I'm not trying to put a damper on this thread but my house actually DID catch on fire in May of this year and burn down. My curio cabinet full of ponies in the bedroom was the last thing on my mind as we ran out. Thankfully everyone is fine including the pets but I chuckled when I saw this thread because I can say that honestly in the moment NONE of the ponies will matter!!! But after the fire was out they mattered a ton and I was super sad to have lost a portion of my collection.
But to play along, the pony I would rescue is my childhood Applejack. She was in the curio cabinet in my bedroom. Thankfully the cabinet survived the fire and it was amazing to be able to go back in the house afterwards and empty the cabinet. She is hanging out on the desk in our rental house with me right now. I can't wait until our house is rebuilt and I can move the ponies back into their room again!!!