The MLP Arena

Pony Talk => Pony Corral => Topic started by: Taffeta on May 02, 2019, 11:24:19 AM

Title: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Taffeta on May 02, 2019, 11:24:19 AM
So some discussions recently in the other thread about pony prices and so on made me think that I've seen a few people buy ponies in poor condition to restore in order to be able to afford them.

And so I wondered what people's opinions generally are on this, whether rare or common ponies or grails or whatever?

Also, share ponies :D Mint ones or restored ones/not so mint/loved ones...

I don't restore ponies. So if I get a flawed one, they get a bath and a groom but they don't get rehaired or repainted or anything like that.

But I feel like the slightly loved ones are just as important as the minty ones.

I'll begin with some of my not-mint-but-loved-for-who-they-are-probably-much-cheaper clan to get the ball rolling :)

visitors can't see pics , please register or login


This is my Rapunzel.
I got her in a trade in around 2000.
She might look absolutely fine. But...that's about where her tail finishes. She has a normal length tail, not a long long one any more.
Weirdly she has her original braid, so I imagine her hair met a horrible tangle accident that led to it being cut.

Then there's this little girl - the one and only pony in my collection that has been restored at all (by PKW, kudos to her skills!) because she had NO eyes at all. And she now has eyes again, but nothing else on her has been fixed. I don't even collect Greek ponies, but it was Christmas, and she was cheap and looked really sad on ebay :( And so I rescued her and now she runs riot around my cupboard with Rozalyn, the only other greek baby I own, and a very abused adult Greek Bow Tie...

visitors can't see pics , please register or login


And finally, Taffy...who one day I will, I swear, get an upgrade of, but she's genuinely more brown than fuzz now..

visitors can't see pics , please register or login


I have a really beat up Truly as well, but I don't have a photo. For some reason I have about five Trulys now, which I never set out to even have one, but they keep staying O.O. This one in particular was rescued from a local collector in sad circumstances following a divorce. She was a loved childhood pony got rid of by her Dad, so I gave her a home. And now she thinks she has her own army.
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: tailrustedtealeaf on May 02, 2019, 11:29:41 AM
I get satisfaction from restoring ponies, but my painting skills are nowhere near good enough for me to be confident working on restores. I guess I tend to settle for flawed ponies and I'll just quietly upgrade if I come across a better one in a lot, a thrift store, etc. I don't need perfectly mint ponies and I don't mind some history on them.
I think I'd actually prefer to pay much less for a project of a pony, because I'll get attached while I'm restoring her. I have a Raspberry Jam with nasty head/body mismatch and a wild mohawk, but I'd feel bad replacing her... I got her at the fair for $1. I said she looked cute with her mohawk and the vendor said that everyone said that but no one picked her up...so she is mine now. I do want to try to lessen the mismatch and I think she might become one of my favorites by the time I'm done.
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Taffeta on May 02, 2019, 11:42:08 AM
I know what you mean. The Sugar Sweet
http://mlparena.com/index.php/topic,393220.msg1741011.html#msg1741011
I dug out of a box of horrors last summer at the carboot sale I totally meant to sell when I'd cleaned her up and recurled her messy hair, but she's still sitting on top of my briefcase in my room as if to say, "well, I'm staying now, and there's nothing you can do about it."
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Nemesis on May 02, 2019, 11:57:05 AM
I often find myself very attached to my “project ponies”. I enjoy cleaning and restoring them, and it’s very rewarding to see the transformation. :)

When I was very little, all of my ponies were secondhand. If there were flaws, there were flaws; I treasured every MLP that came into my possession, regardless. I still have that mentality as an adult, so I do my best to restore all of the damaged ponies that come my way. :) I know that those ponies were played with and loved, and that just gives them more history and character, to me.
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Taffeta on May 02, 2019, 12:00:20 PM
My childhood Princess Aquamarine was 2nd hand like that. She had one symbol and faded hair but I never cared. I loved her because I was mad about Princess Ponies and so excited to have her. Kids can sometimes be way more accepting of things than adults tend to be.
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Leave a Whisper on May 02, 2019, 12:08:47 PM
https://www.deviantart.com/littlekunai/art/Rusty-Pony-609811009

