Who do you prefer? Applejack edition

[Sparkle Pony]

G3 rocks the colors as usual, so I can't resist her.

[SpacePinto]

I'm so glad that the Silly Pony won.

[Sakuyamon]

Sad to say but I actually prefer G4 AJ. Both appearance wise and personality wise. I am not really into her G1 toy but the cartoon version is adorable.

Although... I might like G5 concept AJ (the one with white hoves and nose blaze) best of all, but I guess she dont  count since she isnt official.

[pinkkittywinks]

It has got to be G1 as she was one of my childhood ponies

Love pkw xxx

[Leave a Whisper]

Sad to say but I actually prefer G4 AJ. Both appearance wise and personality wise. I am not really into her G1 toy but the cartoon version is adorable.

Although... I might like G5 concept AJ (the one with white hoves and nose blaze) best of all, but I guess she dont  count since she isnt official.

I wonder if Mishmash AJ will show up cheap on ebay? People could always customize her to look like the possible concept art.

[tailrustedtealeaf]

Good point, once G5 comes out I'd probably vote for her.

I wonder if Mishmash AJ will show up cheap on ebay? People could always customize her to look like the possible concept art.

@ Fakie producers, get on it!

[Leave a Whisper]

Good point, once G5 comes out I'd probably vote for her.

I wonder if Mishmash AJ will show up cheap on ebay? People could always customize her to look like the possible concept art.

@ Fakie producers, get on it!

Fakie Producers? Oh. No I mean the Retro Mane 6 pack Applejack.

[NightGliderSA]

Well gosh that was an easy decision  Have always loved G1 Applejack since I was a kid: she was one of my first ponies and is very special to me

[mlp4me]

I really like G1 AJ, especially her long haired version.

[kingluke]

Not sure if I posted here before, maybe something went wrong? idk.
Anyway I can't decide between g1 applejack and g4 applejack. I generally prefer g1 but I've been with g4 applejack so long you know.
I like the g1 toy better but the g4 character is more appealing to me.

[brightberry]

G1! I think she's adorable.

I like G3's colors quite a bit. 

[Goanna]

Not sure if I posted here before, maybe something went wrong? idk.
Anyway I can't decide between g1 applejack and g4 applejack. I generally prefer g1 but I've been with g4 applejack so long you know.
I like the g1 toy better but the g4 character is more appealing to me.

Same here: I prefer G4's personality (she's one of my faves on the show), but G1s are just prettier toys overall, and I love the shy pose!

[Zapper]

G3 for me because of her outstanding colors. She looks like a delicious red apple hanging in a green leafed tree. Classic AJ colors remind me more of applejuice.

[Jorgito93]

G1 AJ is a classic and I love her but I love g3 aj even more, her colors just look so great.

[OleGrayMane]

I want G3's figure, G1's colors, and G4's hat.