Your creepy pony, or creepy pony stories O_0*

[Tiffoes]

I want to read the haunted fizzy story too!

[MoongazerThePony]

I think BBEs are adorable ono

[Katika]

Ok, sorry guys.  I've been looking for the Fizzy post and can't find it    I really wish I could remember more about it...

[Tiffoes]

Ok, sorry guys.  I've been looking for the Fizzy post and can't find it    I really wish I could remember more about it...

Aww that's a shame! Thanks for trying though!

[Flutterblossom]

I used to be afraid of g1 ponies when I was little! I was afraid of old toys in general, but the ponies really freaked me out. I got over my fear of them eventually when I was older and started collecting them.

I have a g1 birth flower pony with saddle sores all over it... Man it creeps me out... That pose!!! I couldn't sleep with that thing staring at me... I think I threw it in my closet one night...

And btw I would love to read the fizzy story!

[SkyCakes]

thats interesting.. I like to hear about the haunted fizzy too. I heard one person told me a pony winked at her.. o.O I used to have my pony room and I would say goodnight to them alot. I always felt they maybe said it back. I have never had any creepy ponies but I still wonder how like so much fascination to one pony like it calls out to you to buy it.

[hyenacub]

I do not have creepy ponies.  But plenty of other creepy toys.  I collect them!

[Like A Tea Spoon]

  I had a big Alf the alien doll. My sister cut his hair and tossed him into the bottom dresser drawer because she was too scared to toss him in the closet.

[hyenacub]

Alf rules!!

[majikarte]

I can't really remember this too well, but I remember an image someone posted on here of a G1 baby that was... well, I don't really think "well loved" is the right term. It had a lot of marker on it, and the eyes were blacked out maybe? I don't know if anyone knows what I'm talking about or maybe has the picture. The person who owned it ended up giving it to someone in the thread the actually wanted it.

[FlitterRose]

I have a creepy fakie that count?
visitors can't see pics , please register or login

I think she wishes to devour my soul...

That scared my angels!!! 

But I would liek to hear about haunted Fizzy too  Too bad Katika couldn't find it but thanks for trying anyway  haunted Fizzy...LOL!

[Evening_Moonstone]

I love "creepypasta" stories (internet urban legends that are like ghost stories).  A lot of them are about "lost episodes" of well-known shows, or prototypes of video games, and they're always scary and eerie.
Someone should write a pony one!

I would love to hear the haunted Fizzy story as well. ^^

[Like A Tea Spoon]

Slenderman creeps the heck out of me. 

[starrypawz]

I love "creepypasta" stories (internet urban legends that are like ghost stories).  A lot of them are about "lost episodes" of well-known shows, or prototypes of video games, and they're always scary and eerie.
Someone should write a pony one!

I would love to hear the haunted Fizzy story as well. ^^

If anyone wants to they can make a 'creepypasta' about my creepy fakie.