You can only save 5 of your G1's from being eaten by an undead zombie pony...

[DaffyDilly]

I am going to sacrifice myself! Then the zombie will go away and the ponies will be safe. 

Erm..
Buttons, Beachball, Childhood Wind Whistler, argh!

I can't go any further with this. All of my G1s are looking at me and begging me to take them 

[Whippycorn]

Set my attack dogs on the zombie! 

I would have to save my darling babies Noddins and Buttons.

Logic tells me to save my Indian Minty and Snuzzle,  and maybe Lightning or Sunburst...

I hope I am never really faced with this choice 

[aellos]

GOOD THING I ONLY HAVE FIVE!

[Bebopgroove]

Ooooo.. let's see..
I would grab Minty (), Moondancer, Glory, childhood Firefly, and Twilight.

[michelle53]

Holy cannibal pony!  Yikes:(. Well I have to think about this one.

Starry Wings
Argie Sunglider
Lady Flutter
Cool Breeze
Argie Cool Breeze

[hathorcat]

I am going to sacrifice myself! Then the zombie will go away and the ponies will be safe. 

Erm..
Buttons, Beachball, Childhood Wind Whistler, argh!

I can't go any further with this. All of my G1s are looking at me and begging me to take them 

*giggle* you are soooo much nicer than me! I decided to save myself rather than the ponies!

[Moondancer115]

It would be lemondrops from my army 

Piggy
Greek
Macau 2x
Airbrushed italy

Oh no I want to save more!!!

[Iceglider]

Childhood Nightglider (favorite)
IceCrystal
Childhood Baby Sweetstuff (first pony ever)

If animals counted I'd save my lil' litters babies, but you said ponies so...

Childhood Daddy Apple Delight
My smoozie Thundercloud who I would sell to buy back common ponies I lost, Posey, Glittering Gem, Baby Apple Delight and SunGlider or if I had tons of money to rebuild I would grab Childhood Glittering Gem

[lolaandbean]

1. Childhood Blossom
2. Childhood Applejack
3. Baby Blossom
4. Bubbles
5. Firefly

[Sarah-Bee]

I see your pony-eating zombie and raise you a Simon Pegg - he will save my ponies

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

[Bebopgroove]

I see your pony-eating zombie and raise you a Simon Pegg - he will save my ponies

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

[Ginger]

Cool Breeze
Flurry
Moon Jumper
Whirly
High Flyer

[majikarte]

I'm one of the people who has less than five... but if you asked me to pick only one of my two, I don't think I could choose.

[Dee_Kary]

NOOOO my newborns!! but if I have to...

1.- Nov. Chrysanthemum (my babies need a mommy!)
2.- Rattles
3.- Tattles
4.- Squirmy
5.- Dangles

 

[MoongazerThePony]

Blossom, Chief, Tiddlywinks, Medly, Sunbeam

I'd probably have started throwing art supplies at the zombies before they got near my shelf xD