Unpopular Pony Opinions

[Leave a Whisper]

I don't like the G5 boys faces. They've somehow managed to make them look even worse then the girls.

[glitterball]

I don't like the G5 boys faces. They've somehow managed to make them look even worse then the girls.

Gotta agree! Perhaps it's the eyebrows... or the squareness of the head... they look too "tough" IMO!

[Leave a Whisper]

I don't like the G5 boys faces. They've somehow managed to make them look even worse then the girls.

Gotta agree! Perhaps it's the eyebrows... or the squareness of the head... they look too "tough" IMO!

I don't think they look tough, just plain stupid and disproportionate.

[Faeriefalls]

I don't like the G5 boys faces. They've somehow managed to make them look even worse then the girls.

Gotta agree! Perhaps it's the eyebrows... or the squareness of the head... they look too "tough" IMO!

I don't think they look tough, just plain stupid and disproportionate.

There's definitely some sorta uncanny valley thing happening to the male ponies in G5. I also can't pinpoint why it doesn't work. The animation is a bit off or their expressions?

[ridi]

I think the boy ponies look ok in the cartoon, not too noticeably different from the girls, but the boy head mold for the toys looks so smushed, like they're smooshing their lips against a window or something. At least they're not quite on the level of the G4 boys. WTF was up with that dimorphism.

[lonewolf]

I finally saw a G5 toy (Starscout) in person at a Walmart Sunday (which is all they had).
And honestly they look even worse in person. They literally have "block heads". That coupled with the body IMO puts them below Pony Life toys.

[Leave a Whisper]

I finally saw a G5 toy (Starscout) in person at a Walmart Sunday (which is all they had).
And honestly they look even worse in person. They literally have "block heads". That coupled with the body IMO puts them below Pony Life toys.

I don't think anything could be worse then PL toys

[Taffeta]

I hope I don't feel like this when I see them in person, but the multipack sets of G5 look kinda like the multipacks of fakies I see sometimes in the supermarket :/

[Leave a Whisper]

I hope I don't feel like this when I see them in person, but the multipack sets of G5 look kinda like the multipacks of fakies I see sometimes in the supermarket :/

 

[lonewolf]

I finally saw a G5 toy (Starscout) in person at a Walmart Sunday (which is all they had).
And honestly they look even worse in person. They literally have "block heads". That coupled with the body IMO puts them below Pony Life toys.

I don't think anything could be worse then PL toys

There is in my book.

[Esbayne]

Unpopular opinion, I know the new ponies are creepy but somehow it made me love them more.

Retroactively it made me decide 100% I also love G3.5 and PonyLife.

But.
I still appreciate they are honestly super creepy and uncanny valley.
But I admit that's why I decided I liked them.

That being said, *popular* opinion, I don't like the new boy moulded hair. But part of me really feels like they may change that down the line, truly.

[Shystar06]

I don't like the G5 boys faces. They've somehow managed to make them look even worse then the girls.

Stole my post! Egads, they're...borderline creepy.

What else...hmmm....

MLP Tales was screwed by lazy writers as they were basically not "horsey" at all.

Likewise the MLP:FIM plotline nuked the fridge so badly that a lot of the better-written fanfics and AU's beat the canon events. Without question, hooves down. "Keep Calm and Flutter On" was probably my breaking point if I remember right.

[brmylittleponycollector]

I like all generations!
I don't really like the color of Snuzzle
I find the G4 and G4.5 animation style Horrible! But at least the dolls are cute!
I think the G2 Ponies are cute but too thin!
I LOVE AG3 AND G3.5 I THINK THEY ARE THE BEST AND MOST PERFECT GENERATIONS!
I think equestria girls should never have existed (Even me collecting!)
The G5 seems to me much better and superior to the G4!
There are some things from G4 that I think are super unnecessary!
I think G1 made by Estrela here in Brazil is a little prettier than the original Hasbro!
Takara ponies are very cute they look like dwarf ponies!
 

[paradiserain]

I'm not sure if these are unpopular opinions, but they're mine;

I hate G3.5 and G4.5. The "bumper" generations are so ugly and lame. G3.5 not only gave us weird, ugly, bobblehead ponies, but it also gave us the worst of the pony shows/movies. Also My Little Pony Life was such a downgrade from the original G4 show and the toys were/are super ugly. I HATE their designs.

G4 is only good for the show and the lore. The G4 toys are very ugly to me. The ponies in the show look fine and some are even cool, but their toy counterparts are such a disappointment. The generation overall is very overrated to me. I still enjoy the show and I have my favorite characters, but it's not my favorite generation.

The best G3 pose is the original Kimono pose.

[MouseCardinal]

I don’t quite know how unpopular this is anymore, but I refuse to have anything to do with G4/4.5. It was overblown, went on for too long, and got worse as time went on. Brought in some really sketchy fandom people, too.