Unpopular Pony Opinions

[Pokeyonekenobie]

I don't know why I remember Tales as being made to market in Europe, but I remember thinking that when I caught a part of it way back when.

Maybe because the characters that were made into toys were only sold in Europe? 

[brightberry]

I don't know why I remember Tales as being made to market in Europe, but I remember thinking that when I caught a part of it way back when.

Maybe because the characters that were made into toys were only sold in Europe? 

I wouldn't have known about the toys. No internet back then.

[Taffeta]

I don't know why I remember Tales as being made to market in Europe, but I remember thinking that when I caught a part of it way back when.

Maybe because the characters that were made into toys were only sold in Europe? 

I wouldn't have known about the toys. No internet back then.

I always think this is one of the fun discussion points of G1.
I first watched Tales when I was 13. That would've been..1995? It aired on a cable channel and my sister's friend taped it and loaned us the tapes one by one.

I always felt a disconnect with the older episodes because of the different names/existence of ponies that weren't in the UK. But I never felt it with Tales, because I had Bright Eyes as a kid, the comics also included Tales stories, and the context - with football and such, but also the name Glowing Magic(al) - was all in keeping with what I already knew from the later end of MLP.

Probably why I liked it better at the time. It did feel like it was targeted at us.

[Lilja]

I don't mind "recycled names" - I never really did for a long time, as I get that they're all different ponies, with the same names (even if they reused the name "because it worked before" or whatever, like it was a marketable name), but also because I've tried naming my own ponies, and some of the names I came up with turned out to be the names of canon ponies.

I actually always liked that they reused certain names over the years. I felt it gave a sense of familiarity, like the older ponies hadn't been forgotten. Even back when I first got online in the late '90s/early '00s I thought the collector community made too much of a deal of it.

Even less comprehensible when it's people in the UK who grew up with those other names.

In Sweden we had the UK release for most of our ponies, so we had those names too. I remember one Swedish collector saying something along the lines of "I used to call this pony Sailaway when I was kid, but when I got online I learned her name was actually Hula Hula", completely unaware the pony was released under a different name here. As if "Sailaway" was just something she had dreamt up as a kid. (Very unlikely for a Swedish kid to come up with that name! )

My unpopular opinion would probably be that even though I grew up with the UK names (the ones I knew anyway), I still tend to prefer the US names for most of the part. (But the Tropical Ponies might be the one set I'll make an exception for.)

[PrincessKittyDragon]

I know this probably isn't an unpopular opinion but
Spoiler for tiny rant with very very mild nsfw topic

Spoiler

Bronies pretending to be the first male fans to be into MLP is infuriating to me :/
This is coming from someone who really got into MLP from G4 (even though I had some G3's as a kid)
Guys have been into MLP and collecting from the beginning and they managed to not be creepy!
Honestly I'd go as far as to say if G4's characters hadn't been sexualized as much as they have on the internet, most of those "bronies" wouldn't be fans at all! I genuinely think some bronies are only in the fandom for nsfw purposes (some women included!)

I wish I could have known the fandom before G4/Bronies, without the constant gross sexualization of ponies. Maybe I'm just put off from being exposed to really disgusting content at a young age

In short, non-brony guy collectors are super cool and I respect them a whole lot

[applejackbunny]

Idk if this is an unpopular opinion, but it's one I feel quite strongly about. Much as I love the brushable hair of all the pony gens, I can't abide it in the Petites! I literally will only collect the Petite Ponies with moulded hair. How weird is that? 

[Taffeta]

Idk if this is an unpopular opinion, but it's one I feel quite strongly about. Much as I love the brushable hair of all the pony gens, I can't abide it in the Petites! I literally will only collect the Petite Ponies with moulded hair. How weird is that? 

I agree brushy hair on the petites is a weird thing...xD. I don't hate it, but it is definitely not the most convenient pony hair to deal with, either in standing up ponies or trying to style it. It's sort of 'what's the point', although I admit it looks pretty on the fancier sets.

I do quite like the mad curls mind you. Hasbro didn't use them enough.

