Help Me Decide Who to keep MIB

[kittybethy]

I voted Trixie.

[egyptiondragon]

trixie because i would get the tru set and open that 1 with trixie and lyra doesn't have bon bon so why should she be trapped too

[Ren-Ren]

If you're leaving one MIB I assume it is for potential future value. Lyra is the more popular pony (see below) and is currently more scarce (since Trixie is in the TRU set) so she's the one more likely to be worth something in a few decades ^_-

Whenever I have Lyra available on my sales page she disappears immediately, while I've never run out of Trixie, though she is more popular than Sunny Rays or Cherry Berry.

[StarDragon]

If you're leaving one MIB I assume it is for potential future value. Lyra is the more popular pony (see below) and is currently more scarce (since Trixie is in the TRU set) so she's the one more likely to be worth something in a few decades ^_-

Whenever I have Lyra available on my sales page she disappears immediately, while I've never run out of Trixie, though she is more popular than Sunny Rays or Cherry Berry.

This is exactly what I was thinking.

[gabumon]

Thanks everyone for your input!

My motive for keeping MIB isnt really about value, it is mostly to protect them and keep them in nice conditon.  (as I've ranted before) I am a fan of the packaging (save the DVD-obscurra fiasco) so I like how thy look in there, they display nicely MIB, IMO. Luckily they are squarish and stand upright ok. (cursed Hot Wheels don't stand up MIB!).

I like the reasoning that Lyra is less common so keep her MIB.  And Trixie needs to don a hat and cape! Even if they are made of construction paper!!