Hello fellow MLP lovers! After being away for a bit, I'm back to continue selling my collection. *sobsobsob*

About half of them were my beloved childhood toys, and the rest I purchased from eBay in the late '90s/early '00s. Most are in pretty good toy condition, some are in really super awesome condition, and a few could do with a deflocking or a new tail. I’ve taken two pictures of each of them so you can get a good idea of the condition of the pony and whether she would be right for your collection. If there were any big flaws other than play wear, I tried to get that in the photo. (Thanks, Mom, for writing names on some of their necks. Didn’t you know I could remember them ALL?)

I am in the US, but I will ship internationally. Let me know your zip code or country and I’ll give you a shipping estimate.

Some ponies have an asking price, but I’m open to offers. If you have any questions or want to see more pictures of a specific pony, please let me know. I will do my best to get back to you as soon as possible.

Let me know if you’re interested or have any questions!

View photos here: http://jillin.it/mlp (I try to remove pictures of ponies as they sell. If you see a picture of a pony that isn't on the list below, it's probably gone already.)

CUSTOM PONIES

The Last Unicorn $50 or best offer
Snow Queen $50 or best offer

YEAR 1

Little Ponies (flat feet)
Blossom (not the best shape, see photos)

YEAR 2

Earth Ponies
Cotton Candy
Blossom
Applejack $15
Bow Tie
Bubbles $20
Seashell $20

Unicorns & Pegasi
Moondancer
Glory
Twilight
Sunbeam
Firefly
Medley

Rainbow Ponies
Moonstone 1
Moonstone 2
Windy
Starshine
Skydancer
Parasol

Sea Ponies
Seawinkle

Ponies & Pets
Peachy
Twinkles the Cat
Lemon Drop
Sprinkles
Majesty

YEAR 3

Earth Ponies
Lickety-Split
Posey
Cherries Jubilee (cut tail)

Unicorns & Pegasi
Sparkler $30
Gusty
Powder $10
Skyflier $15
Surprise

Rainbow Ponies
Pinwheel $20

Baby Ponies
Baby Blossom
Baby Moondancer
Baby Firefly

Other
Sundance

YEAR 4

So Soft Ponies
North Star $8
Lofty $5
Wind Whistler $8
Buttons $10
Shady $5
Truly $15
Magic Star $15
Bouncy $8

Twinkle-Eyed Ponies
Fizzy $20
Galaxy $20
Masquerade $20
Whizzer $20
Sweet Pop $20

Baby Ponies w/BBE
Baby Heart Throb
Baby Lickety-Split

Other
Best Wishes 1 (SS) (bait or deflock) $2
Party Time (TE)
Baby Sundance (BBE)
Baby Cuddles (BBE)
Baby Sleepy Pie (BBE)

YEAR 5

Twinkle-Eyed Ponies
Bright Eyes $40
Tic-Tac-Toe $30
Locket $15
Quackers $25

Twice As Fancy Ponies
Up, Up, and Away $10

Princess Ponies
Princess Tiffany (w/purple hat)
Princess Primrose
Chumster (yellow Bushwoolie)
Pink hat & aqua wand

Flutter Ponies

Big Brother Ponies
Tex (w/hat & bandana) $50

Baby Ponies w/First Tooth
Baby North Star

Newborn Twins
Milkweed & Tumbleweed
Doodles & Noodles
Rattles & Tattles

Other
Fifi (TAF)

YEAR 6

Twice As Fancy Ponies
Buttons $70

Happy Tails Ponies
Romper
Squeezer

Magic Message Ponies
Cuddles
Floater
Magic Hat

Summer Wing Ponies
Buzzer (w/wings) $20

YEAR 7

Princess Brush ‘n Grow Ponies
Brilliant Bloom

Loving Family Ponies
Mommy Sweet Celebrations
Daddy Sweet Celebrations
Baby Sweet Celebrations (boy)

Sparkle Ponies (no symbol on cheek)
Twinkler $15
Star Hopper (yellow hair) $15

YEAR 8

Baby Drink ‘n Wet Ponies
Baby Rainfeather
Baby Flicker
Baby Cuddles (w/ 2 diapers)

Baby Sparkle Ponies (U.S.)
Baby North Star (white mane (faded?), pink tail)
Baby Gusty

Other
Pony Bride 1
Pony Bride 2

SPECIAL OFFERS

Ember
baby blue $8
purple $8

Collector Ponies (concave hooves)
Snuzzle
Blue Belle

Wedding Ponies
Lucky, the Stallion

Sparkle Ponies (symbol on cheek)
Sunspot $25

Baby Pearlized Ponies
Baby Blossom $40

INTERNATIONAL PONIES

Non-So Soft Ponies
Magic Star $10
North Star $25

Non BBE/Non First Tooth Baby Ponies
Baby Lickety-Split $50

Early Ponies
Honeycomb $25

Baby Ponies
Baby Bow Tie $40
Baby Hopscotch $45

View photos here: http://jillin.it/mlp

Hello fellow MLP lovers! After being away for a bit, I'm back to continue selling my collection. *sobsobsob*

About half of them were my beloved childhood toys, and the rest I purchased from eBay in the late '90s/early '00s. Most are in pretty good toy condition, some are in really super awesome condition, and a few could do with a deflocking or a new tail. I’ve taken two pictures of each of them so you can get a good idea of the condition of the pony and whether she would be right for your collection. If there were any big flaws other than play wear, I tried to get that in the photo. (Thanks, Mom, for writing names on some of their necks. Didn’t you know I could remember them ALL?)

I am in the US, but I will ship internationally. Let me know your zip code or country and I’ll give you a shipping estimate.

