Which to keep?

[Carrehz]

Both!! ..But purple-eye if I had to make a decision. I like the contrast

[bluerose9978]

Purple eyed because she's harder to find. Blue eyed is more common.

[Nappercasper]

Thanks for all the comments, blue eyed needs a clean

[Jinxxy]

I like the purple eyes best. I usually keep whatever one is whiter with white ponies though.

[slyons]

I'm jumping on the purple eyed band wagon! She looks nicer condition to me...

[Baby Sugarberry]

As has been mentioned, they're two different releases - the gap-haired one came with the Dream Castle and is far more common, while the purple-eyed Majesty is Mail Order and rarer.  If you have to pick just one, I'd keep the MO, since she'd be harder to find again.

[Ponyfan]

I agree with the MO one. I think she is prettier since her mane goes farther.


Ponyfan

[princessluna11706]

I know it's probably no help but in my case when I found I had the two I kept both :p  But yea, purple if I had to sell one.

[Leave a Whisper]

Both, but if only one, then the purple eyed one.

[ChipsteRJ]

The Blue eye....

The castle one with the gap in her hair line. She is so difficult to find with a matching head/ body. The Mail order one is the easiest to replace later on. So common for the DC one to discolor.

Honestly I like them both, so I would keep them both. They are not the same version!