

• G1 Minty - green body, white hair, shamrocks
• G3 Minty - green body, fading pink hair, peppermints
• G4 Minty - green body, pink and white hair, peppermints

I personally wasn't a fan of the G1 version, but I think the G4 version is super cute, and I love the winter-accessory version of G3 Minty as well. I never watched the G3 cartoons, I just like the colors and symbol on G3/G4 Minty.  Green ponies are a very unique breed.

[ApertureScience]

Toy-wise:  G4 (I don't know why, but I prefer the G4 pony molds over the G3 ones)
Color-wise:  G1 (Light green coat and white hair?  Simple and cute.)
Personality-wise:  G3 (Such a cute little klutz...)

I'm all over the place. 

[Dragonflitter]

I love her G3 winter version with the TAF symbols. <3

[sweetstuff]

As much as I love G1s - I never thought shamrocks made much sense for Minty. I think G3/G4 symbols make more sense.

So I guess I'll have to go with G3/G4  - since they are pretty much the same.

[StarDragon]

As a toy, G4 Minty looks awesome the way she is, but my favorite color combo is the G1.

[xkelpiex]

Diva pose g3! One of my most wanted G3's. I also love the G4 version, but was never a fan of the G1 Minty. I abhor the collectors pose.

[Evening_Moonstone]

I abhor the collectors pose.

Ever since my husband referred to it as the "pooping pose", I haven't been a fan either! 

[aellos]

Actually- G4.
I love the color combos.

[PinkRosedust]

I agree that G1 Minty doesn't really make sense...but I still love her best! For some reason in the last year, I suddenly fell in love with the CP even though I used to not really care for it. But gosh it's so sweet looking!

I do like G3/G4 Minty too (any green pony is a good pony!) but I honestly don't understand why she seems to be everyone's favorite pony ever. Was it because of her personality in the cartoons? Or because she's green..?

[SwordPony]

I'm gonna go with G4 Minty.

[Koudoawaia]

My favorite version is G3 Minty.^^

[mlp4me]

G1, unique colors, and a very classic pony..

[reyl]

G3 Donkey Pose Minty! And I like her better with her hair faded white

[TheBeatlesPkmnFan42]

This is difficult. I'm gonna say G3 because she's a donkey pose. Plus, I don't have the G1 or G4 Mintys.

[SkyCakes]

I totally love the G1 minty. Not that I like the other newer versions of her. Though the old one is so cute because I never had her as a child. Which made her all the more special once I got her.