Who would you keep and why?

[mul-ta]

I guess I'll have to leave Dream Beauties out of this? I have no super rare and/or expensive nirvanas to think of, so I'm completely free to choose ponies based on other criteria than monetary value.

1. D'n'P Player "Galaxy". My first childhood pony. Not in great condition, but she'd probably be the last pony I'd give up.

2. 7-Tales Patch. My favourite Tales character.

3. Pink Dreams. The dreamiest flutter around.

4. SS Crumpet. She reminds me of myself - I drink tea and am So Soft. She's not in pristine condition, but has her original comb and ribbon, and I cleaned her myself.

5. Sweetsteps Ballerina Tip Toes. As a hobbyist ballerina, I need a ballerina pony, and she's the most beautiful one I have.

6. Baby Woolly. Every pony needs a lamb friend.

7. Sea Mist. How could I go on without a Sea Pony?

8. August Birthflower Poppy. It's not my birth month, but she's my favourite of the ordinary birthflowers.

9. Medley. My favourite pegasus and one of the first ponies I really obsessed over when I started collecting. I ridiculously overpaid her, but in retrospect I don't care

10. Lemon Drop (the HK 4-stamper with dark purple drops). My first Lemon Drop, where my love for this pony started.

[Honeycomb]

Hmmmm.
1. Spain Texas because he is from my childhood, because he is complete, and because I would never be able to afford him again
2. MOC Love Meldoy because she is a Christmas present from my mum who usually doesn't really support my collecting
3. Baby Splashes because she was my favourite childhood pony
4. MIB Breast Cancer Awareness pony, no need to say why.
5. Open mouth loose BCA pony
6. Closed mouth loose BCA pony
7. Galaxy because she was my first pony ever
8. Baby Schlummerlein because she is mint and complete and my last ever childhood pony
9. the prototype drama pony just because I hope it will be worth more money.
10. childhood Sherbet just because.

That was NOT easy.

[shabbychicdee]

thats really really hard. ok here goes.......
1- glory cos she was my first ever pony and the most beautiful.
2- minty because she set of the whole wanting mlp when i was a kid and seeing her in a toy catalogue 
3- surprise love the fluoro hair and white body and gorgeous shy pose.
4- skydancer cos she is an adult fav and so 80s looking
5- baby cuddles with baby buggy cos i wanted her so bad as a kid
6- seashell and
7-  bubbles i wanted them sooo badly as a kid, sitting ponies are mega awesome.
8 - another real hard one, baby glory or moondancer, probibly baby moondacer cos i left out mommy moondacer from the list.
9- sprinkles cos mum bought me the waterfall it was awesome and the only mlp playset i had as a kid.
10- moonstone loved her she was my second pony as a kid.

if i could cheat..........
- moondacer, i love her colouring more then her body pose.
- baby glory love her so much
- macau jenny cos she looks like TJ from rescue from midnight castle. brown ponies are awesome.

[cyberunicorn]

I know that others have found this hard but sadly for most of my ponies there is no contest as to which ones I would keep.

1. Cherry Treats
2. Hula Hula
3. Rainbow Rider
4. Paint time
5. Wind whistler
6. Pony bride
7. Happy glow
8. Merry Treats
9. Merry go round Flower Bouquet
10. Sugar sweet

All are either original or replacement childhood ponies that are currently in the house with the exception of sugar sweet and I just love her smell.

[Sabrina]

This is a pretty easy question for me. I would keep my childhood ponies. It would be hard to part with any of my ponies but I would be heartbroken if I had to part with childhood ones, my grandparents bought them for me. So my list would be:
1. Blossom
2. Galaxy
3. Buttons (so soft)
4. Buttons (TAF)
5. Sealight
6. Princess Tiffany (and Friendly, she needs her bushwoolie friend )
7.Peach Blossom
8. Lady Flutter
9. Little Flitter
10.Baby Sleepy Pie
10.5. Little Honey Pie (she is too tiny to count as her own pony so she can count as part of the 10..... Lol! That's my story and I'm sticking to it! )

[lemonice]

Here is mine:

1) Baby Snoozy (my first pony)

2,3,4 the sweetie babys lollipop. licorice and candy

5) ice crystal

6) lemom treats

7) baby splash (the last pony i got when i was a Little girl that was moc )

8) the giraffe (i just love giraffes so much)

9)  my Lovely rock n beat half note

10) dinosaurius =)

[PWN-E]

Oh gosh, only ten?

