I'm not actively looking to buy anything right now but I'm moving my want list over from the old Arena so I can update it.
G1
Earth Ponies
Confetti (upgrade, either version)
TE Bright Eyes
TE Tic Tac Toe
Cherry Treats (with a white body)
Raspberry Jam
Cranberry Muffins
Raincurl
Caramel Crunch
Mint Dreams
Lemon Treats
TAF Munchy
MGR Diamond Dreams
Nice N Spicy
Good Weather
MO Napper
10th Birthday Pony
Pink Dreams Soft & Sleepy Newborn with accessories
Unicorns
Majesty (upgrade)
SS Ribbon
Red Roses (I want to rehair, so more interested in condition of body than hair)
Pegasus
Peppermint Crunch
Ringlet
Bluebell (UK flower pony)
Babies
NBBE Gusty
NBBE Ribbon
Graffiti
Baby Stella
Baby Explorer
Baby Mischef
Baby Nightsong
NBBE Half Note
Li’l Sweetcake
Sugarcake
Gametime
Dancing Butterflies
Milky Way (w/ blue stripe not blue forelock)
Sugarberry
Lemon Drop (UK pose)
Cherries Jubilee
Buttons
Hopscotch
Honeycomb
Candy
Licorice
Racer
Speckles
Li’l Cupcake
Flutters / Wingers
Lady Flutter
Cool Breeze
Moon Jumper
Starry Wings
Sun Glider
Whirly
Big Brothers / Mountain Boys
Tux ‘n Tails
Sunburst
Ice Crystal
Thundercloud
Lightening
Nirvanas (best condition possible)
Argie: Christmas Pony, Baby Ribbs, Lickety Split (white with chocolate ice cream symbol and green with white ice cream), White Snuzzle,Yellow Snuzzle, Rainbow Gingerbread, Baby Posey (cotton candy pose), Baby Sparkler (light body), Love Melody, Sugarberry, Masquerade, Paradise, Novia, Truly
Brazilian: Sitting Bow Tie, Baby Gusty, Gusty (collectors pose), Truly
Greek: Sunbeam, Baby Cuddles (any one)
Dutch: Diary Pony
Italy: Polly, Jenny (or the Macau version), Unicorno (walking pose), Blue Lickety Split
German: Nightlight, Raindrop, Baby Hopscotch, Baby Buttons, Baby Honeycomb, Baby Cherries Jubilee, Baby Schlummerlein
Peru: unicorn Baby Bowtie, Baby Medley, unicorn Bowtie
Spain: Piggy Frestia (white strawberries), Piggy Algodoncete, Piggy Rayito, non-piggy Peachy (blue hair)
Mexico: pegasus Baby Blossom
Dolly Mix
Apple Jack
Snuzzle
Powder
Blue Belle
TicTacToe
Cherries Jubilee
Glory
Medley
Gusty
Lemon Drop
Cotton Candy
Sundance
Firefly
Blossom
Minty
I also need the pamphlet
Playsets and Accessories
Pretty Parlour: name cards (Blue Bell, Lemon Drop), pink blanket, pink standard comb
Waterfall: playset, curlers, pink handle comb
Baby Bonnet School of Dance: playset, cards, tiara
Satin Slipper Sweet Shoppe: one turquoise light, 3 yellow hearts for the lights, Scoops' apron.
Paradise Estate accessories: only 1 speaker
Perm Shoppe accessories: only pink mesh cap, 3 large curlers & 3 small curlers, pink smock, pink towel
Catnip kitten (white w/ green stripes)
Snowball puppy (white and pink)
Rock-a-bye Bed accessories: only alarm clock, diary, pillow
Scrub-a-dub Tub: only the rubber duckie and star sponge
Sweet Dreams crib and accessories
UK schoolhouse: only the following accessories *UPDATE*
UK kitchen: only yellow breakfast bar w/ shelves and dishrack, pink rack for inside oven
Sleepover party pack accessories: only teen & screen magazines, rainbow hop game & spinner, pony cookies, telephone, milk, record player, record & sleeve
Merry Treat's xmas tree comb
Twin stroller (purple)
BBE Highchair (purple body with yellow tray)
Blankets w/ hearts (any colour)
dishes and spoons (any colour)
baby pony stroller (the one that harnesses to the mom with the rainbow strap)
Ponywear
Satin ‘n Lace garter and ring, Tux’s bowtie
Neon Lights: yellow bow shoes, belt
From the Designer Collection
Lights, Camera, Action (boa, shoes only)
Pageant Queen
Hearts and Candy
Sun and Fun
Sunday Stroll: both purses and baby wear
Prima Ballerina (tutus, legwarmers)
Ready for Rainbows (baby boots only)
Jumper and Snowsuit (just the pals)
Elephant and Party Dress
Lion suit and Sleepwear (I have the nightgown and night cap, need the rest)
Hit the Slopes
Pony Holiday (hat and suitcase)
Rockin' the Night Away
Abra-Ca-Dabra
Academy Award
Pony-Naut
Galaxy Glamour
In the Centre Ring
Milk ‘n Cookies (have the nightshirt, need the rest)
Merchandise (I'm still working on the merch. sections.)