[Leave a Whisper]

Idk if this is an unpopular opinion, but it's one I feel quite strongly about. Much as I love the brushable hair of all the pony gens, I can't abide it in the Petites! I literally will only collect the Petite Ponies with moulded hair. How weird is that? 

I agree brushy hair on the petites is a weird thing...xD. I don't hate it, but it is definitely not the most convenient pony hair to deal with, either in standing up ponies or trying to style it. It's sort of 'what's the point', although I admit it looks pretty on the fancier sets.

I do quite like the mad curls mind you. Hasbro didn't use them enough.

Now we need a BnG or PP named, Mad Curls.

[starrynights]

It drives me crazy about how McDonald's ponies have a brushable mane or tail and then the other plastic.

[Leave a Whisper]

It drives me crazy about how McDonald's ponies have a brushable mane or tail and then the other plastic.

Same. Its the reason I turned my nose up at the g3 ones.

[Taffeta]

Idk if this is an unpopular opinion, but it's one I feel quite strongly about. Much as I love the brushable hair of all the pony gens, I can't abide it in the Petites! I literally will only collect the Petite Ponies with moulded hair. How weird is that? 

I agree brushy hair on the petites is a weird thing...xD. I don't hate it, but it is definitely not the most convenient pony hair to deal with, either in standing up ponies or trying to style it. It's sort of 'what's the point', although I admit it looks pretty on the fancier sets.

I do quite like the mad curls mind you. Hasbro didn't use them enough.

Now we need a BnG or PP named, Mad Curls.

Knowing Hasbro's current naming sense, it will probably be Curly Cutie. >.>

[Leave a Whisper]

Idk if this is an unpopular opinion, but it's one I feel quite strongly about. Much as I love the brushable hair of all the pony gens, I can't abide it in the Petites! I literally will only collect the Petite Ponies with moulded hair. How weird is that? 

I agree brushy hair on the petites is a weird thing...xD. I don't hate it, but it is definitely not the most convenient pony hair to deal with, either in standing up ponies or trying to style it. It's sort of 'what's the point', although I admit it looks pretty on the fancier sets.

I do quite like the mad curls mind you. Hasbro didn't use them enough.

Now we need a BnG or PP named, Mad Curls.

Knowing Hasbro's current naming sense, it will probably be Curly Cutie. >.>

Ooh. 

[Wardah]

Idk if this is an unpopular opinion, but it's one I feel quite strongly about. Much as I love the brushable hair of all the pony gens, I can't abide it in the Petites! I literally will only collect the Petite Ponies with moulded hair. How weird is that? 

I agree brushy hair on the petites is a weird thing...xD. I don't hate it, but it is definitely not the most convenient pony hair to deal with, either in standing up ponies or trying to style it. It's sort of 'what's the point', although I admit it looks pretty on the fancier sets.

I do quite like the mad curls mind you. Hasbro didn't use them enough.

I wonder if there's a way to give spiral curls to the ones without them?

It drives me crazy about how McDonald's ponies have a brushable mane or tail and then the other plastic.

Same. Its the reason I turned my nose up at the g3 ones.

Has there ever even been a McD pony that had both mane and tail hair?

[Leave a Whisper]

Idk if this is an unpopular opinion, but it's one I feel quite strongly about. Much as I love the brushable hair of all the pony gens, I can't abide it in the Petites! I literally will only collect the Petite Ponies with moulded hair. How weird is that? 

I agree brushy hair on the petites is a weird thing...xD. I don't hate it, but it is definitely not the most convenient pony hair to deal with, either in standing up ponies or trying to style it. It's sort of 'what's the point', although I admit it looks pretty on the fancier sets.

I do quite like the mad curls mind you. Hasbro didn't use them enough.

I wonder if there's a way to give spiral curls to the ones without them?

It drives me crazy about how McDonald's ponies have a brushable mane or tail and then the other plastic.

Same. Its the reason I turned my nose up at the g3 ones.

Has there ever even been a McD pony that had both mane and tail hair?

Not to my knowledge

[Shadowperla]

Has there ever even been a McD pony that had both mane and tail hair?

No, I think, but FAKIES of g3(?) Mcdonald pony I used to see. Very bad plastic, so never did buy any.