That AJ plushie is absolutely adorable!! Big congrats on your new additions.

Congrats! Those are some awesome new additions!! 

Wow, what an incredible find!! Your Breyers look lovely in it too.

Sent you a PM! 

I'm actively seeking to buy the following G1 items:

Flutter Ponies:
Wingsong
Tropical Breeze
Wind Drifter
Cloud Puff
Hollywood

Starlight Baby Ponies:
Baby Nightsong

DollyMix Ponies:
Medley
Firefly

Accessories:
Fish Combs  (all colors)
Sippy Cup
Boas (Aqua, pink, white, purple)
Mesh bow ties that came with fancy pants babies (all colors)
Various back cards (in good display condition)
Ribbons (gold metallic & silver metallic)

I'm a mint / near mint collector.
Please let me know if you have any of these items for sale!

Thank you!!! 

Concur with cutting off all communication at this point and reporting directly to ebay - this is classic scamming behaviour, fear mongering and extortion. I wouldn't post their ebay username until this is resolved one way or the other officially - don't give them any ammunition.  Wouldn't mention any outside forums either.

This is what I've been thinking as well and why I've been reluctant to disclose her username.

In response to the last message I received from her, I politely said that I think that it's best to proceed with putting this in the hands of the resolution center. I have yet to hear back from her.

I'm speculating that she may be trying to avoid opening a claim as she recently opened one against giggles friend. I imagine if there are multiple complaints coming in from one buyer that could be a red flag for eBay. However, if she is able to negotiate partial refunds from sellers without escalating things to the resolution center, then I'm thinking eBay would be none the wiser and this sort of behavior could go on indefinitely.

Congrats on the great finds! I never find G1s in thrift stores.

I appreciate all of your responses!  I'm glad to hear that I wasn't completely out of line with how I was handled the situation. 

I finally heard back from the buyer in response to that e-mail I sent.  She has lowered her requested partial refund to $10 and said that if I do not agree to this refund, then she is afraid that she will have no choice but to "ruin my seller's account".  Then she proceeded to tell me that she can take a picture to attest to the extra two pindots which is the reason for the requested refund.

I'm tempted to fight this just based on principle alone.   Again, I do not believe she received a misrepresented pony and I never denied there being 6 age spots.  I'm put off by the way she has gone about this refund and I do not like the fact that she is threatening to tarnish my seller's account. That being said, I really do feel badly that she is not happy with the pony and that her expectations were not met.   

I think the resolution center would side with me but ultimately I don't know if it is worth it (time to fight it, her leaving me negative feedback, and  me having a very unhappy buyer).