Radio shaped like Sunbeam (preferred working)
Butterick mini plush patterns (xmas wreath)
McD charm bookmarks: Snuzzle, Blossom, Bluebelle,
Stampers (any, but especially those with pony-shaped handles)
Colouring books
UK Annuals
Storybooks
Stickers
Notepads/ writing sets
PVC figures
Cherries Jubilee or Bubbles pony-shaped hot water bottle
Applejack air freshener
MOC Birthday cake candles (same mold as petite ponies)
Any G1 party favours / party supplies except the Glory napkins
Mini soap in boxes
Basically anything with early G1 art. Please, no puzzles.
G2
Since these ponies were re-released so often I've listed them by year here, using SweetTune's G2 guidebook as a guide.
1997
Petal Blossom's hat and ladybug clip w/braid
1999
Princess Crystal's wizard hat and crystal ball (accessories only)
Princess Trixibelle (w/ accessories)
Lady Moonshine (w/ accessories)
Lady Cupcake
Hip Holly
2000
Bright Bramley (w/ accessories)
Baby Tickle Heart
Baby Twinkles
Baby Polka and Dot (w/ accessories)
Baby Honeyberry
Baby Drifter and Dreamer
Baby Sweetheart and Trueheart (w/accessories)
Prince Firefly
Princess Golden Light
Giggle Garden Nursery w/ Little Flitter (MOC or complete)
Royal Castle (w/ accessories or just the castle is ok too)
2001
Baby Petal
Baby Nosy and Click
Baby Study and Play
2002
Melody (I don't care if the batteries are dead)
Muse (I don't care if the batteries are dead)
Magic Diamond Glow
2003
Gardener (w/accessories)
Puff (w/ accessories)
Miss Painter (w/ accessories)
Miss Teacher (w/accessories)
Autumn
Twins Rumba and Samba
Twins Sunshine and Sunny
Twins Rose and Lily
Merchandise:
G2 Promo poster ("they're back" with Light Heart)
Wastebasket
Pony-shaped stampers
Stickers
Badges and Pins
Magazines
Coin purse/wallet
G3 (all can be loose unless otherwise specified)
Jingle Jangle w/ accessories
Silver Rain
December Poinsettia
Jolly Lolly w/ accessories
Mittens 2's hat only
White Pony Project
TAF Pony Project
Rainbow Bubbles
Snowdrop Swirl
Lovely Ladybug w/ accessories
Fun Fairy w/ accessories
Whimsical Winter w/ Pinkie Pie outfit
Bubble Bath Time with Sweetsong outfit + accs
Build a Pony Cinderella outfit (the original Disneyworld one)
Plush
Any Sweetberry plush except the three yarn hair versions and the large crane game version
Merchandise (I'm still working on this section)
Anything with Sweetberry on it. ;D
Wallets
Stickers
G4
Starswirl
Funko Pop Doctor Whooves and Bubbles
any merchandise (we don't get much in Canada) especially with Twilight Sparkle or Doctor Whooves
2014 Calendar (we likely won't get this in Canada and I'd love one)
Blind Bags
Lovestruck
Golden Harvest
Pudding Pie
Meadow Song
Tea Love
Sprinkle Stripe
Applebloom
Honeybelle
Golden Grape
Apple Dazzle
Shining Armour
Zecora
Groovin' Hooves Set
Elements of Harmony Friends
Cake Family babysitting fun
Other stuff I collect
Breyer stablemates, especially the Arabian molds and older molds.
Stickers
Anything Unicorns
Carosel, rocking horse, and unicorn Christmas ornaments
Rubber duckies