Love is blind sometimes. I saw an MO Starhopper on ebay for $20.00 free shipping. I was so delighted to find her that not only did I not care about the huge amount of rust in her body, but I literally did not notice the obvious haircut she had until I'd calmed down enough to take a second look after I'd bought her. Usually mohawked manes are a big no-no, because I'm too scared to rehair. But I cleaned her up and sent her off to get rehaired.

Here she is after

https://www.deviantart.com/littlekunai/art/MLP-n-Transformers-Close-Encounters-696233415

I don't mind putting up with some flaws, especially for a grail pony. These are 30 year old toys, they aren't gonna be perfect and there's no guarantee they'll stay perfect even if you got one in mint condition.
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: PoserBeachball on May 02, 2019, 02:27:05 PM
Some of my absolute favourites are my 'flawed' ones - it gives them such character. I like restoring and working out how to make them the best they can be, even if it just restyling hair to hide a mark.

So yes, I'll settle for a flawed pony if it's the 'right one'. It's the same for a grail or a common pony - if I like her, or she needs a good home, then home she comes (or he as I like my boys :) ).
I've found that if I do upgrade then I want to keep the original too - which is why I have so many multiples of favourite ponies, they all look a bit different to each other.


Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: glitterball on May 03, 2019, 12:11:27 AM
I am happy to give a home to nearly any G1 that needs some TLC, but due to storage limits I need to be a bit more picky these days! I go for how pretty the colour scheme is (mainly limes and turquoises and blues) and their pose (if only UK Tootsie was in an alt pose, though! I love her colours but her pose... nah)

Spa-days, rehairs, re-paints - all great fun and very satisfying when a project is completed.

So, with my stash of new pony hair and acrylic paints, various brushes, needles and hemostats, I'm all set to go!  :cool:

I rub my hands with glee when a pin-dotty Honeycomb sits in my sink, it is hard work cleaning off the grime but the efforts are so worth it.

De-flocking a very scratched-up Paradise was more work than I thought, her glue was so stubborn and I took extra special care to be gentle around her symbols, she turned out like new!

Some could say, allowing a minimum wage hourly rate against how long it took to restore would work out more expensive than buying a mint pony, but here's the thing: it only costs me money for the physical materials, the time "spent" is my leisure time - which is a choice to do something arty, crafty and fun, just for li'l me, not to run a business  :)


 
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Taffeta on May 03, 2019, 12:31:12 AM
@Glitterball - exactly how many Honeycombs do you have? xD.

@LAW - a little OT but I love the image of Fizzy with the soda cup in the other photos on your DA site :) And Starhopper looks amazing too :D

My sister has a whole box of rescue ponies in the loft. She used to pick up every really abused pony she could find at carboot sales to rescue them. She's still a bit that way - at ponycon last year I had to talk her out of buying a bald Posey and I couldn't talk her out of adopting a brown Blossom...
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Shaz on May 03, 2019, 01:15:29 AM
I love flawed ponies! Since I like to play with my ponies/take them outdoors for photo shoots, really minty ponies scare me a bit, especially expensive ones! I'd be too worried about messing them up to enjoy them! Some ponies get restored, some make their flaws work for them :).
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: PoserBeachball on May 03, 2019, 01:18:25 AM
My sister has a whole box of rescue ponies in the loft. She used to pick up every really abused pony she could find at carboot sales to rescue them. She's still a bit that way - at ponycon last year I had to talk her out of buying a bald Posey and I couldn't talk her out of adopting a brown Blossom...

I'm the same - except I doubt I'd have been talked out of a bald Posey - I've got a big gang of them that I've rehaired in all sorts of colours (she looks great with rainbow hair btw :) ). They look rather fab together, like a chorus line dancing along a shelf.

