Who is your impossible pony?

[glitterball]

Ah, Cascade, replacing my childhood pony that got lost after storage in the shed... always miss-out on the auctions! 

[Miniature Sheep]

Ringlet, without a doubt. Every time I find her, the pink part of her hair is always faded. Normally I'm not fussy about that on other ponies but she really doesn't look right without the pink bit going on. :/

[EnaRocketQueen]

Because I'm unable to use PayPal, pretty much every G1 2 or 3 pony. Also the early G4s that I can't find anywhere

[Kittywhiskers]

Night Glider and Dutch Baby Cat! The one time I saw Night Glider for under 80$, I slept through the auction!  And the one time I found a Dutch Baby Cat that didn't cost a downright insane amount, there was just enough question about what might happen to the economy at the time that I was advised to save my money.

[SkyCakes]

Rapunzel, and Trickles, or Confetti. I always wanted to replace the two rainbow ponies since they have bad age spots.

[josiekat]

Well condition never really is an issue for me. I don't mind manky ponies. But.......for some reasons, Cranberry Muffins is simply impossible for me to get. She pops up for sale when I don't have money, and is never around when I do. lol

[Shaiyeh]

Every single pony, ever, atm at least. Such is life with no pony funds

Other than that, one that keeps evading me is Lickety Split. in my 10 years of collecting, I have never once owned her, not even as a bait. I do have her baby, though.

[BlushingBlue]

Pinwheel without major body issues and/or whose symbols aren't worn off or a rusty mess. Ditto for Trickles.

[Gingerbread]

Jenny. I once passed by on a £20 BiN for her, went back on line the next day and of course, she had gone. Now she is just too far out of my price range or I miss the auction.

[pinkkittywinks]

South African Starshine or Seashell

Love pkw xxx

[invaderhorizongreen]

Right now it is any pony on my list, we had unexpected bills so no funds right now. 

[Haruna]

My Impossible Girl, eerrr I mean pony, my impossible pony

Ha ha, I had the same thought! Whovians FTW. My impossible pony would be Baby Sugarcake. A good portion of the ponies on my wish list are more expensive (Baby Milky Way, Baby Sapphire, Baby Honeycomb), but they do show up on Ebay and, if I budget carefully, wouldn't break the bank. Baby Sugarcake, though . . .

[brightberry]

Butterscotch.  I own so many of her and every single one has a spot.  Though it is neat to see all the tiny variations she comes in.

[Katika]

This is going to so und sorta "well, *duh*!" but MO Mommy and Baby ponies have eluded me for *years* now! I'm hunting for them in good or better condition, but am adamant for some reason about buying them *together.* I don't know if it's to feel like I have a pair that was originally packaged together or what (that might be it... I think I've only ever bought my NBTs and TTs in pairs). I've come so very close to getting them about three times, but always about 5 hours behind someone who just wants one of them. I'd have the set by now if I'd have let myself buy them separately, but I just can't seem to do that 

[Marlin]

Princess Taffeta.

I've lost count of how many times I've lost out on her. The last auction I had a go at she was unmarked in a lot and slightly hidden and went soooo cheap but more than I could justify with international shipping.  I pissed steam out of my ears for weeks over that one!

But hey... I eventually lucked out on Red Roses after years of trying, so one day, Taffeta, you little blue tart, I WILL get you!! 

Post Merge: February 08, 2017, 03:58:30 PM

oh, whoops, I just realised this thread is more about condition - not impossible to obtain generally!

Oh well, condition wise, I'd have to join the consensus on gingerbread. Had lots go through my hands... never a perfect one! Her and Bubbles and Seashell. There's ALWAYS something, be it a mark or haircut!