The Most Sought After

[hathorcat]

Ok - this isnt the "rarest" pony or the "most expensive" pony...this is the most sought after pony.

Lol - this is one of those completely subjective questions as you have to take out value and rarity and completely base it on the ponies that most people seem to wish to have in their collection.

For me I think its the enchanting Red Roses - yes she can be a little expensive [but far from the most expensive] but she comes up as often as the other PPs yet so many people always seem to be on the look out for her.

Any others?

[TickledPink]

Hmm..maybe Ice Crystal? He was quite the hot ticket there for awhile!

[ponylady]

Let's see..how about TAF Buttons?

[Oneleo1]

TAF Buttons is a good one!

What about Vanilla Treats?

[Ivy]

I agree with Ice Crystal - I had Red Roses as a kid so never had to seek her.

How about any Year 3 Sea Ponies and their shells? Or Baby Buttons!

[ponylady]

Oh Yeah!!!Year 3 Sea Ponies  Good One!

And I don't even want to talk about their shells.

[Sonata]

The Tales ponies. This was the only MLP show I watched when I was a kid and I've always wanted to have the actually toys...

Darn, I want them all but they are expensive and hard to find !

[Gingerbread]

Mimic for sure, and everyone wants a Minty and a Ditzy.

[Brightglowpony]

It's interesting to see what everyone says

A few came to mind for me:  Mimic, Ice Crystal, and Greek Ladybird

[Enolaalone]

I agree about Mimic. Also those hair-do ponies seem to do well and I see them come up a lot, and the sweetie baby ponies. I'm not sure though, it might be that they come up a lot more in the UK than the US.

[kakenterprise]

I can't say mimic because luck would have it, that  I found one a while back.

So my next pony is Ice Crystal.

[kittybethy]

How about the G3 birthfower ponies?


 They are so hard to find!

[hathorcat]

Oh TAF Buttons is a great shout!

Maybe Diamond Dreams? I seem to see a lot of people on the look out for her.

[Bebopgroove]

For me, I've personally wanted Mimic, just because she's a unicorn (+) and my favorite shade of green (+), but I haven't really gone looking for her lately. I know she's worth a hefty sum

I would agree with Pinkamena - Ditzy and Minty are probably the most sought-after G4s at the moment.

[Sunset]

I would add Dandelion the 2010 Fair pony since I had such a hard time finding one for sale when I was looking.  I still almost never see her for sale.