It's great that there are so many people that will restore and love these ponies
 

Post Merge: May 03, 2019, 01:25:17 AM


Some could say, allowing a minimum wage hourly rate against how long it took to restore would work out more expensive than buying a mint pony, but here's the thing: it only costs me money for the physical materials, the time "spent" is my leisure time - which is a choice to do something arty, crafty and fun, just for li'l me, not to run a business  :)

This is just it.
The fun of doing them up isn't measured in monetary value.

It's the same for so many other things in life too - making your own clothes, doing up a house, growing plants from seeds.....
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: kingluke on May 03, 2019, 04:09:16 AM
Well I like restoring ponies and I aint exactly swimming in money. Tho I can see the appeal in mint ponies too.
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Baby Crumpet on May 03, 2019, 05:43:06 AM
Most of my rares have flaws of some description; my thundercloud has brown spots, I imagine it's why I managed to snag him for a tenner on eBay a few years back.

I don't really mind so long as it isn't tail rust... flaws are just flaws at the end of the day and the ponies are cute with or without them. Sometimes I just want to rescue every single pony, so some of my doubles have some quite strange flaws.

It's really fun to restore baits back to their former glories, and anyway, it's not like I'm rich - my pony budget is very very stringent!
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: SaraMari on May 03, 2019, 07:00:25 AM
As I primarily only collect ponies that I find in the wild most of them are flawed, though I have some nice mint ones like a pony friend Cha Cha with accessories and box I got in a lot on the marketplace last month. I don't mind flaws like haircuts, leaning or a little marks. I can easily fix fried hair, pin dot and rust. The only flaw I don't like having in my collection is age spots so those I will try to upgrade when possible.

And like mentioned above a mint pony may one day start leaking plastizor/breaking down. So it's better to not be too picky about 35 year old toys

 I've bought ponies online and generally there's always some flaws that weren't shown or didn't seem as bad in photos, that always makes me feel disappointed. Though I don't mind the same flaws as much on ponies I find in the wild. So I've stopped buying online this year unless it's things I can't find in the wild like non-US ponies
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Safflower on May 03, 2019, 07:29:16 AM
I'm all about restorations, and I have a fair bit of experience. I would totally go for a baity Sternenglanz or any other of my grails for a lower price if I thought I our fix them up :) I'm not very picky.
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Leave a Whisper on May 03, 2019, 08:33:27 AM
@Glitterball - exactly how many Honeycombs do you have? xD.

@LAW - a little OT but I love the image of Fizzy with the soda cup in the other photos on your DA site :) And Starhopper looks amazing too :D

My sister has a whole box of rescue ponies in the loft. She used to pick up every really abused pony she could find at carboot sales to rescue them. She's still a bit that way - at ponycon last year I had to talk her out of buying a bald Posey and I couldn't talk her out of adopting a brown Blossom...

Thank you Taf. :)
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Shileah on May 03, 2019, 09:17:59 AM
When I first started, I bought every pony that seemed reasonably priced and did not care about the condition that much. I am pickier now and rather pay a bit more to get a pony in good condition. It doesn't need to be perfect and I haven't gone for any MIB ones (yet), but I don't buy ponies that have pen marks (except on the underside of the hoofs), obvious hair cuts, bite marks and easily visible damage to the symbols or eyes.

That said, I tremendously enjoy rehairing. I still have some ponies left from a bait lot I picked up before I went into collector's hiatus, but I haven't been able to find any decently priced new ones. I will keep looking though!

