Obviously there are some ponies that I want more than others, but my collection is still relatively small. I'd be happy with any pony (in decent condition) if I don't already have it. So I really think it would be easier to just list what I have, and if you have one that I don't, I probably want it lol
G1
Sparkler
Moondancer
Butterscotch
Bonnie Bonnets
MLP Friends, Zig Zag
Baby Lucky
Baby Lickety Split
Glory
Moonstone
Firefly
Peachy
Applejack
Sunglory
So Soft Magic Wand
So Soft Sundance
Minty
Twilight
Pony Bride
Beddy-Bye Eye Baby Hearthrob
G2
Ivy
G3
Baby Pinkie Pie
Baby Cheerilee
Fluttershy
Kimono
Royal Rose
Tropical Delight
Midnight Dream
Sunny Daze
Rainbow Dash
BumbleSweet
3D symbol Pinkie Pie
Round n' Round
Periwinkle
Styling Size Rarity
Styling Size Starcatcher
Paradise Island
3D symbol Rarity
Pineapple Paradise
3D symbol Royal Bouquet
Amberlocks
G3.5
Starsong
Scootaloo (glittery with her name on her side)
Scootaloo
Rainbow Dash
Styling Size Pinkie Pie
G4
Cutie Mark Magic, Sweetie Drops
Water Cuties, Diamond Mint
Wysteria
Rainbow Dash
Sunset Shimmer
Cutie Mark Magic, Skywishes
Nurse Redheart
Feathermay
Fluttershy
Styling Strands, Fluttershy
Trixie Lulamoon
Rarity
Rainbow Power Rarity
Fluttershy
Pinkie Pie
Charm Wings, Honey Rays
Princess Luna
pre-alicorn Twilight Sparkle
Princess Gold Lilly
Sorry for the length ;-; Like I said, if you have a pony that isn't on this list, it's on my wishlist!