1. Minty (my childhood pony)

2. Munchy

3. TAF Yum Yum

4. MO Star Hopper (friend let me play with their childhood one when I was young)

5. Nightmare Moon

6. Diamond Rose

7. Baby Lemon Drop

8. Cotton Candy (my first g1)

9.  Baby Molasses

10. Creamsicle

[Gizmo]

I'll have to include playsets, so it would be either:

• Confetti
• Trickles
• Starflower
• Pinwheel
• Tickle
• Flutterbye
• Satin n' Lace
• Baby Buggy & Cuddles
• Peachy w/ the Pretty Parlor
• Majesty w/ the Dream Castle

Or:

• Blossom
• Cotton Candy
• Butterscotch
• Minty
• Bluebelle
• Snuzzle
• Bowtie (collector pose)
• Peachy w/ the Pretty Parlor
• Sprinkles w/ the Waterfall
• Majesty w/ the Dream Castle

[Rhubarbpie]

ooh this is gonna be a toughie............

1 - G1 UK Gypsy - won in a vicious ebay battle and I adore her

2 - G1 Baby Applejack - so adorable

3 - G4 FS Rarity - my glamour gal

4 - G3 Silver Glow - a bargainous 10 pence pony from a car boot sale

5 - G3 Baby Keen Bean - cutie

6 - G1 Barnacle - the alpha stud of my herd

7 - G1 UK Hopscotch - I gave one away when I first started collecting ponies, then I realised she was a UK exclusive pony and spent ages looking for her (I just couldn't go to my 5 year old goddaughter and ask for her back could I?)

8 - G4 Mrs Cake - quite possible the happiest pony ever

9 - G1 Snuzzle - love the name, love the colours, love the pony

10 - G1 Baby Glory - my first restoration project and oh so adorable!

[CrazyCatPony]

it is so hard to pick but i would mostly keep my childhood ponies.

1. Baby glory (a childhood fav)
2. High flier (a childhood fav)
3 .Moondancer
4. Sky rocket
5. G3 Minty (christmas fancy pony)
6. G4 nightmare moon (villin pony!)
7. Merry treats
8. Baby moondancer
9. Sun glider
10. Dancing butterflies

[katrine2309]

It is so much fun reading all your choices and why - especially since everyone has such different ones! And different reasons as well. I guess when it comes down to it, none of us are really only choosing the "popular" ones, but those that are meaningful to us in some way. I think that is kind of nice!

[Wishing Well]

Out of my G4 collection

1. Zecora: She's my FAVORITE MLP Character!
2. Rainbow Flash: Was the first pony I ever bought.
3. Twisty Twirls (Baby Molasses): Favorite Filly Pony.
4. CE Ploomette: I just have fond memories of de-tinselling her while watching Aladdin with my best friend.
5. White Celestia: Love Celestia
6. Nightmare Moon: Love Nightmare Moon
7. Honeybuzz: I love her colors!
8. Lyra Heartstrings: I love her character and her colors
9. Sunset Shimmer: She looks fantastic!
10: Starswirl: I just love her colors!

[Griffin]

Oh no, this is going to be tough. I probably have around 10 childhood ponies (half of which were my sister's) so those need to come first, obviously.

1. Hair-Do Bangles (my childhood fave!)
2. Pony Bride (my 2nd fave)
3. Strawberry Surprise (got it from one of my best childhood friends, we're no longer in touch)
4. Sports-Time
5. Love Story (nos 5-7 are my lil' sister's ponies)
6. Love-in-a-Mist
7. Chatterbox
8. Baby Cotton Candy (the only baby pony we had)
9. NSS Gusty (I saw a picture of Gusty in a sticker album as a child and she instantly became my top favourite pony ever. I'm trying to get all/most variants of her eventually, but this NSS was my first and will remain my favourite.)
10. I have so many candidates for the last one but I guess I'm going with G3 Seaspray. She was a birthday gift from a friend of mine when I had just started collecting ponies.

I left out Stardazzle and CP Bowtie from the childhood collection. Those were our shared ponies just like Baby CC and Strawberry Surprise but we never liked them as much as the other ponies, and today they still don't hold the same value to me as the other childhood ponies. I'd much rather keep my first Gusty, the pony I always dreamed of. ^^

[Pumpkin]

1. Lemon Drop off course! She is lovely with her chubby body and beautiful colors. I've played the most with her in my childhood.

2. Pretty Parlor (if a playset counts), played a lot with it and is so easy and simple design.

3. Sky Dancer France also childhood pony and I love the pose.

4. Baby Surprise, I've still have her from my childhood and in perfect condition. Super white body, lovely shiny hair and awesome glitters.

5. Minty Macau, what a beautiful eyes and long hair she has.

6. Peachy FF, so cute with her chubby body and feet.

7. Glory, the perfect unicorn, what an amazing colors!

8. Dream Castle playset, played a lot with in my childhood and still have it in my collection.

9. Applejack CP, chubby body and cute apples.

10. Bonnie Bonnets TAF, she is so cute with all those hats on her body and her sweet shy pose.