I don't really know what to do with the rehaired ones to be honest. I've kept them all so far, which is ok because they are all ponies I don't have in better condition, anyways. I have two Up, Up And Aways that both needed rehairing, one is done, the other one not yet, so not sure what I will do with her once she is done, too. Is there even a market for rehaired ponies?
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: glitterball on May 03, 2019, 10:41:17 AM
Oh - to add -

I recently bought one of my grails off of ebay - Bonnie Bonnets - she was actually a re-hair but that was cool with me - the re-hair was of great quality and she has a long, silky, mane and tail. I was absolutely delighted with her  :heart: :heart: :heart: - but I know some folks would rather buy an original haired version.
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Skeen on May 03, 2019, 11:42:35 AM
I don't enjoy upgrading because I don't like comparing flaws and deciding both ponies are equally flawed and having to keep both til I upgrade AGAIN, so I tend to buy either mint or "will clean up to mint."  I don't accept rehairs or restorations in my herd.  They have to be original. 
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Carrehz on May 03, 2019, 12:44:43 PM
I don't do upgrades - except in very very rare occasions, I buy a pony to keep. And I'm not a rehairer. So I'll wait until the right one in the right condition comes along. :)
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Taffeta on May 03, 2019, 01:56:01 PM
I don't enjoy upgrading because I don't like comparing flaws and deciding both ponies are equally flawed and having to keep both til I upgrade AGAIN, so I tend to buy either mint or "will clean up to mint."  I don't accept rehairs or restorations in my herd.  They have to be original. 
I do this too. I have a rule that the first in never leaves. Later ones might, or if I buy a pony my sister already has and then get a better one, upgrading and selling the original is ok because it's just a placeholder. It's complicated because we have a shared collection, but the "real collection pony" sometimes belongs to her. SS Truly is one of these, but for some reason I can't stop amassing Trulys. I guess I'm still looking for a perfect one or something?
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Artemesia's Garden on May 03, 2019, 02:41:42 PM
 I'm settling for flawed ponies now hat I'm getting down to the final few I really want. I love restoring them. I'm working on one at the moment and will post pictures when he's done.
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Leave a Whisper on May 03, 2019, 04:34:41 PM
Oh - to add -

I recently bought one of my grails off of ebay - Bonnie Bonnets - she was actually a re-hair but that was cool with me - the re-hair was of great quality and she has a long, silky, mane and tail. I was absolutely delighted with her  :heart: :heart: :heart: - but I know some folks would rather buy an original haired version.

Can we see?  :happy:
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Khoufu on May 03, 2019, 09:17:45 PM
I bought a Thundercloud with acne spots for $20 because I couldn't afford him otherwise. I don't mind limited spots and such, as long as it lowers the price sufficiently and symbols/eyes/flocking are in at least good shape, like 8/10.
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: SpacePinto on May 04, 2019, 01:01:32 AM
Since I don't really know how to restore old toys anyway, it's saving for really good ones for me, especially that I don't even have that much space in my living area to devote to ponies so I'd much rather settle for a small collection of ponies I really like that are in a really good shape, rather than having tons of random ponies in different stages of wear.
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Elfpony on May 04, 2019, 04:45:26 AM
I have a few ponies in my herd that are restorations and also a few that have flaws (Posey has a bobbed tail, but I think it’s cute and suits her). Funnily, I don’t mind flaws on more common ponies, but I am extremely picky when I’m looking to buy more expensive ponies. In those cases I’m willing to save up and spend more on a mint pony.

I also do upgrades, but I have also chosen to keep flawed ponies instead of upgrading. Sometimes the flawed pony has a “better face” and I end up keeping her instead. It’s certainly not a science.

Elf
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: toyjunky on May 04, 2019, 08:49:29 AM
For me, it depends on what the flaws are. Like some others I do not do restorations, so just a bath by hand, shampoo, condition maybe and restyle. So when I find some G1's I try to pick out the ponies that I think I can clean up decently.  Which means I leave ones behind that look full of rust or mold based on outward appearances (marks and staining) and also ones that have badly cut hair. Or ones that have things like marker scribbled down the whole side or across the face. I figure some other collector will eventually come along and buy those, so I try to only buy things I know I can handle. Although the last time I was at a swap meet I saw two baby sea ponies (never had found them in the wild before) that were tempting but they looked so icky and they wanted too much in my opinion for something that looked that moldy/mildew.
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: glitterball on May 04, 2019, 09:30:52 AM
Oh - to add -

I recently bought one of my grails off of ebay - Bonnie Bonnets - she was actually a re-hair but that was cool with me - the re-hair was of great quality and she has a long, silky, mane and tail. I was absolutely delighted with her  :heart: :heart: :heart: - but I know some folks would rather buy an original haired version.

