PC Full set of Birthday Jewel G3's NM?

[Stormness_1]

I'm eyeing a lot which contains the full set of the Birthday jewel ponies, and am unsure what to offer, as the lot is overpriced, but I kinda want them, ya'know? And of course I want to be fair!

All of them are removed from box only for display, and are described as being near mint, but the photos are a bit dodgy.

So all you G3 experts... help, please?!

[PinkiePosh]

$45-$60 is my best bet. 

[ponycake]

Are they coming with boxes then?..

Truly MIB they usually sell for like $20-$30 a piece from what I've seen (actually I just checked and it looks like several also go for ($12-$15), so having been taken out and not completely mint should ding the prices of each in the lot. There's an online MIB auction of them that comes out to like $17 a piece with shipping included and I think that's a reasonable deal (okay now I think it definitely is a bit high!). But if you're just talking loose ponies I'm not sure at all.

[Stormness_1]

These girls I'm looking at are loose.

[hathorcat]

They can be a little all over in price and they are no where near as pricey as the birthflowers. Loose, which they technically are having been removed from their box, I would not expect to pay more than $6-8 per one. As a lot I would think $70-80 for a set of loose birthstone ponies is fair. However I would note that unless the shipping is a great deal, you would possibly be cheaper buying individually....it really depends.