Desert Island Ponies...

[hathorcat]

So some of you will and some of you wont know the Desert Islands Disks show/game...where you are supposed to decide what 8 songs you would like to have with you if you were a castaway on a desert island.


This is the same idea for ponies...if you were a castaway on an island which 3 ponies would you like to keep you company...it can be your "favourite" ponies or the ponies who have most sentimental value...anything at all for a giggle.


For me - Baby Fifi [my favourite], Chief [as he is my dads favourite colours so reminds me of him] and Hula Hula [a tropical pony for a tropical island!]

[IIya]

G4 Rarity (because she is my favorite pony)
G2 Princess Crystal and G2 Light heart because they were gifts from my sister

[ponylady]

Tornado, Baby Leaper and probably my FS white Celestia.

[Eviecorn]

Hmmmm... I'd have G2 Globe Trotter, G1 Applejack, and G3 Sunrise Song.

[Storm.Runner]

G1 Tex, G2 Light Heart, and Princess Starburst

[Chi]

Two of my nirvana Poseys (don't ask me which ones because I really can't decide..) and my prototype pony. She may be completely blank but for some reason she has totally won over my heart. I really can't understand why but she's become something pretty special to me.

[Applejack]

for me it would be
Speedy (shes one of my favorites)
G3 pinkie pie (she was my first)
and Princess Primrose (Favorite)

[scarletjul]

SS Wind Whistler (she's my absolute favorite)
Raincurl (childhood pony)
Baby Crumpet (another favorite)

[StoryDreamer]

Baby Glider (one of my childhood ponies)
Luna (one of my faves)
Princess Tiffany (favorite of the princesses)

[kellyponyfeathers]

Ha ha, I think I'd prefer to leave them all at home so they'll still be pristine when I come back to them!

[hyenacub]

Childhood baby Surprise, Lightning (assuming I can choose a pony I don't have) and a life-sized, real Rainbow Dash...because she can fly my ass off that island! 

[Nienna]

My childhood Gingerbread
childhood Princess Amethyst
NSS Cupcake.

[Princess-Sparkles]

Only....only three? This is hard, I have so many I really love.

Okay here goes:
UK Princess Sparkle (Lucy) - my all time favourite childhood pony
Mimic - birthday present from my fiancé
Bowtie - I just love Bowtie altogether <3

[foalpatrol]

Giant 1 metre tall Minty because she's cuddly and doubles as a good pillow.
Any one of the cookery ponies (probably Vanilla Treat) so she can whip up delicious snacks for me.
Hippity Hop because she's awesome.  Also, she's a pegasus and I can send her off to fetch me things from the mainland.

[hathorcat]

Giant 1 metre tall Minty because she's cuddly and doubles as a good pillow.
Any one of the cookery ponies (probably Vanilla Treat) so she can whip up delicious snacks for me.
Hippity Hop because she's awesome.  Also, she's a pegasus and I can send her off to fetch me things from the mainland.

Lol...I love this list! You are covering all bases!