Can we see?  :happy:

OK - I have popped her into temporary storage as we are preparing to move house, but I do have one of the seller photos:

visitors can't see pics , please register or login


She is a lovely re-hair, gorgeous long, slightly curly locks!  :heart: :heart: :heart:
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Taffeta on May 04, 2019, 09:33:19 AM
She does look pretty with those colours.
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: glitterball on May 04, 2019, 09:40:22 AM
She does look pretty with those colours.

Thanks - I was really pleased when I got her in my pony-mail! It would have cost me a lot more to get an "original" haired one from here or the US (high postage fees are such a killer) and then I saw her for a decent price in the UK! I guess no one else bid on her as she was a re-hair but that's fine by me! She has gone to a good home! (albeit now waiting in a box until we move and I can display her again, lol)
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Leave a Whisper on May 04, 2019, 10:10:19 AM
Oh - to add -

I recently bought one of my grails off of ebay - Bonnie Bonnets - she was actually a re-hair but that was cool with me - the re-hair was of great quality and she has a long, silky, mane and tail. I was absolutely delighted with her  :heart: :heart: :heart: - but I know some folks would rather buy an original haired version.

Can we see?  :happy:

OK - I have popped her into temporary storage as we are preparing to move house, but I do have one of the seller photos:

visitors can't see pics , please register or login


She is a lovely re-hair, gorgeous long, slightly curly locks!  :heart: :heart: :heart:

Ooh, she's so pretty!  :thumb:
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: TheBeatlesPkmnFan42 on May 04, 2019, 02:57:08 PM
When I find a pony in the wild that I don't have I buy it regardless of condition. If a flaw is so severe that I cannot fix it, then I just make a mental note to upgrade it in the future. If a flaw is more minor like something I can easily fix myself or a flaw that I don't mine too much (a small age spot or small area of paint rub isn't enough to warrant an upgrade for me unless I actually find a better one in the wild), then I will keep that pony and not upgrade it.

I'm more picky when I buy online usually. If a pony has minor flaws and is really cheap I may get it, but when I'm buying online I usually search out ones that are in better shape (not necessarily mint, but at least pretty nice).

OK - I have popped her into temporary storage as we are preparing to move house, but I do have one of the seller photos:

Spoiler
visitors can't see pics , please register or login

She is a lovely re-hair, gorgeous long, slightly curly locks!  :heart: :heart: :heart:


Beautiful! I love alt rehairs!
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: NightGliderSA on May 06, 2019, 12:25:10 AM
I know what you mean. The Sugar Sweet
http://mlparena.com/index.php/topic,393220.msg1741011.html#msg1741011
I dug out of a box of horrors last summer at the carboot sale I totally meant to sell when I'd cleaned her up and recurled her messy hair, but she's still sitting on top of my briefcase in my room as if to say, "well, I'm staying now, and there's nothing you can do about it."

You know... she has done that to me to. I received one in a lot, who I did not intend on keeping. But she is still there with all the other ponies, firmly ensconced.

Regarding mint or 'fixer-upper' ponies, for me it depends on the pony. I have Baby Pictures who looked a bit gruesome because she only had half an eye. But I have painted her a new one now and I love her - can't find that photo just at present, sorry! Also a Glory who had no symbol, so I decided to give her a new symbol and I like her so much that now I am keeping her.

Baby Fifi was partially rerooted and her symbols were repainted.