Some ponies have an asking price, but I’m open to offers. If you have any questions or want to see more pictures of a specific pony, please let me know. I will do my best to get back to you as soon as possible, but it might take a day. Same with shipping, but I will keep you updated!

Okay, I think that’s all. Let me know if you’re interested or have any questions!

View photos here: http://jilleh.com/mlp

You can also view my original post here. I think it was too old to be able to bump, so I made a new one. I also removed everything I sold the first time around to make it easier to read.

CUSTOM PONIES

The Last Unicorn $50 or best offer
Snow Queen $50 or best offer

YEAR 1

Little Ponies (flat feet)
Blossom (not the best shape, see photos)

YEAR 2

Earth Ponies
Cotton Candy
Blossom
Applejack $15
Bow Tie 1
Bow Tie 2
Bubbles $20
Seashell $20

Unicorns & Pegasi
Moondancer
Glory
Twilight
Sunbeam
Firefly
Medley

Rainbow Ponies
Moonstone 1
Moonstone 2
Windy
Starshine
Skydancer
Parasol

Sea Ponies
Seawinkle

Ponies & Pets
Peachy
Twinkles the Cat
Lemon Drop
Sprinkles
Majesty

YEAR 3

Earth Ponies
Lickety-Split
Posey
Cherries Jubilee (cut tail)

Unicorns & Pegasi
Sparkler $30
Gusty
Powder $10
Skyflier $15
Surprise

Rainbow Ponies
Pinwheel $20

Baby Ponies
Baby Blossom
Baby Moondancer
Baby Firefly

Other
Sundance

YEAR 4

So Soft Ponies
North Star $8
Lofty $5
Wind Whistler $8
Buttons $10
Shady $5
Truly $15
Magic Star $15
Bouncy $8

Twinkle-Eyed Ponies
Fizzy $20
Galaxy $20
Masquerade $20
Whizzer $20
Sweet Pop $20

Baby Ponies w/BBE
Baby Heart Throb
Baby Lickety-Split

Other
Best Wishes 1 (SS) (bait or deflock) $2
Party Time (TE)
Baby Sundance (BBE)
Baby Cuddles (BBE)
Baby Sleepy Pie (BBE)

YEAR 5

So Soft Ponies
Twilight $40

Twinkle-Eyed Ponies
Bright Eyes $40
Tic-Tac-Toe $30
Locket $15
Quackers $25

Twice As Fancy Ponies
Up, Up, and Away $10

Princess Ponies
Princess Tiffany (w/purple hat)
Princess Serena (w/aqua hat & purple wand)
Princess Primrose
Chumster (yellow Bushwoolie)
Princess Sparkle (w/pink hat & aqua wand)

Flutter Ponies

Big Brother Ponies
Tex (w/hat & bandana) $50
Salty $12

Baby Ponies w/First Tooth
Baby North Star
Baby Quackers

Newborn Twins
Milkweed & Tumbleweed
Doodles & Noodles
Rattles & Tattles

Other
Fifi (TAF)

YEAR 6

Twice As Fancy Ponies
Buttons $70

Princess Ponies
Princess Dawn

Happy Tails Ponies
Romper
Squeezer

Magic Message Ponies
Cuddles
Floater
Magic Hat

Summer Wing Ponies
Buzzer (w/wings) $20

YEAR 7

Princess Brush ‘n Grow Ponies
Brilliant Bloom

Loving Family Ponies
Mommy Sweet Celebrations
Daddy Sweet Celebrations
Baby Sweet Celebrations (boy)

Sparkle Ponies (no symbol on cheek)
Twinkler $15
Star Hopper (yellow hair) $15

YEAR 8

Rainbow Curl Ponies
Raincurl $15

Baby Drink ‘n Wet Ponies
Baby Rainfeather
Baby Flicker
Baby Cuddles (changing table & 2 diapers)

Baby Sparkle Ponies (U.S.)
Baby North Star (white mane (faded?), pink tail)
Baby Gusty

Other
Pony Bride 1
Pony Bride 2

SPECIAL OFFERS

Ember
baby blue $8
purple $8

Collector Ponies (concave hooves)
Snuzzle
Blue Belle

Wedding Ponies
Lucky, the Stallion

Sparkle Ponies (symbol on cheek)
Sunspot $25

Baby Pearlized Ponies
Baby Cotton Candy $40
Baby Blossom $40

INTERNATIONAL PONIES

Non-So Soft Ponies
Shady $10
Magic Star $10
North Star $25

Non BBE/Non First Tooth Baby Ponies
Baby Lickety-Split $50

Early Ponies
Snowflake
Honeycomb $25

Baby Ponies
Baby Bow Tie $40
Baby Hopscotch $45
Baby Honeycomb $45


View photos here: http://jilleh.com/mlp

Hello, everyone. My name is Jill. I'm 33 and have loved MLPs since I was a child.

I had quite a bit of pony toys growing up. When I was in my late teens and early 20s, I discovered eBay and doubled my collection. (This was a time before PayPal so there were a lot of checks and money orders, lol). I focused on G1s. The rare ones, the ones I'd never gotten as a child, and some *gasp* International ponies! I was floored when I found out they existed.

When I moved into my own house, I displayed them in a hutch, but space started to get cramped and they ended up in storage totes.

I really do love them. They bring back fond childhood memories, and I remember the excitement I felt when I got each one. With that being said, I don't foresee myself having them on display again. I've wavered on what to do with them for a few years now, and I think it's finally time I give them new homes. 



It makes me really sad because I'm a sentimental person and I have a habit of projecting human emotion on inanimate objects (thanks mom and dad), but they'd be better off enjoyed by someone else than stuck in a tote in the back of my closet for all eternity.

So that's why I'm here. Nice to meet you all!