Unpopular Pony Opinions?

[Sandi]

*I like Tootsie and her pose.
*I like Shady.
*I love the donkey pose.
*I love first tooth babies.
*I like G2s and G3.5s.
*I don't love wingers. Don't dislike them either, I just don't like them enough to pay those high prices.
*I'm not super fond of Rapunzel. Same as with wingers.
*I love piggy ponies because of their eyes and pose.
*I don't think BBEs look scary.

[annukkainen]

I like tinsel and Gingrebread's pose. Oh, and nowadays I like G2 ponies too.

[Starlie]

I don't like the majority of the G1 ponies. :I But I love G2. -hides-

[hathorcat]

Is it weird that about half of the posts in this thread are for "unpopular" opinions that I didnt realise were "unpopular"...? I am so not "cool" enough...lol

[megsense]

Is it weird that about half of the posts in this thread are for "unpopular" opinions that I didnt realise were "unpopular"...? I am so not "cool" enough...lol

I'm with you.

I always loved Megan, hated Perfume Puffs. And Mimic.. sorry that's ugly, rare or not.

[little.fox]

I detest Princess Sparkle.

[Squirrelypaws]

I'm not really a big fan of most G1s. They just tend to look... I don't know... dopey or something?

I see a lot of hate toward tinsel, but I actually like it. I think it adds a lot to a pony.

[Tropical_Sunset]

--I like NSS Shady!
--So Softs kind of gross me out.  I have some, but I prefer them deflocked.
--I don't really like G1 baby ponies.  I have some, but I don't actively seek them out like I do with adult ponies.
--I DESPISE My Little Pony Tales!!!
--I can't stand that so many G4s are flawed coming right out of the box.  I am assuming this is an unpopular opinion because of the amount of collectors here telling me "it's not that bad" or "they're only children's toys".  I am perfectly fine with G1s having problems; They're old.  A ton of G4s come out of the box looking like garbage and I'm not having it.  When I buy something that's brand new, I expect it to look nice.  Period.  Anything less than nice gets returned to the store immediately.

[Mandy85]

-I don't mind hair tinsel
-I like G2's more than G3's and I'm not a G2 collector
-I love how small the G4's are
-I get more excited for the animal friends the G4's come with over the ponies themselves
-I think the G4 blindbag ponies are overrated, they don't even have a proper mold for Fluttershy
-Though I'd prefer them to match, I don't really care when a pony's head doesn't match it's body
-I think Rapunzel is hideous, everything about her has always just seemed off to me
-I think pony fanfiction is odd and refuse to acknowledge fanon names for G4 ponies
-I dislike G1 So Softs and prefer them deflocked
-I think the G1 cartoon is laughably bad. I loved it as a child but I really wish I didn't try re-watching it as an adult, I feel it ruined the nostalgia factor for me.
-I'm not big on MLP accessories and hate when a pony comes with too many
-I'd rather own a rehair/repaint than a pony with ratty "original" hair or scuffed symbols/eyes
-I love the fakie Princess Rinse n' Spit

[JessicaAFM]

I am new to the world of collecting ponies even though I have collected them for years so I am not sure how unpopular my opinions are.


-One of my strongest opinions is that the G2 line is worthless. Ponies are supposed to be short and wide. G2s look like horses, tall and skinny. I don't have a single one and probably won't ever have one unless it really is eye catching.


- I love the old 80's cartoons 100% more than FiM.


- I prefer ponies with brushable mane and tail. I don't like the figurines much.


- Even though I buy them, I feel cheated by the standard size of the newer ponies. At least G2s were still full sized.


Jessica

[DazzleKitty]

I guess Tootsie isn't popular? At first I thought she looked fugly in pics. I got her not too long ago and she is much prettier in person. I actually like her. The green color is less icky with the vibrant blue hair. I always thought TAF Buttons was ugly but I've never seen in her in person. I am thinking if I like Tootsie I may liker her better if I actually acquire her.

[princesskitty]

I really hated the G4s when they came out, since I was so loving the G3 ponies.
but they I grow to like them.. does that count? O_o


Post Merge: March 01, 2012, 07:54:44 PM

I also don't really like newborn ponies, with the hard heads and soft bodies..

[Icecrystalline]

I adore Mimic and Oakly, and year 3 seaponies,
I am soo creeped out by BBE's, I will never buy one, I've always been scared of them!
My favourite pony pose is Sundance's pose, my least favourite is Cherries Jubilee's pose.
I don't like Gingerbread, Shady's pose, I really dislike it, it's very masculine !

I love F.I.M but I don't want to collect the G4s, although I like them, I adore my G1's too much! xxx

[PandaBerryInSpace]

--I can't stand that so many G4s are flawed coming right out of the box.  I am assuming this is an unpopular opinion because of the amount of collectors here telling me "it's not that bad" or "they're only children's toys".  I am perfectly fine with G1s having problems; They're old.  A ton of G4s come out of the box looking like garbage and I'm not having it.  When I buy something that's brand new, I expect it to look nice.  Period.  Anything less than nice gets returned to the store immediately.

This, SO SO MUCH. I can't STAND it when I get a pony with eyes that are uneven, or anything else like that. It gets to the point where I can't play with a G4 for too long, otherwise I'll start to see flaws that probably aren't even there. D: I get really paranoid about it...

On a completely unrelated note, I don't like the Princess Luna doll. It's not even the fact that she's not show accurate... I just don't like the way they painted her unique eyes while giving her Twilight Sparkle's head mold. You can see the original eye sockets under them, it's SO weird! I'm also not a fan of the glitter or the tinsel.

[Firehooves]

I liked the shows more than the toyline? *hides* (There are a few toys I like though!)