And of course there was slimy mold-filled cat pee covered Munchy.

Spoiler
visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login



There are many more, but I suppose you can say I try to do the best I can for the ponies in my herd. Small rubs to symbols I leave, but if they need major work then I will do it.
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Moonbreeze on May 06, 2019, 02:32:03 AM
Depends on the rarity of the pony of course ;) I settled for a French Moondancer with some flaws.
But she's still one of my favorites. However, since my (G1) collection isn't that big, I usually havethe funds to buy a NM one :)

I did rehair one Peru Moonstone. The poor thing was bald :P

Spoiler
visitors can't see pics , please register or login
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: gemini_pony on May 06, 2019, 03:08:52 AM
I have only found a few ponies here in thrift shops.  Most mine were gifts and I love my herd even with all it's flaws.
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Ponyfan on May 06, 2019, 03:50:46 AM
I have a Sparkle Baby that I can't seem to part with. Someone gave her mane a buzzcut and cut her tail to about a 3rd of its original length. I usually don't like ponies with mane or tail cuts but this little baby has made me love her anyway. If I get an upgrade one day the buzzcut baby will also stay in my herd.


Ponyfan
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: mlp4me on May 06, 2019, 05:59:15 AM
Much of my collection is flawed, I guess I'm not really that picky. Would I take a mail order or more expensive sea pony with a hair cut, yes please!
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Loona on May 07, 2019, 04:11:15 AM
I know what you mean. The Sugar Sweet
http://mlparena.com/index.php/topic,393220.msg1741011.html#msg1741011
I dug out of a box of horrors last summer at the carboot sale I totally meant to sell when I'd cleaned her up and recurled her messy hair, but she's still sitting on top of my briefcase in my room as if to say, "well, I'm staying now, and there's nothing you can do about it."

You know... she has done that to me to. I received one in a lot, who I did not intend on keeping. But she is still there with all the other ponies, firmly ensconced.
What is it about Sugar Sweet? Add me in too, she came to my herd the same way! I still have to get around to restore her.

I'm totally not a picky collector, and have a lot of flawed ponies. I do not mind most flaws. I have yet to try restoring cut hair or symbols, but I do have candidates who are waiting for such restorations. Since I don't enjoy looking for ponies online and spending a lot of money on them (I usually just see the money I spent in them, and not the backstory of stumbling upon them), most of my collection comes from second-hand, thrift or charity shops where I don't get to choose their condition. That is OK, as the pleasant memory of finding them accidentally makes up for any signs they carry on their bodies from their previous life. I also often wonder where they might have come from, and how long a way they've travelled until they got to me :)
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Taffeta on May 07, 2019, 07:24:28 AM
I know what you mean. The Sugar Sweet
http://mlparena.com/index.php/topic,393220.msg1741011.html#msg1741011
I dug out of a box of horrors last summer at the carboot sale I totally meant to sell when I'd cleaned her up and recurled her messy hair, but she's still sitting on top of my briefcase in my room as if to say, "well, I'm staying now, and there's nothing you can do about it."

You know... she has done that to me to. I received one in a lot, who I did not intend on keeping. But she is still there with all the other ponies, firmly ensconced.
What is it about Sugar Sweet? Add me in too, she came to my herd the same way! I still have to get around to restore her.

It';s the face. It doesn't have quite the same effect with Moondancer or Sunbeam, but it's such an awkward, shy looking pose and when you get that, coupled with a bush for a hairdo, it just makes you want to fix her. Big sad eyes and all that. And then when you've spent all the time working on her, suddenly she seems to belong. xD

I dunno. I am not a huge fan of the pose, but it really works on Sugar Sweet somehow. I am sure it's all in her expression.
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Artemesia's Garden on May 07, 2019, 10:57:18 AM
She does look pretty with those colours.

