The package is only 4 oz. A little less to be exact. The recipient has a verified shipping address. I double checked.
Is it possibly that you are sending it by "envelope" rate instead of "package" rate? If it is fatter than 3/4" - the price jumps to $9.50, even for a tiny little package weighing 3 or 4 oz (so I have discovered)
Nope. It said $9.50. I do this a lot. I actually got charged a little less because eBay gives sellers a discount. As I have said, it was taken to the post office and the clerk said everything on the form was filled out correctly and they had no idea why it was returned. And with no stamping on it. I even emailed customer service and got a call back today and they couldn't explain why it had been returned twice.
And I didn't select envelope. I clearly selected package. It's set up that way on my template.
Post Merge: January 18, 2017, 11:28:49 AMIn case everyone wants to see this great shipping circle my package keeps taking (judging by the Jan. 18 in Newark, it's on its way back to me again....):
Delivered, In/At Mailbox
Jan-13-17, 13:59 PM, NEWARK, OH 43055
DELIVERED IN/AT MAILBOX
Jan-13-17, 13:59 PM, NEWARK 43055
ARRIVAL AT UNIT
Jan-18-17, 07:27 AM, NEWARK 43055
ARRIVE USPS FACILITY
Jan-18-17, 06:18 AM, NEWARK 43058
DEPART USPS FACILITY
Jan-18-17, 05:24 AM, COLUMBUS 43218
DEPART USPS FACILITY
Jan-18-17, 05:17 AM, COLUMBUS 43218
PROCESSED THROUGH USPS FACILITY
Jan-18-17, 04:25 AM, COLUMBUS 43218
PROCESSED THROUGH USPS FACILITY
Jan-18-17, 02:41 AM, COLUMBUS 43218
PROCESSED THROUGH USPS FACILITY
Jan-18-17, 00:55 AM, COLUMBUS 43218
PROCESSED THROUGH USPS FACILITY
Jan-18-17, 00:06 AM, COLUMBUS 43218
PROCESSED THROUGH USPS FACILITY
Jan-17-17, 21:39 PM, COLUMBUS 43218
DEPART POST OFFICE
Jan-17-17, 18:13 PM, REYNOLDSBURG 43068
ACCEPT OR PICKUP
Jan-17-17, 15:29 PM, REYNOLDSBURG 43068
ARRIVAL AT UNIT
Jan-16-17, 13:01 PM, NEWARK 43055
DEPART USPS FACILITY
Jan-16-17, 03:25 AM, COLUMBUS 43218
DEPART USPS FACILITY
Jan-15-17, 22:58 PM, COLUMBUS 43218
PROCESSED THROUGH USPS FACILITY
Jan-15-17, 20:52 PM, COLUMBUS 43218
PROCESSED THROUGH USPS FACILITY
Jan-15-17, 00:15 AM, COLUMBUS 43218
PROCESSED THROUGH USPS FACILITY
Jan-15-17, 00:04 AM, COLUMBUS 43218
PROCESSED THROUGH USPS FACILITY
Jan-15-17, 00:01 AM, COLUMBUS 43218
PROCESSED THROUGH USPS FACILITY
Jan-14-17, 23:07 PM, COLUMBUS 43218
PROCESSED THROUGH USPS FACILITY
Jan-14-17, 22:19 PM, COLUMBUS 43218
PROCESSED THROUGH USPS FACILITY
Jan-14-17, 22:12 PM, COLUMBUS 43218
DEPART POST OFFICE
Jan-14-17, 15:50 PM, NEWARK 43055
PICKED UP
Jan-14-17, 12:36 PM, NEWARK 43055
Arrived at Unit
Jan-13-17, 04:28 AM, NEWARK, OH 43055
Arrived at USPS Facility
Jan-13-17, 04:14 AM, NEWARK, OH 43058
Departed USPS Facility
Jan-13-17, 03:20 AM, COLUMBUS, OH 43218
Arrived at USPS Facility
Jan-12-17, 19:24 PM, COLUMBUS, OH 43218
Picked Up
Jan-12-17, 13:01 PM, NEWARK, OH 43055