Thanks - I was really pleased when I got her in my pony-mail! It would have cost me a lot more to get an "original" haired one from here or the US (high postage fees are such a killer) and then I saw her for a decent price in the UK! I guess no one else bid on her as she was a re-hair but that's fine by me! She has gone to a good home! (albeit now waiting in a box until we move and I can display her again, lol)

She's gorgeous, she looks like a completely different pony. I definitely prefer her to the original.
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Loona on May 07, 2019, 11:02:33 AM
It';s the face. It doesn't have quite the same effect with Moondancer or Sunbeam, but it's such an awkward, shy looking pose and when you get that, coupled with a bush for a hairdo, it just makes you want to fix her. Big sad eyes and all that. And then when you've spent all the time working on her, suddenly she seems to belong. xD

I dunno. I am not a huge fan of the pose, but it really works on Sugar Sweet somehow. I am sure it's all in her expression.
Haha, there must be truth in this. And coming to think of it, I also always found the Moondancer pose awkward (which doesn't stop me from happily having Moondancer in my herd), but with Sugar Sweet, it feels like it's not the same pose. I don't know if it's the greater amount/differently styled hair, the colours, or both, but it feels different, even if I know it's the same.
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Taffeta on May 07, 2019, 11:21:19 AM
There's something gentle and fluffy about Sugar Sweet somehow XD


Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: brightberry on May 07, 2019, 01:49:00 PM
I tend to settle.  My childhood ponies mean a lot to me so I'm not inclined to replace them.  I don't really want a valuable collection of ponies to worry about.  I just want ponies to hold, admire and twirl their hair.  :P

But if you mean going on ebay and buying a cheap worn out pony, I would rather hold out for a pony closer to mint.  It's been a long time since I've bought a G1 pony.  My want list is tiny and I have a lot of other interests.
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: StayGoldPonyboy on May 07, 2019, 10:11:12 PM
I absolutely don’t mind “flawed” ponies at all! I’m the same about my Transformers (I have a G1 Inferno who’s missing his everything, even hands haha). I’m here for childhood nostalgia, not a flawless collection if that makes sense. I see all these ebay listings and stuff on here for “bait” ponies that have like, a few marker dots and some messy but still fixable hair! I appreciate how worthless people seem to think they are though because I’m broke 😂 The only pony I would think of as beyond redeemable would be if all their hair was missing/cut or if they had mold/regrind/cancer.
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: Loona on May 08, 2019, 10:24:56 AM
I absolutely don’t mind “flawed” ponies at all! I’m the same about my Transformers (I have a G1 Inferno who’s missing his everything, even hands haha). I’m here for childhood nostalgia, not a flawless collection if that makes sense. I see all these ebay listings and stuff on here for “bait” ponies that have like, a few marker dots and some messy but still fixable hair! I appreciate how worthless people seem to think they are though because I’m broke 😂 The only pony I would think of as beyond redeemable would be if all their hair was missing/cut or if they had mold/regrind/cancer.
Themeaning of the term 'bait' is so different from person to person... I agree with you, to me a lot of (I may even say the majority of) ponies sold under this term are far from bait. In the past I've bought ponies that were sold as bait, and they cleaned up perfectly in my eyes. I enjoy them just as they are :)
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: nessa16 on May 08, 2019, 10:50:04 AM
I usually settle for a non-mint pony because A-cheaper which allows for more ponies and B-I don't mind ponies with some flaws.  I do not restore ponies, however.  I am too anxious to take their heads off even to clean them out even though I know I should.  I would be devastated if some of my more expensive ones were ruined because I could not behead them properly. 
Title: Re: Settle for a flawed pony or save for a mint one?
Post by: ZeldaTheSwordsman on May 09, 2019, 06:40:42 AM
Settle. I bought a tail-less Applejack, a Hollywood with a chewed leg and a haircut, a Baby Sundance who turned out to be missing an iris... So many with flaws, all in the name of the purchase being cheaper at the time. If not for the 35th Anniversary reissues, I wouldn't have any mint G1s.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal